MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
No.1 Cardsmith Challenge 4
THIS IS AN ONGOING COMPETITION. NO NEW PARTICIPANTS ARE ALLOWED.
Welcome to the second last stage of this competition. Congrats to all of you who have made it this far as this has been a very long process to get here. Those who are still in the running are Lujikul
@TrippleBoggey3, @IanLowenthal, @Corwinnn, @Gelectrode, @Faiths_Guide, @dashdo101, @Arceus8523, @kltmtg29, @KimJongMartin, @TasyCheez, @MaverickGV, @TheFriendlyGeek, @Tutlaschk & @thenightbringer.
Now the there is one area I have not covered yet and will be the main focus of this task. Legendary Lands!! Now because everyone keeps getting confused I will say this. YES ALL TYPES OF LEGENDARY LANDS ARE ACCEPTED. The point of this contest is to test your abilities of creating cards so these descriptions are meant to be vague. However, as usual, there are some special rules of this round.
1. NO EDITING BY PREMIUM OR NON-PREMIUM MEMBERS. Time to actually crunch some numbers. Once your entry is submitted, THAT IS IT . Editing of a card may only be approved by myself but it is time to start being careful with your entries.
2. Only land cards allowed. So no transformations, no melding, no alterations of lands. These lands can only be lands and nothing else.
3. NEW CARDS ONLY.
All other basic rules for the competition are here.
http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/2152/who-is-the-no-1-mtg-cardsmith/p1
As stated, you have 2 weeks until closing and as shown in the past 2 rounds, this close time is strict. Close for judging will occur on the 13th December .
5 CARDSMITHS WILL BEING GETTING DQ'D THIS ROUND. THIS WILL LEAVE THE TOP 10 FOR THE ULTIMATE LAST ROUND!
Good Luck and remember, create with care.
Butters
Welcome to the second last stage of this competition. Congrats to all of you who have made it this far as this has been a very long process to get here. Those who are still in the running are Lujikul
@TrippleBoggey3, @IanLowenthal, @Corwinnn, @Gelectrode, @Faiths_Guide, @dashdo101, @Arceus8523, @kltmtg29, @KimJongMartin, @TasyCheez, @MaverickGV, @TheFriendlyGeek, @Tutlaschk & @thenightbringer.
Now the there is one area I have not covered yet and will be the main focus of this task. Legendary Lands!! Now because everyone keeps getting confused I will say this. YES ALL TYPES OF LEGENDARY LANDS ARE ACCEPTED. The point of this contest is to test your abilities of creating cards so these descriptions are meant to be vague. However, as usual, there are some special rules of this round.
1. NO EDITING BY PREMIUM OR NON-PREMIUM MEMBERS. Time to actually crunch some numbers. Once your entry is submitted, THAT IS IT . Editing of a card may only be approved by myself but it is time to start being careful with your entries.
2. Only land cards allowed. So no transformations, no melding, no alterations of lands. These lands can only be lands and nothing else.
3. NEW CARDS ONLY.
All other basic rules for the competition are here.
http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/2152/who-is-the-no-1-mtg-cardsmith/p1
As stated, you have 2 weeks until closing and as shown in the past 2 rounds, this close time is strict. Close for judging will occur on the 13th December .
5 CARDSMITHS WILL BEING GETTING DQ'D THIS ROUND. THIS WILL LEAVE THE TOP 10 FOR THE ULTIMATE LAST ROUND!
Good Luck and remember, create with care.
Butters
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
A singular entry (per smith) without revision.
It appears I was wrong?
Sorry @TastyCheez.
@KimJongMartin, The competition is ongoing but this is a new challenge.
Sorry as well @Lujikul.
Hope you like it!
Only real issue is that it is "strictly-better" than a basic land (of either relevant type).
WotC tries to stay away from that as best it can, usually giving it a minor draw back
for being able to produce multiple types such as entering tapped. Still cool, but ya.
Yes, but the kamigawa lands give a very, very, very minor upside, that you barely ever use, whereas that land gives a VERY BIG upside.
The Eldrazi subtype should be capitalized and the Titan subtype no longer exists...
http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=2735
Also annihilator shouldn't be capitalized as keywords aren't capitalized within sentences.
@Butters can I edit my land? I want it to just add red mana to the mana pool?
Check out the set:
http://mtgcardsmith.com/user/Faiths_Guide/sets/16057
More of the backstory over here:
http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/comment/54069/#Comment_54069
I also made it Eldrazi Titan since there are other Eldrazi creature tokens, and 'Eldrazi Giant' didn't sound as good.
They are nitpicky
*thumbsup*
I like it. I think @Buttters did it purposely to kinda say 'This time, you're on your own - there's no people to help you mout balancing wise anymore!'