MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
cadstar369
About
- Username
- cadstar369
- Joined
- Visits
- 18,483
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
By "each card creates increasingly large numbers of the same kind of creature token," do you mean 'all three artifacts have to function like some variation on Assemble the Legion', or 'artifact A creates more tokens than artifact B which makes more …
-
@V0id Eclipse Crusader's ability doesn't count tokens, so it doesn't work in token decks. Additionally, the Mentality mechanic both has nothing to do with lifegain and also is difficult to utilize without restricting one's deckbuilding decisions, so…
-
@V0id Aselth seems to swing between underwhelming and busted, with no in-between state. Her +1 and -X are both weak for five mana, especially considering how vulnerable her 3 starting loyalty is. However, if a player has any way to speed things alon…
-
I'll toss my hat into the ring with some new cards for an old ability word. Cards with the Mentality ability word have effects based on the top card of your library that also make sure that card doesn't stay on top of your library. (This is int…
-
I'll be here if/when this gets going again.
-
One mystery box please. (It's been a hot minute since I picked up my last one, so I think I'll just leave it in whatever dusty corner it's landed in. 😅)
-
@Jadefire thanks for the feedback. ? The Leech cycle and this song were the two main inspirations for Arenna. Do you think she'd be playable as a one-drop 2/1 or 2/2, or does white have so much protection on its own turn that it just doesn't care ab…
-
@Floodkiller45 The Battle Bus is rather underwhelming. As a vehicle, it lacks any abilities that could even begin to justify having a crew cost greater than its power. Looking at the other abilities, while smashing halves of Oketra's Monument and Rh…
-
Welp, Hanqiu can do naught but wait while the two of them are dragged closer to the creature. ~~~ To respond to your concerns, this campaign seems to suffer from giving the players too much freedom in an empty world, similar to many sections of Ar…
-
@Jonination Scryfall (and Gatherer) will be your best friend when trying to perfect the wording on your cards, as perhaps evidenced by how many links I threw out there. Once you find cards with an effect close to what you want, try to modify the pun…
-
Rennala, the Lunar Queen {2}{w}{u}{u} Legendary Creature – Demigod Wizard [5/3] Once each turn, when you cast a spell with mana value 5 or greater, you may draw three cards. If you do, you may cast a spell with equal or lesser mana value from among…
-
@Jonination welcome to the site & thanks for the feedback. ? Regarding Phrygian, the triggered ability is meant to be a double-edged sword for increased flexibility. While it may seem risky to use Phrygian's buff on your own creatures, consider…
-
Hanqiu is still convinced there is little to nothing he can do about the current situation, so he will continue to wait warily.
-
Hanqiu stares up for a few moments at the light show. Well, this doesn't look good, but I doubt either of us have the ability to do anything about that…what did those creatures call it? A shard? If it's incomplete, perhaps it'll exhaust itself if we…
-
Smoldering Spite triggers when the elementals damage Heju, burning them away.
-
@FireOfGolden Hanqiu will let Heju act first. If the inklings can deal at least 2 damage to each of the Shardborn Guardians, Hanqiu can both slay the Shardborn Guardians and reduce the elementals that'll spawn from their death triggers to 1/1s via S…
-
Taking note of the vines as he sets a couple supplies against the trunk, Hanqiu dismisses the notion that they might be able to climb the tree with them, as it's unlikely mere vines would hold long enough to reach whatever might be up there, and fal…
-
Grateful for the natural shelter, Hanqiu starts setting up camp for the time being. Upon noticing the strange glow, he gazes nonplussed at it for a few moments before returning to his work. "Heju, you wouldn't happen to have an inkling (pun intended…
-
@Jadefire thanks for the feedback! ? Most of the issues you brought up with Locrian definitely stem from the initial mirrored Battlebond-style partner idea I had for him and Dorian, which no longer works on a number of levels now that I'm working o…
-
I can't think of any reason to stick around, so we might as well go see what else the realm has to offer (i.e. 'explore for other interesting occurrences').
-
Hanqiu takes note of the words, but otherwise ignores them and keeps moving. Having dealt with a number of both intangible forces and similarly vague threats in his line of work, he doesn't think there's anything to fear from such hazy intent. Even …
-
Reeling for a few moments from the sudden shift in lighting, Hanqiu hears Heju call out to…someone, and decides to cautiously keep it moving until there’s more tangible evidence of whatever/whoever that might have been.
-
@Jadefire if there was a reason for making Celestial Interference's first ability an 'as' instead of 'when', I neither recall it nor was it particularly strong; perhaps I'd been annoyed by too many Elesh Norn (ONE) players on Arena that day. ? @Flo…
-
@Jadefire thanks for the feedback! ? Firestorm Pollen was originally created for a now-defunct campaign here, and while I was iffy on whether I should just turn it into Jund Everlasting Torment, I held off since it got a surprising number of favs. …
-
@Ilmarinen Hoard Mimic feels like it's caught between being strong and being effective. It's difficult to justify spending four mana on casting it if you aren't destroying at least four or five Treasures, but how often is an opponent going to leave …
-
@FireOfGolden Esia saying "Faerie permanent" instead of "Faerie creature" is relevant because of Tribal cards. Faeries in particular have two existing tribal enchantments: Bitterblossom and Faerie Tauntings, so those also count toward the three Faer…
-
@StuffnSuch thanks for the feedback! ? The wording on Spellfracture Prism feels a little wonky (mostly because it messes with the process of casting a spell), so perhaps this would work: Instant and sorcery spells with one or more targets have stor…
-
@Astrophibian please remember to give feedback on prior card(s) before posting for review, especially when presenting an edit of a previous card. That said, Esia might be one of the most cracked dual lands I've ever seen. Not only can it be fetched …
-
@bramboy99 do the cards I inline linked to in my previous comment not satisfy your question? (If they don't, then I'm afraid I don't understand what you're asking for.) For example, consider Pentarch Ward and Spectra Ward: Suppose a creature is …
-
@bramboy99 I derived that effect mainly from cards like these, which circumvent the protection they grant.