I feel like the lifelink on this thing is a bit too much, especially when combined with the 'Return to library' and 'May have haste' clauses. Would four mana be too high for this to be useful? Maybe 1WW? Possibly just triple-white? I don't know... Coloured mana leads to strange balancing decisions.
Here is a card I recently entered into the Vaguely Mentioned contest. I am basing him off of the Demon from New Phyrexia that is mentioned but never portrayed. I understand his ability and cost may seem OP upon initially reading it, but I encourage you to look at my analysis description on the card page and then see what you think
Even though I don't play angels and don't really make angel related cards, there is one angel in particular that since 2016's commanders is wished had a prequel card, but seeing as how it does not, I have made one! I present to you, Atraxa, Mirrodin's Arbiter!!!
@Valoth (Cataclysmic Demon) Cool concept. But its benefit-cost-ratio is way underpowered in a world where Innocent Blood exists. Maybe lose the second condition?
@bitterwicht I was going to make the suggestion that you said, however it seems that someone must have requested the cards removal for whatever reason... So I'll make said change whenever I recreate the cards sometime
@TenebrisNemo Sweet, I'm checking what the community is interested in as we wanted to have a set of community contests to celebrate the upcoming holiday season.
Comments
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/wasteland-sprinter
Here is a card I recently entered into the Vaguely Mentioned contest. I am basing him off of the Demon from New Phyrexia that is mentioned but never portrayed. I understand his ability and cost may seem OP upon initially reading it, but I encourage you to look at my analysis description on the card page and then see what you think
Here's a card I made as a play off of the Desolation twin eldrazi
The idea is to make a red version of Demonic Pact
http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=398433
I want it to be as powerful as possible.. but I'm going to fix it if it's too good.
Also do anyone know any motive that would be better than this one, that is one that has a better full perspective of the woman.
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/merlin-evils-end
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/merlin-corruptor
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/merlin-protector
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/merlin-ally-of-fire
Any thoughts on my planeswalker?
Thoughts?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/unhallowed-pilgrim
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/toju-peace-keeper
The last ability feels overpowered, even if it had an opponent clause on it.
Hello fellow cardsmiths, in addition to the closing process of our last contest we want to know what you'd be interested in.
We're planning on starting another contest with similar prizes. But would like to know the types of cards others are or would like to work on.
Prior Contest: Classes and Curses Contest
Random Ideas:
1) Music Contest
2) Lore Contest
3) Tribal Contest (Old school fun)
4) Weekly Christmas/holiday prize contest. (4 Weeks)
Sweet, I'm checking what the community is interested in as we wanted to have a set of community contests to celebrate the upcoming holiday season.
Hopefully we can get more opinions as well.
I could do a weekly song contest with the prizes given out over a month. (4 Weeks)
The goblin's more of a fun design, but I still like it.