Remake a Whymtgcardsmith Card

Comments

• Faiths_Guide

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  New_________________________Original
  
  
  Whu-huh XD
• AustinSmith

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  
  
  Link to original here: http://whymtgcardsmith.tumblr.com/post/151586146070/so-so-close-to-working-a-for-effort
• IanLowenthal

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  Original
  
  
• IanLowenthal

  November 2016

  Remake
  
  
• MaverickGV

  November 2016

  are we allowed to remake old cards of ours that were on whymtgcardsmith?
• Faiths_Guide

  November 2016

  @MaverickGV
  (I hope so.) XD
• TrippleBoggey3

  November 2016

  @Faiths_Guide, @AustinSmith, @IanLowenthal, You must post the original card.
• Faiths_Guide

  November 2016

  K
• MaverickGV

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  Original featured exactly one year ago (Provides was supposed to mean "spells you cast cost {1}{r} less to cast" but that is super broken):
  
  
  Remake.
  
  
  Also yes I deleted the original.
• IanLowenthal

  November 2016

  @TrippleBoggey3 I did! It's in the comment directly above my entry.
• TrippleBoggey3

  November 2016

  Bump
• LyndonF

  November 2016

  Original: http://whymtgcardsmith.tumblr.com/post/152921186116/its-balanced-because-its-sorcery-speed
  Remade :http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/leaning-tower-1
• unicornsareevil13579

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  Original - OP
  
  
  Remake - Less OP
  
• Kinojitsu_Asahi

  November 2016

  Original:
  
  
  My version:
  
• Nicholas_Bolas

  November 2016

  WhyMTGCardsmith is a humorous site. So I decided to remake a card still humorous, just making more sense.
  
  Original: http://whymtgcardsmith.tumblr.com/post/139258808780/judge-my-opponent-isnt-running
  
  My version: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/charles-advocate-of-war
  
  I think you'll agree that this card pretty much embodies WMTGCS.
• TheClayKnight

  November 2016

  @Nicholas_Bolas while I think you preserved the essence of the card and WMTGCS itself in your new version, I think you misunderstand what "making more sense" means.
• Nicholas_Bolas

  November 2016

  @TheClayKnight So does everyone else on WMTGCS.
• Corwinnn

  November 2016

  Where's that Drum Roll guy?
  XD
• unicornsareevil13579

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  I think some subtle differences is that mine has less elves
  
  
  
  
• unicornsareevil13579

  November 2016

  Sorry i couldn't tell what the name was.
• Wackosaru

  November 2016

  Go elves
• unicornsareevil13579

  November 2016

  I think the first one spawned more elves but it costs a lot more as well.
• Nicholas_Bolas

  November 2016

  Check it out! My remade version of a WhyMTGCardsmith card got on WhyMTGCardsmith itself! I'm so frickin proud!
  http://whymtgcardsmith.tumblr.com/post/153281334313/keywords-within-keywords-and-im-pretty-sure-it
• unicornsareevil13579

  November 2016

  Ummmm congrats?
• KrampisZman

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  
  
  Infect on Melons.
  
  Probably also belongs on WhyMTGCardsmith...
• TrippleBoggey3

  December 2016

  I think ill make this ongoing instead, okay?
• KJMartin

  December 2016

  bump
• KJMartin

  December 2016

  b
  u
  m
  p
  y
• MrRansom

  December 2016