MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Unique Planeswalker Contest
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/essence-of-serra
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/avir-metalloid-mercenary
@GageEvan thanks for your entry, but your card has some problems. Flatfish commented on your card. Please check it out!
Can this be from a previous contest...?
Welp, now I've got another planeswalker to make a story out of (and basically somewhere along the lines something screwed up for him and he found that his powers are dwindling, and therefore resorts to less than plesant means of sustaining his power, might make a version of him that's a black-blue which wouldn't have any easy way of recovering his loyalty)
Honorable mentions
"Jace, Dualistic Detective" by @FangQuil
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/jace-dualistic-detective-1?list=user
^I like the concept of Light/Dark!
"Mrat, the Contractor" by @Lujikul
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/mrat-the-contractor-1?list=user
^I like the card that messing with your life dangerously! I want to pump up Death's Shadow to 12/12!
Also, there are many planeswalkers that need to interact with other cards that have custom mechanics/subtypes. I'm sorry for people who making those cards. I couldn't judge them. As long as I can't know how widely that mechanics can be expanded, it isn't possible to estimate those card's power. But they are very creative and interesting to see!
-------------------------------------------
- 5th place
"Jerune, Eye of the Coast" by @Animist
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/jerune-eye-of-the-coast-1?list=user
^I think 2 mana card that let you draw two or more cards is a bit overpowered. But I like the way it gains loyalty and the name are telling its character!
- 4th place
"Essence of Serra" by @Gelectrode
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/essence-of-serra?list=user
^Fun idea! And I like the flavor.. No one knows where actual Sera is. It's making Sera's story mysterious!
- 3rd place!
"Garruk, One with Nature" by @milanaarz
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/garruk-one-with-nature-2?list=user
^I think it is a bit weak, but I like how it forces you difficult decision when to activate 2nd or 3rd ability. I think it's fun!
- 2nd place!!
"Anastasia, the Darkheart" by @Termite1
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/anastasia-the-darkheart-1?list=user
^Cool way to gain loyalty. Discarding is a cost, but black is good at turning it into advantage. Repeatable killing ability seems powerful. But considering that you need to protect her 1 turn, and its cost, I think this is balanced!
- 1st place!!!
"Ahau, Eternities Dweller" by @Flatfish
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ahau-eternities-dweller?list=user
^It can protect itself and gain loyalties at the same time. All ability can interact with each other, if you can use 2nd ability well and predict what happens next. If an opponent's library is few, you can go just for milling. Very strategic card!
-------------------------------------------
There are many other good cards that I want to show, but I'll end this around here. If you want to hear my thoughts about your card, please feel free to send me message or reply to any of my disqus comments. I'll reply as much as I can. Thanks for all participants! I hope you enjoyed as much as I did!
Don't feel bad for me or I kill you.
How we gonna teach you not to make those obnoxiously long blank comments?
Not ever.
Perhaps reverse psychology? Could you please post another obnoxiously long comment filled with mostly nothing?
YOU CANNOT STOP ME!