@modnation675 thanks for mentioning that. @Animist: I had a look at all the cards and will take my time until tomorrow about noon here in germany to think and do some research to to my best job judging your cards. Please make sure, the link you posted will lead me to the card you want to have my judgment be based on.
3st place: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/tallis-rell-and-digri?list=user by @Animist I really like it. It's a Human Beast Rebel with a great and fitting artwork. What a fun! It's a real green beast growing stronger with every land that enters the battlefield and tramples your opponents to death. And it searches basic lands for you, wich, especially in combination with landfall, is an ability I like, when thinking of all the times I got mana screwed. In late game, that might not be too important anymore, but nevertheless, I love this card.
2nd place: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ajanis-adjudicator by @nsm91It's a great and very strong card. Fits the color pie very well, taking into accont, rebels are traditionally white, as Ajani is as well. Not to mention the counter mechanic, wich is one of the most blue things, I can think of. Together with card draw or lifegain and flash, this card should be part of many decks. Really good work!
1st place: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/renegade-weaponsmith by @Ludos Very kaladeshy and therefore it deserves attention alone. A red Dwarf Artificer Rebel is very fitting and the card's ability makes this card the one that wins the game for you. All in all a great job!
Let's now have a look at the honorable mentions. It's really a pitty, there are only 3 first three places to choose for me, because, I liked so many cards. Here are all cards I really want you be honored as well:
Thanks to everyone who entered. I enjoyed this contest and all of your entries very much. Everyone not on this list, don't be sad. All your cards wer great, so no losers here, just some people who won a little more.
Comments
Just a reminder that Animist's card Krovmiri Refugee is edited since the current image upload.
Not sure if Animist is counting the new or old one as an entry! (Same link.)
3st place: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/tallis-rell-and-digri?list=user by @Animist
I really like it. It's a Human Beast Rebel with a great and fitting artwork. What a fun! It's a real green beast growing stronger with every land that enters the battlefield and tramples your opponents to death. And it searches basic lands for you, wich, especially in combination with landfall, is an ability I like, when thinking of all the times I got mana screwed. In late game, that might not be too important anymore, but nevertheless, I love this card.
2nd place: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ajanis-adjudicator by @nsm91It's a great and very strong card. Fits the color pie very well, taking into accont, rebels are traditionally white, as Ajani is as well. Not to mention the counter mechanic, wich is one of the most blue things, I can think of. Together with card draw or lifegain and flash, this card should be part of many decks. Really good work!
1st place: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/renegade-weaponsmith by @Ludos
Very kaladeshy and therefore it deserves attention alone. A red Dwarf Artificer Rebel is very fitting and the card's ability makes this card the one that wins the game for you. All in all a great job!
Let's now have a look at the honorable mentions. It's really a pitty, there are only 3 first three places to choose for me, because, I liked so many cards. Here are all cards I really want you be honored as well:
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/blueprint-smuggler?list=set&set=17653 by @nsm91
Very flavorful and fitting for Kaladesh again.
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/peema-partisan by @Flatfish It creates unicorn tokens! Do I have to say more?
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/novice-rebels by @Faiths_Guide Very flavorful, using a custom mechanic, I really like.
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/imperishable-operative by @koover Energy counter and a way to reanimate your card again and again. That's what we want and need.
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/heretical-herbalist by @Animist Revolt and morbid. Great combination and that kind of card I love to play in real life!
Thanks to everyone who entered. I enjoyed this contest and all of your entries very much. Everyone not on this list, don't be sad. All your cards wer great, so no losers here, just some people who won a little more.
You chose the cards you liked best, which means you chose right! You did a great job with judging in general too!