Post your cards here, see what others think

Comments

• TheFriendlyGeek

  August 2017

  @modnation675 Yah I missed the flavor opportunity, but what other subtype would I add?
• modnation675

  August 2017

  @TheFriendlyGeek
  Performer as Faiths_Guide has made. I think it's appropriate and fits well into MTG lore.
• TenebrisNemo

  August 2017 edited August 2017

  
  
  I wanted to try out ninjutsu. What do you think?
  
  Edit: I also created this. Inspired by the defeat cycle in Hour of Devastation.
  
  
• Knightzoru

  August 2017 edited August 2017

  Here is a new link
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/black-death-dragon-abygale-2
• Sullyman

  August 2017 edited August 2017

  
  
  Any thoughts?
• Gelectrode

  August 2017

  @Sullyman, I think it should be worded as "Enchanted creature gets +2/+2 for each card in your hand."
  
  Maybe increase the mana cost to make it more balanced?
  
  Thoughts?
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/tazeem-quickbinder
• AbzanCompany

  August 2017

  Probably should have made first line "Quickbind costs W/U W/U more to cast as long as it's another player's turn," but even that may be incorrect.
  
  
• Sullyman

  August 2017

  @AbzanCompany Based on the precedent set by Defense Grid, it would read "Quickbind costs {w/u}{w/u} more to cast except during your turn." Either way, the card is really cool, I like the balance of it, but I feel like giving mono white a counter spell is pretty stronk since you don't actually need blue to use any of it.
• modnation675

  August 2017 edited August 2017

  @AbzanCompany
  I don't like the balance on the card. I think it shouldn't be available to mono white and it shouldn't be below two mana on your turn.
  
  Overall it's too powerful without the cycling ability, which says a lot about it with cycling.
• NokiSkaur

  August 2017

  I was trying to find a way to make Coal Stoker's ETB effect a keyword. I put that added cost of sacing a land, just to balance it a bit more. I honestly think this would be okay as a common, but I want to know what you guys think.
  
  
  
• AbzanCompany

  August 2017

  
• modnation675

  August 2017

  @AbzanCompany
  So everyone can just cast the same spells?
• TheFriendlyGeek

  August 2017

  @NokiSkaur Manaburst seems busted with Ramunap Excavator, Crucible of Worlds, Legacy loam lands etc.
  
  
• TheFriendlyGeek

  August 2017 edited August 2017

  Thought on this odd but friendly hand-filter spell?
  
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/live-shipping
  
• NokiSkaur

  August 2017

  @TheFriendlyGeek
  
  I don't see how being able to retrieve those lands makes it broken. Do you think Coal Stoker is broken simply because you can blink it?
• TheFriendlyGeek

  August 2017

  @NokiSkaur The card Kazandu Warcaller is not broken. The ability itself seems broken if stuck on a cheap card. Generating 3 mana with no downside is powerful. Also, it has shenanigans with Gitrog.
• modnation675

  August 2017 edited August 2017

  @TheFriendlyGeek
  I think Live Shipping is too low costed and has too good of a ceiling result.
• NokiSkaur

  August 2017

  @TheFriendlyGeek
  
  Yeah, I could certainly see it being broken on anything below a four-drop.
• TheFriendlyGeek

  August 2017

  @modnation675 @NokiSkaur i see where you guys are coming from, it generates a LOT of instant value, but it does benefit the opponent very highly as well. You take 1-5 cards, they draw 1-5 cards. modnation i see what you mean by ceiling result where there's too much value being given to players even if it doesn't shift all of it to yourself so that's a problem, but I don't want to increase the mana cost.
• modnation675

  August 2017 edited August 2017

  @TheFriendlyGeek
  I have two possible suggestions.
  
  1) Change cost to 2 CMC and ceiling to 4. (I like this one as it's very balanced, but strong!)
  2) Keep the same CMC, but ceiling is changed to 3. (This one is still too strong, but it's a fair compromise!)
  2b) If you choose #2, I'd prefer the ceiling be 2 though. One drops have a high premium compared to two drops!
• Sullyman

  August 2017

  I did a thing
  
  
• AbzanCompany

  August 2017

  
• Gelectrode

  August 2017

  Hello @AbzanCompany, I like the idea of Spellmorph! However, I would be careful making instants with Flashback. I find them hard to keep track of, and frankly kind of annoying!
  
  Thoughts?
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/syllabaxs-inquisitor
  
  
• modnation675

  August 2017

  Yes, instants with flashback should be low impact.
• AbzanCompany

  August 2017

  
• DarkstripeBlueflame

  August 2017

  Hello all,
  
  Thoughts? comments? improvements? advice? requests? I'll take em all!
  
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/account/sets/14870
• Gelectrode

  August 2017

  @DarkstripeBlueflame, it seems that your link leads to a 404 error? Maybe try again?
  
  Thoughts?
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/asha-archangel-of-bant
• SpiritDragon

  August 2017

  Opinions?
  
• AbzanCompany

  August 2017

  
• Gelectrode

  August 2017

  Hello @AbzanCompany,
  
  First of all, I would highly suggest giving feedback to the other cards posted on this thread. It makes sure everyone gets feedback, which makes MTGCardsmith better for everyone.
  
  Concerning your card, I would change the {1} mana symbol to just {W}. It makes more sense thematically, and it looks prettier too! That would be the only thing I would change about your card.
  
  Thoughts?
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/eldrak-vicar-of-vermin