MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Suleman
About
- Username
- Suleman
- Joined
- Visits
- 100
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Sharks are cool and cute. Also predators, of course, but no more evil or cruel than any other. Please don't make shark week about spreading misinformation about them.
-
Third card: Sea Legs Commander version: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/abe-and-bea-co-captains
-
@jpastor It's been an interesting experience, but I'll drop out of the league now.
-
@cadstar369 Amaya seems a bit odd for a commander. Since it's a highlander format (only one copy of each card), making use of that ability would require multiple players running the same card, which you can't really plan around. It's arguably broke…
-
Original card: My version: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/neel-innovative-engineer-1 It's probably too powerful, but I had trouble fitting all the text and didn't feel like tweaking it any more.
-
@Arceus8523 Huh, I tried searching on Scryfall, but didn't find that one. Good to know!
-
Original card: https://scryfall.com/card/hml/42/black-carriage My version: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/the-black-carriage-3 There are currently no published vehicle commanders, so this might be a bit of a stretch.
-
@KorandAngels There are some pretty extreme life gain effects out there, and this guy has enough power that it can leech quite a bit of life by itself. It's pretty powerful. One big problem is "40 or more life". Some formats have different startin…
-
@hileandr Yeah, I figured these cards wouldn't be super well-graded. Eras were my attempt at making symmetrical effects that would scale up in an interesting way in multiplayer games. I love symmetrical effects, they're a very challenging design sp…
-
Oof. 4:0? And here I thought I had a pretty good bunch of cards. Honestly, without any feedback, it's kind of difficult to know how to improve. I do realize that these are judged subjectively and Commando's cards might have just been exceptional, bu…
-
@Arceus8523: It's not quite the same effect, since those would count EVERY instant or sorcery spell the player has cast that turn, not just the ones on the stack. E.g. You cast sorcery 1 before combat, then an incant spell after the combat. Your ve…
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/serenity-in-conformity
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/split-personality-7
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/split-personality-7
-
Idris Elba as Teferi, at least the older version, seems like a pretty natural choice. He has the right look and body type and the proper air of authority. Garruk would need a big, wide body builder type who can be gruff and menacing. Jason Momoa mi…
-
@jpastor The name is pronounced "Soo-lay-munn", more or less. You can google the pronunciation if you want, I don't particularly mind. Small note: A card with the Era mechanic enter with an era counter for EACH player, so it takes 6 total mana to …
-
@hileandr Don't worry, I got what you meant. Some more cards. Note: These all share the same basic mechanic ("Era"), so you don't need to spend as much time on each card individually. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/age-of-strife-2 https://mtgca…
-
@hileandr Thanks again! My notes: Careful Chronarch is actually a twist on an existing card. I tried to figure out how to make it cheap enough to actually play but also with more interesting decisions to make. "The League" in the flavor text is …
-
Here's another batch of cards. These are older cards and not really related in any way, except they're all blue. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/careful-chronarch https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/absorb-essence-3 https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/phant…
-
I'm interested, though I only briefly glanced at the previous competition, so I'm not very familiar with it.
-
@hileandr Once again, thanks for the feedback! I noticed you getting annoyed with ads while browsing the web. I highly recommend getting an adblocker extension (e.g. uBlock Origin for Chrome). I can't imagine surfing without one. Yao Buke Ji is ju…
-
Thanks for the video commentary once again! All of the featured cards were my attempts at making 3-mana 5-color creatures. Some of them felt a bit weird and forced because of that, I was trying to see how far I could push the concept. Do note that …
-
I made another bunch of cards that could use your feedback. When you have the time! Note for context: All of these cards are 5-colored, and five of them are 3-mana cards. I'd like the casting costs to remain as they are. https://mtgcardsmith.com/v…
-
Thanks for the feedback! Some notes from my end: For such a popular franchise, there is surprisingly little fanart or even official art out there for Borderlands. So I had to use subpar pictures for some of them. Sorry about that. Amara and Axton…
-
Thanks for the feedback! For context, all of my cards featured in the video are based on the Borderlands video games. The Bee is a personal forcefield generator that you can find in the game. I should rethink how the Shield mechanic works, it's word…
-
@hileandr I'm intriqued! I made a batch of cards based on the Borderlands game franchise, might as well go with these. Some notes ahead of time just for context: Borderlands is a wacky sci-fi action game with guns, cars and explosions (in space). …
-
@jpastor Sure, I guess. I should probably be in Division C.
-
@ShadowReign Nice art choice, I approve. Since this card doesn't specify "activated" abilities, this might lead to some confusing interactions. Things like multiple different abilities with "This creature's power is equal to [something]". Usually a…
-
@Sweda Suffering: One thing to note: "Your opponent" is a bit vague in multiplayer formats like Commander. Either the ability needs to choose an opponent or apply to each opponent. It's an interesting idea. Very annoying if it can exile a lot of cu…
-
@SPyBondPlays That seems like a very expensive fog effect, with an extremely specific setup. Fog effects are used to buy yourself a little bit of time to find your missing combo pieces and so on against aggressive decks, but this specifically requi…