MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
What's Your Most Popular Card?
Just thought I'd start a chat room on the topic.
This is mine. It's also the only card I've ever made that's been featured.
This is mine. It's also the only card I've ever made that's been featured.
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Here's mine:
Only regret is the artwork...
I still like it as a card tho.
And, with Devilish Pact, can't you just edit the artwork?
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/sporehost-spinner
I was very happy with how it came out.
Too old to edit... Also, I was simply unable to find any others I thought suitable.
Don't know if this is my "runner-up" or not, but it's my only other featured.
-For a Price-
(Guess I have a thing for Red.)
It was favorited by a lot of people, but not Chargingbadger
He did like the card though
LOL. Just post a set, why not?
I've never understood entirely why it was so popular. I mean, I know's it's a great card for Bant, but still, it just always perplexes me.
Maybe I'm missing something - was Duskcast Infiltrator that complex? Doesn't the active player always have priority on an empty stack? Maybe I'm overlooking the obvious...
Maybe the more interesting question would be "which card do you wish was your most popular?"
And @DomriKade you're not missing something. Mind you, You Art of Benevolence and Eldrazi Unlife both seem pretty damn OP too...
This ties in to the examples you picked (which are all great cards by the way). I personally find beauty in elegant solutions to complex problems. What makes your chosen cards so interesting are the accessibility of the mechanics and the simplicity of the layout. The joy of card creation isn't always in building mazes; sometimes it's in untying knots. Plus, the growth process comes from seeing an idea, responding to it and then figuring out how to make it better. Hopefully, when we make unintentionally silly, too-powerful things from time to time we're doing so in an effort to improve. I'll take intricacy over brute force in my custom cards just about any day of the week... some days are just for smashing face though.
Well, didn't mean to pontificate about this but here we are.
Anyways, here's my most popular - http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/crucible-of-hate
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/groveform
Celyndria, Fae Knight
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/celyndria-fae-knight-4?list=user
These two are currently tied for my most popular:
Golden Tear
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/golden-tear?list=user
Serum Spotter
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/serum-spotter-2?list=user
Still in love with the artwork
I feel that the card itself doesn't do the art justice.
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/bump-in-the-forums
Not sure if this is still something that happens on forums, I haven't been on this site for a while
It is not my favorite card though... That would have to be one of these three:
Or maybe not. I don't know. It's like I'm picking between my children. But those are three of my favorites.
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/derpitus-mind-boggled-worm?list=set&set=16309
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/portal-of-the-cosmos?list=set&set=16309
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/sungate-lions?list=set&set=16309
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/brachec-winnower-of-all?list=set&set=16309
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/addled-goat-1?list=set&set=16309
Can I add your Moody Bidoof in CS17 set?
Thanks to all of you for approving my cards.
Thanks!
I commented on your Heavyweight Housecarl. Please check it out!
In response to @DomriKade: I don't know if I wish these cards were my most favorited, but some cards I wish were more popular are:
I wonder if this would be as popular if I had just given it bestow.