Post your cards here, see what others think

1…3637394142…101

Comments

  • DecaldorDecaldor
    edited May 2017
    Is there a better way to word it?
    image
    Edit: Took @Karmadragon's suggestion and @modnation675's suggestion
  • KarmadragonKarmadragon
    @Decaldor
    A better name could be "Power Struggle".
  • modnation675modnation675
    edited May 2017
    @Decaldor
    I'm working on the re-designed rules text for you. So please wait on any final changes!
  • modnation675modnation675
    @Decaldor
    I posted two options for you in your card's comments.
  • KarmadragonKarmadragon
    edited May 2017
    image
    Don't know if this is too powerful, or not powerful enough... I would like some feedback.

    Edit: Made it 4 mana, as suggested by @Tigersol
  • TigersolTigersol
    @Decaldor
    Power Struggle seems a little too powerful for its mana cost. Maybe two mana?
  • modnation675modnation675
    edited May 2017
    @Tigersol
    Perhaps. Keep in mind the wording may be different when it's edited though.
  • TigersolTigersol
    @Karmadragon
    I love the idea. Perhaps make it worth four mana. That would make it a easier card to play early game, while increasing its threat level.
  • TigersolTigersol
    edited May 2017
    @MrRansom
    The card idea is great ,but I have just have one suggestion. I think that whenever a player's dealt damage you only put one counter on it and have it be 13 (a classic unlucky number) to win. That way it would be a little harder for you to get. Otherwise you could just attack with Merit Lage in Commander and instantly win the game.
  • modnation675modnation675
    edited May 2017
    @Tigersol, @MrRansom
    Yeah, that card is fundamentally broken since you could just take damage yourself for it to take effect.
  • Archergirl2000Archergirl2000
    edited May 2017
    image

    What do you guys think of this unglued style card? Its not ment to be a serious card its just to be weird.
  • modnation675modnation675
    edited May 2017
    What are people's opinions of this card in it's current version?

    Changes Made:
    1) Uncommon to Rare.
    2) Added First Strike.

    image
  • Faiths_GuideFaiths_Guide
    Howdy:
    image
  • Faiths_GuideFaiths_Guide
    @MrRansom & @Gelectrode

    Thoughts?
    image
  • GelectrodeGelectrode
    edited May 2017
    Hello @Faiths_Guide,

    I think Avoid the Purge is realistic and handy, yet still simple. The only part I would change is the flavor text. To me, it just seems unwieldy and not very creative. What about these?

    "You can't run, but you can hide."

    "Hidden talents arise in the most dire conflicts."


    Can you please give your opinions on these two cards?

    https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/staff-of-the-animist
    https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/xanadilius-of-the-gelectrimagi
  • Faiths_GuideFaiths_Guide
    edited May 2017
    @Gelectrode
    The one I wanted opinions on was mine, Ancient Fang. But thanks anyway!
    The flavor text was meant to reference the MTGCardsmith site purge, that card was created on @squee's account so that it won't (for any reason) get purged. I think it's favorites would vanish if it did and I don't want that!
  • sanjaya666sanjaya666
    edited May 2017
    So, if someone can tell my failures about this, that would be helpful...

    image image image image image
  • Faiths_GuideFaiths_Guide
    edited May 2017
    Pushed?
    image
  • MaelstromMasterMaelstromMaster
    My first card on this site. How do you all like it?
    https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/kergu-maelstrom-born
  • KarmadragonKarmadragon
    @MaelstromMaster
    I like dragons, and most things to do with the maelstrom, so yes :)
  • sanjaya666sanjaya666
    edited May 2017
    Oh wow, how disappointing this place can be.

    Not a well known user made tons of cards = automatically ignored.

    A premium and well known user made a janky card = instantly commented and liked.

    Really....
  • modnation675modnation675
    Sorry that I haven't been checking out your cards lately @sanjaya666. I've been working on some set design and scouring for artwork.

    I'll post some feedback on your cards.
  • sanjaya666sanjaya666
    Here come the crappy remark.
  • sanjaya666sanjaya666
    @modnation675
    I'm not reffering to you. Just people in general. You shouldn't feel sorry.
  • sanjaya666sanjaya666
    edited May 2017
    Also, and the whole promote new cardsmiths crap? Promote my ass.
  • KarmadragonKarmadragon
    edited May 2017
    deleted
  • modnation675modnation675
    edited May 2017
    I can't reply this quick everybody. I'm getting more comments here before I can even start making feedback.

    I think I'm gonna start a new thread that people can ask for feedback on. Then I'll reply to as many of them as I can.
  • CorwinnnCorwinnn
    @sanjaya666 - Keep in mind, this thread was created by a guy who started three discussions and who has made 10 comments since joining over a year ago. Everyone else here just volunteers their time and efforts, and there is no promise that anyone will look at these cards and comment on them... There are a few people who do try their best to offer up opinions, but they also want to make cards and have people look at their creations as well, so they don't dedicate their time to this thread.

    Ideally, if someone wants an opinion on their card, they should comment on the one before theirs, and in this way every card would get at least one comment, and no card would get left behind.
  • KarmadragonKarmadragon
    edited May 2017
    image
    Is this card balanced?

    Edit: Took @modnation675 suggestions to make it legendary. Made it 1 more mana
  • MaelstromMasterMaelstromMaster
    edited May 2017
    @Karmadragon Thanks! I did not expect my first card to get so many favorites. Love the community so far.
This discussion has been closed.