MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Who wants to make a FOUR COLORED COMMANDER???
Hey, it's llamalord44! This contest is super simple and super easy! All you have to do is make a 4 color Commander! Judging will be based off of simple guideline (down below).
What I will be looking at (Since I'm a gymnast, I'm used to a system of scoring where you start at a 10.00. You can get bonus points and deductions.) -
1. Is the artists name on it? (I screw up with this all the time actually, but still) If the artwork used has no author shown, put 'Author Not Found' or something like that so I know you checked - minus 0.5 if forgotten
2. Creativity - Lack of creativity can subtract up to 3.00 from your score, but can also get you up to 2.00 in bonus points!
3. Originality - If I can clearly see that it is based off of something else to an extreme point, you will get 2.50 off.
4. Balance - If the card is not balanced and is too good or bad (don't worry, I won't be mean with this) I will take off up to 1.00
The prizes are these -
1st Place - 5 favorites of your choice, a follow from both of my other accounts, and a trophy card made for you
2nd Place - 3 favorites of your choice, a follow from one of my other accounts, and a trophy card made for you
3rd Place - 3 favorites of my choice and a trophy card made for you
4th and 5th Place (Honorable Mentions) - 1 favorite of my choice
Good luck everybody and have fun! ;D
What I will be looking at (Since I'm a gymnast, I'm used to a system of scoring where you start at a 10.00. You can get bonus points and deductions.) -
1. Is the artists name on it? (I screw up with this all the time actually, but still) If the artwork used has no author shown, put 'Author Not Found' or something like that so I know you checked - minus 0.5 if forgotten
2. Creativity - Lack of creativity can subtract up to 3.00 from your score, but can also get you up to 2.00 in bonus points!
3. Originality - If I can clearly see that it is based off of something else to an extreme point, you will get 2.50 off.
4. Balance - If the card is not balanced and is too good or bad (don't worry, I won't be mean with this) I will take off up to 1.00
The prizes are these -
1st Place - 5 favorites of your choice, a follow from both of my other accounts, and a trophy card made for you
2nd Place - 3 favorites of your choice, a follow from one of my other accounts, and a trophy card made for you
3rd Place - 3 favorites of my choice and a trophy card made for you
4th and 5th Place (Honorable Mentions) - 1 favorite of my choice
Good luck everybody and have fun! ;D
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Couldn't find author of art- Just got source
Anyway, offering "a follow from both of my other accounts" as a prize is against site rules, I'm pretty sure. Even if it isn't, it's essentially the definition of gaming the system.
--TO--
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/arcanum-unbound-1?list=user
So that there is no confusion, there is an official site-wide contest going on right now that is asking the same thing that you are - 4-color commanders. It's part two of an ongoing contest (LINK HERE) that's been forecasted for months. This is a fine idea for a contest but your timing frankly couldn't be worse. Sorry, friend.
As to @strongbelieves 's comment, check the Forum Guidelines in regards to rewarding contest participants.Technically you can only offer 1 follow since you're only one member. Hope this helps clear things up.
And just for informational purposes, yes, banning is a thing, but it's not something we take lightly. I believe we've only banned one person that wasn't a spammer, and that person REALLLLY deserved it!
XD
Here's the ones from the other contest: