Unique and Intriguing Tiny Leader!

Hellberto

My 2° entry, Ku-Maw from Muraganda"
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ku-maw-savannah-king

Faiths_Guide

Alright I'm going to try to have finished judging by tonight (wish me luck because I leave at 5AM tomorrow morning to head out on a week vacation for skiing and other snow activities in Colorado). No more entries. Message me if you'd like to help judging.

Faiths_Guide

My idea for the next competition is going to be unique. I like to sketch and I am going to design artwork which I will upload and request that everyone make their version of a card to fit the art.

It will start out not having colors which sway the card to a specific color. The winners card will then cause me to finish the rendering to match the cards design, at least from a color standpoint. We will see how it works out! It will be my attempt at a one week competition if all goes well.

Cryptonight

@Faiths_Guide I Didn't realize it ends tonight.

I know it's too late to enter, so I'm leaving this here in case others are curious to see another Tiny Leader...
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/zurgo-zombified
(Probably very strong in the format, what with his Unearth ability - oh well.)

I think your idea for your next challenge is great - though you might get very similar entries. There might be a problem where those who submit early could argue that others copied mechanics that they posted first - causing some sort of race. You would have to be completely impartial when judging, irrespective of the order in which they were made.

I would help you judge, but I'd probably be a little biased. Would it be fair to allow participants to judge? o.0

Best of luck & enjoy your vacation.

Faiths_Guide

@Cryptonight Thanks a bunch for the comment. The contest ended midnight early this morning I am just trying to judge by tonight.

As far as people copying each other I don't think that will be to big of an issue. In general it seems like people prefer to differ from everyone else on this site if at all possible.

And Finally, no participants can help.

Thanks for the well wishes!

Gateways7

Princess Of Hearts
http://mtgcardsmith.com/display?img=1451701393694174&t=876894

Hyperborean Queen
http://mtgcardsmith.com/display?img=1451706823533711&t=941612

Faiths_Guide

@Gateways7, sorry, too late.

Faiths_Guide

So, here's what I did:


Gaelan: 7
Tisa, Into Loam (7)

CrucibleOfHate:
Disqualified, 11 Entries

Gelectrode : 8
Caln, Primal Oracle (9)
Leagadra, the Booncrafter (7)

gummyboys: 4
Carson, the Eternal Fury (4)

Suicidal_Deity: 7.5
Eyris, who Delights Ravens (8)
Shel the Infallible (7)

Damnation: 7
Orseis, Daydreamer (7)

kauyon: 7.5
Dillinger, the Kingslayer (7)
Helaina the Fallen princess (8)

Latinas: 5.6
Nari and Forndeath (6)
Yuki, Snowstorm Kami (6)
Zahara, Volcanic Royal (5)

Biblio: 3.6
Elong-Gator (3)
Little Cheese (4)
Baron Zemo (4)

koover: 7
Munti, the Little One (6)
Kimry, Master Tinkerer (8)

Corwinnn: 8
Klik-Nak-Nik (8)

IanLowenthal; 5
The Black Death (5)

Supermunkie1: 6
Assyth Jia, First Thenn (6)

cadstar369: 8
Henko the Alchemist (8)

Animist: 8
Sadaar, Nightveil Seer (8)
Gwee, Murderous Eremite (9)
Rynn, Master of Heists (7)

FangQuil: 6.3
Thormos Three-Soul (7)
Worwood, Gaea’s Champion (7)
Soryamo, Brass Beast (5)

llamalord44: 6
Regathor, Coastal Tyrant (7)
Belbe, Agent of Phyrexia (5)
Takara, Daughter of Starke (6)

Beeswax: 7.3
Adam, Prince of Ilvan + Adam, Prince Among Mice (8)
Alecto, Duke of Aspen + Alecto the Mad (7)
Baba Yaga the Curseweaver (7)

fellwynd: 5
Ra-Nai, Trained of Gods (5)

dudedaniel: 6
Crossade Motivator (7)
Gleek Goblin Saboteur (5)
Tithe Personal Angel (6)

Teacup: 7
Fiora Sprite Noble (7)

Kian_killer: 7
Delia, Cycle’s Guide (7)

FatTaft: 8
Chalaga Spell Glutton (9)
Wonder of Wonders (7)

Archaos: 8
Mara Erue the Prodigal (8)

Hellberto: 6.5
Voltan, Bright Flame Invoker (7)
Ku Maw Savannah King (6)

benw: 7
Cecil the Lionhearted (8)
Tetsu Defender of the Meek (6)

dibbydubsdubs: 7
Atraino, Ruler of Trie (7)

Kinojitsu_Asahi: 7
Hiroji the Stubborn (8)
Jumartus the Marbled Hero (6)
Fiorella the Freewings (7)

ChaseTheHuman:
Disqualified, 4 entries

SirWarriorLegend: 6.5
Glasca, Mistress of Treason (5)
Balthazar, Hallow Inquisitor (8)

leo5873: 6.6
Lalborn, Trap Artist (7)
Corwinnn Boros Battle Master (7)
Ant Man, Swarm Summoner (6)

Supermunkie1: 7
Boresh, Restless Warrior (7)

Goran-Block: 7
Blinker, Bombing Buffoon (7)

AkatsMadara: 7.6
Zaford, kingdom Protector (7)
Tub Tub the Pestered Goliath (8)
Rukesh, Mana Titan (8)

Cryptonight : 7
Cuddles, Grizzly Roofstalker (7)

Sylux: 7.6
Grazi the Scavenger (7)
Uriek, Justices Rage (8)
Thelesios Sea Champion (8)

Azeois: 6
Insar the Quickfoot (6)

Tomigon: 7
Avery Shade (5)
Elewin, Supreme Lawmage (7)
Xena, Sadistic Necromancer (9)

Faiths_Guide

I know, I went a little crazy. That is the score of each entry on a scale from 1-10 in my personal opinion. I rated based on personal preference ( ), but things like balance, ingenuity, unique and Intriguing-ness, art, flavor, etc.

It looks like... @Animist wins yet again, the numbers have spoken.

Most Entries and highest average score. Those tied for highest average score were:
@Gelectrode
@Corwinnn
@Cadstar369
@Animist
@FatTaft
@Archaos

AVG: 8

My rankings in no way reflect on how good the card is or isn't in any world other than my own mind's...

Congratulations @Animist!
Favorite on your 3 entries as well as a card of your choice (at my discretion).

Thanks for the participation everyone!

Corwinnn

Congratulations to ALL the winner and all the mentionables too!!