MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
0 days of christmas tournament (voting round)
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/complete/full/2016/12/4/1480867789175802.png
Jolly olde Saint Nicholas 4.5/5
Even though I already have a Santa Claus card as champion, this card is pretty good. The artwork looks epic and its abilities matches what Santa Claus has and does in real life. (If he is real, no one really knows that)
But I don't no about the choices for land cost. It's pretty good land cost but it doesn't match the artwork. The artwork makes Santa Claus look like a swamp creature with a battle axe and the ability to have undead powers to bring elfs back from the dead and call everyone naughty. Evil Santa Claus is what I would call it but there is no swamp land in the cost only plain,mountain, and forest. Unless that mountain cost is santas evil side then that explains it.
This time it's a time limit of 25 days. Right now it's 22
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/complete/full/2016/12/4/1480867789175802.png
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/complete/full/2016/12/4/1480893420660138.png
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/complete/full/2016/12/4/1480894229594342.png
Ajani claws 4.5/5
The ability to give presents is cool. And the land cost is reasonable, you say you edited the artwork yourself . So instead of asking the author a question I will ask you. There is a big red lump in the middle of the card's artwork do you know what that is? Is it santas sack (ajanis sack)
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/spirits-of-christmas
Spirits of Christmas 4.8/5
Old fashion artwork, 3 abilities for 3 spirits of Christmas, and decent land cost and hp
Though I would have made 3 cards one for every spirit because if its spirits of Christmas with an s it's more than one creature. Unless you did not know how many cards you could make like some of the other smiths have been asking then my answer is that you can post almost as many cards as you want until the 25th of December. Just don't spam. So take another try if you want.
Oh, opportunity lost...
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/festive-arbor
2.333333333/5
You don't put a Christmas counter on it, so you can't take a Christmas counter off it, so you can never use the abilities, but you have spectacular art and a fun name.
Also, that's not an official rating, but I didn't want you to explode before @GeekBabe123 could rate your card, so you might want to wait for an official rating!
Festive arbor 3/5
I agree with corwinnn because you gain a Christmas counter but if you don't put a Christmas counter on festive arbor then festive arbor can't do those abilities but if you did it wouldn't be that bad of a card. This card is an example of not enough detail in the card's abilities and both of you probably know that. Sorry if I'm late I was a bit busy.
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/dark-gift-1
Dark gift- 5/5
Believe it or not but this is actually a Christmas card, first of all it mentions gift in the name and Christmas has gifts, lots of them some good some bad. Second of all this card allows you to create a 3/3 corupted elf and elfs are involved in the Christmas season making presents for Santa.
Other than that this card is really good with nice artwork and several choice abilities that would be useful in combat. But I don't like how you draw 2 cards and lose 4 life but that's sopposed to be an ability otherwise it would not be a dark gift and like in the card flavor text, you'll get power...for a price. It proves that you intentionally put that there.
There's no reason to but ok.
XD