Beginner Duel Decks: Wild vs. Civilized

I recently saw a post on the forums (http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/comment/25190/#Comment_25190) asking people how they try to teach others magic. As soon as I read some of the replies, I realized how ineffective my ways were. I had the idea to make duel decks to help with teaching people, and I would use my own custom cards to make it a bit more fun. I would appreciate your help if you could give me ideas and/or card suggestions.

For these duel decks, I want to keep everything as simple as it can be, so once a player has "the jist" of what to do in magic, they can use these decks as practice. It is also a great way to introduce keywords such as flying, reach, etc.

The two decks I had the idea for was a mono white human deck, vs. a green/red "monster deck". The monster deck focuses on bigger creatures in play, while the human deck has a weenie playstyle, with some utility to help deal with big creatures from the other deck.

For submissions I will take anything, however the simpler designs would be better. Here are some examples I recommend looking at. Thanks!

Monsters:
~ http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/natural-habitat?list=set&set=7906
~ http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/menacing-roar?list=set&set=7906
~ http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/scorched-drake-1?list=set&set=7906

Humans:
~ http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/brightbomb-1?list=set&set=7907
~ http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/town-hero?list=set&set=7907
~ http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/restock-supplies?list=set&set=7907 (honestly the best art I could find, feel free to find a better picture :P)

Comments

  • Restock is too op.

    image
  • While I would probably agree with restock being too OP, I would like to add resupply is an instant, and that card is pretty garbage anyways. I think I will change it to you gain 5 life because I can compare it to this card: http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Discussion.aspx?multiverseid=398563
  • Wait, is this thread or making cards or judging them?
  • Either! Any feedback is appreciated.
  • here is a sample list of cards: contains cards from MTG database. this is a potential cardlist, use it or not.

    Creatures:
    Accorder Paladin x2
    Ampryn Tactician x1
    Angelic Overseer x1
    Avacynian Priest x2
    Banisher Priest x1
    Benalish Knight x1
    Benalish Veteran x1
    Blessed Orator x1
    Capashen Templar x1
    Cathedral Sanctifier x1
    Champion of the Parish x1
    Consul's Lieutenant x1
    Odric, Master Tactician x1
    Town Hero x1

    Spells:
    Aerial Manuver x1
    Armored Acsension x1
    Bar the Door x1
    Battle Mastery x1
    Brave the Elements x1
    Brightbomb x1
    Bonds of Faith x1
    Cathars' Crusade x1
    Channel Harm x1
    Commander's Authority x1
    Endure x1
    Faith's Reward x1
    Gather the Townsfolk x1
    Gleam of Resistance x1
    Increasing Devotion x1
    Restock Supplies x1
    Spare From Evil x1
    Sunlance x1

    Lands:
    Plains x22
    Secluded Steppe x2
  • Thanks for all the suggestions stormbreath! Will definitely be using some of those.

    Just curious what your opinions on this card is: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/flamegorger
    I tried to make a bomb card for the duel decks, but I might have gone a little too far. Thoughts?
  • Why not Quintuple-decks? First MTG player I taught rejected his beginner Boros deck and made me build the deck he wanted to play, which was Dimir. As odd as that sounded, he learned incredibly quickly with the choices he wanted.
  • Flamegorger is a great card. I think maybe it should have unblockable until it has a +1/+1 counter on it or something like that. I found some great art that I'll turn into a card.
  • edited March 2016
    I'm not fully sure I understand what you are saying @Gelectrode. Are you suggesting I make decks incorporating all colours?

    Thanks for the advice on Flamegorger ZendikarIncarnate, I must remind you that Flamegorger gets the counters before dealing damage, so the unblockable idea won't really work. And I really like your card!
  • Maybe Flamegorger's ability triggers when it deals combat damage to a player. Also, flip the 2 and the 4.
  • I would make sure to use http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/kenny-mccormick-8?list=set&set=10432 as your main card for the white weenie deck
This discussion has been closed.