Commander 2017, Anyone?

Comments

• KJMartin

  December 2016

  @Faiths_Guide
  Oh, no, I thought I only said 3 entries max, so thought you were just putting those down there for people to see...
  
  And while I was writing that it was like, half past 12 or something where I live so I probably made a few mistakes.
• Faiths_Guide

  December 2016

  @KJMartin
  I'm not put out about it!
  Just commenting.
• KJMartin

  December 2016

  Ah. I think this is the last time I'm going to be giving feedback on every card anyway - it takes a LOOONG time.
• Faiths_Guide

  December 2016

  @KJMartin
  I can imagine!
• kltmtg29

  December 2016

  For my favorites I choose:
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/mindwrack-titan-1?list=set&set=10746
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/drahkk-beserk-commander?list=set&set=10746
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/evolution-10?list=set&set=10746
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/fear-14?list=set&set=10746
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/valley-of-kings-1?list=set&set=10746
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/pentad-prism-1?list=set&set=10746
• TastyCheez

  December 2016

  @KJMartin favorite whatever cards I own that you wish to.
• KJMartin

  December 2016

  @Beeswax, @kltmtg29, and @KarmaDragon
  As well as @MaverickGV, @VSSS, @TastyCheez, @ThefriendlyGeek, @Gelectrode.
  HERE IS YOUR, EXTRA-SPECIAL, TROPHY!!!
  
  
• TheFriendlyGeek

  December 2016

  Thanks @KimJongMartin and congrats winners!
  
  I'd like these favorited:
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/culan-aquatic-behemoth
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/santa-claws-miracle-ruiner
• MrRansom

  December 2016

  @KJMartin, I did read the rules. I just misunderstood.
  I thought because you wrote "DONE! DON'T MAKE THESE!" you meant we shouldn't make something that had been made before i.e. an enemy-pair colored Legendary Creature commander.
  So I didn't make an enemy-pair colored Legendary Creature-- you readily admit that there hasn't been a WB Planeswalker designed specifically for commander, which is what I made. I am sorry I was not following the rules, I hope you can understand how I interpreted them. Though I do not expect that to change the validity, or lack thereof, for my entry.
• KJMartin

  December 2016

  @MrRansom
  Oh...Oh...Sorry.
  I did put under it:
  " So, either make a colorless, five-colored or two-colored ally commander, geared for multiplayer play! "
  
  Er...Sorry.
• MrRansom

  December 2016

  Two-colored ally commander:
  
  
• KJMartin

  December 2016

  Okay, but this has already ended. Nice card anyways.
• MrRansom

  December 2016 edited December 2016

  @KJMartin, I know it's over. But I just wanted to show you that I am capable of following rules and designing a card within the parameters of your contest.
  
  Also, I really appreciate that you have feedback on every entry. Many judges don't do this, but participants really like when it happens. So, thank you.
• pewnd

  December 2016 edited December 2016

  
  
  "In body and mind, I am Selesnya."
  
  (Oh, noticed it closed. Oh well, I'm happy with this card anyways )
• unicornsareevil13579

  December 2016

  @pewnd why not just have "gain life equal to the number of +1/+1 counters." And increase the cost. Since green often puts counters on creatures.
• pewnd

  December 2016

  @unicornsareevil13579 it's difficult for an EDH deck to optimize it's use of token generation and +1/+1 counter generation. Those are often two different types of G/W strategies. The experience counters allow him to remain relevant after he dies a few times.