Alrighty, i deleted my older entries because I've made a lot of new one mana cards in the last month.
Here are my old entries, these are also my official old entries by virtue of being a few of the only (decent) one mana cards I've made in the past:
Alrighty, now onto the new cards, starting with the non-official entries (I'm actually very bad at evaluating my own cards, so I'm probably submitting the wrong cards as official entries lol.):
Picking these was horrible and I hope never have to choose favorites like this ever again! Anyway, here are my official new entries (and honestly I might switch em up again.):
New official entry #1: Adventurer's Beginnings This was the only card I was sure I wanted to submit as an official entry, and I have no idea why. I just like like it, I guess.
New official entry #2: Four-leaf Spriteling I am contractually obligated to include this card. (Also flavor. I was very much doubting between pollination sprite and this card, but the contract compels me.)
New official entry #3: Erina, Ashiran Hero/Erina, the Guiding Light Idk if this is my best one drop, but I quite like this card, and i did make it with the intent for this contest, so here it is. I also quite like this character. (Now if only i could find the artist for Ashiran Hero)
I ended up going mostly of feeling rather than objectivity, but this challenge was great, and it made me realize how much fun it is to try and design interesting one drops. Either way, hope ya'll enjoyed at least one of my entries! (sorry for taking up this much space lol)
The song mechanic is a mechanic I made that is meant to function as a more flexible saga in a way. The song subtype gives it the following effect: (As this Song enters and after your draw step, choose a mode that hasn't been chosen. If you can't, sacrifice CARDNAME.)
The circuit challenge has ended. Here are the results of the challenge based on the number of favorites the card had and how mechanically unique they were. I hope you all had fun and if you didn't get top 3 remember, there is always another challenge that you can enter in.
Thanks so much for this contest! I'm thrilled to have gotten even a fraction of a circut point!
In the future, please refrain from judging based on favorites. Many cards by less popular smiths should have just the same chance of winning, and it should not be based on how many members were on the site on that specific day.
You may want to ping @Corwinnn to distribute circut points and close this discussion.
@Everyone I'm sincerely sorry about how I judged this contest. I am new to making a circuit challenge and should have talked to more experienced smiths and done more research on how to judge a contest. I hope this does not hurt my relationships with any of you guys. I would give first place to everyone because you put herd effort into each of your cards. I was a bit rushed due to school starting and other problems. But his is no excuse for how unfairly I judged your cards. I hope you guys can forgive me for my actions.
Comments
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/asgores-willing?list=set&set=44915
Disclaimer: Art doesn't belong to me! It can be found in google.
It's a double sided card for Sorinjace's birthday!
Edit: And another one.
If you click on the card and go to its page, you can see a story that accompanies this .
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/memnrin?list=user
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/syr-jack-the-noble-pumpkin
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/deathmark-archer
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/invoke-the-outlasting
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/trapped-on-the-mountains
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/shoemakers-gnome
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/defiant-fallbark
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/voldaren-reprobate
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/tarmagh-spellbook
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/mawumag-fetish
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/seal-of-salt
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/iron-guard-1
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/durins-4th-rank
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/dwarven-barbarian
Here are my old entries, these are also my official old entries by virtue of being a few of the only (decent) one mana cards I've made in the past:
Alrighty, now onto the new cards, starting with the non-official entries (I'm actually very bad at evaluating my own cards, so I'm probably submitting the wrong cards as official entries lol.):
Picking these was horrible and I hope never have to choose favorites like this ever again!
Anyway, here are my official new entries (and honestly I might switch em up again.):
New official entry #1: Adventurer's Beginnings
This was the only card I was sure I wanted to submit as an official entry, and I have no idea why. I just like like it, I guess.
New official entry #2: Four-leaf Spriteling
I am contractually obligated to include this card. (Also flavor. I was very much doubting between pollination sprite and this card, but the contract compels me.)
New official entry #3: Erina, Ashiran Hero/Erina, the Guiding Light
Idk if this is my best one drop, but I quite like this card, and i did make it with the intent for this contest, so here it is. I also quite like this character. (Now if only i could find the artist for Ashiran Hero)
I ended up going mostly of feeling rather than objectivity, but this challenge was great, and it made me realize how much fun it is to try and design interesting one drops.
Either way, hope ya'll enjoyed at least one of my entries! (sorry for taking up this much space lol)
. . . and new:
This was fun to make!
The song mechanic is a mechanic I made that is meant to function as a more flexible saga in a way. The song subtype gives it the following effect:
(As this Song enters and after your draw step, choose a mode that hasn't been chosen. If you can't, sacrifice CARDNAME.)
New Entries 1 & 2:
1st place: Hand of Ehn-Tog by MemoryHead
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/hand-of-ehn-tog
2nd place: Animation Vessel by Shadow123
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/animation-vessel
3rd place: Prepared Countermeasures by Ranshi
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/prepared-countermeasures
Honorable mentions: Fickle Mob by Animist
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/fickle-mob
Agent of the grave by Ral1000
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/agent-of-the-grave
Mawumag Fetish by Crawdadswelcome
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/mawumag-fetish
In the future, please refrain from judging based on favorites. Many cards by less popular smiths should have just the same chance of winning, and it should not be based on how many members were on the site on that specific day.
You may want to ping @Corwinnn to distribute circut points and close this discussion.
Congratulations to the winners.