This is Why Mtgcardsmith

Comments

• Credius

  September 2017

  I'm not sure, but I guess none of my cards got to that list... so for now I'm safe xD
• Corwinnn

  September 2017

  :::mental note. nominate Credius for a spot on Why MTGCardsmith:::
• urtar370

  September 2017

  I'm thinking of doing this one:http://whymtgcardsmith.tumblr.com/post/162957069217/44-power-with-infect-on-turn-one-its-balanced.
• urtar370

  September 2017

  I fixed this one so that it is balanced.https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/gravelord-nito-5?list=user. I made it only have one Phyrexian mana, and added blue for balancing reasons, made it an Illusion, and the targeting sacrifice power, and I made it so that it only creates 4 skeletons if you paid life. Instead of being a */* it is a 1/1 infect that gets +1/+1 for each Skeleton you control.
• urtar370

  September 2017

  Anyone have any ideas how to do this one? http://whymtgcardsmith.tumblr.com/post/163268100543/well-this-just-made-a-lot-of-artifact-decks-happy.
• NokiSkaur

  September 2017

  @urtar370
  
  I'm the one that submitted Nito...
• Brainifyer

  September 2017

  @urtar370 I'm happy to see someone continuing my work, which I will now to try continue myself.
  
  That card in particular has a very simple but very broken ability. I'm not sure how to fix it.
• JoshVB33

  September 2017

  You could make it that you still can only activate the artifacts ability once per turn but it doesn't make it tap. still good for Artifact creature and less broken
  Just a suggestion @urtar370
• TezzeretofCarmot21

  September 2017

  Is anyone going to do *my* card on WMTGCS?
  I'll let you find it. Hint: No typos
• urtar370

  October 2017

  I think that I will now fix this one. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/alakar-human-warlord. Any ideas?
• modnation675

  October 2017 edited October 2017

  @urtar370
  Make it say "As an additional cost to cast *, sacrifice a teammate", just kidding! XD
• urtar370

  October 2017

  I remade this one https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/magnetism-weaver-1?list=set&set=24455. I made it so that you have to tap to allow your artifact creature to not tap, and you can only do it for each creature once a turn, and then you can pay [2] to untap it. I made it a 2/3 instead of a 1/2, because otherwise it would be pretty awful. I also put it in Kaladesh because of the artifacts. I just realized I forgot the Metalcraft power. Oh well.
• urtar370

  October 2017

  Well if I had put in the metalcraft ability then it wouldn't fit on the card
• urtar370

  October 2017

  I am gonna do this one now I think.http://whymtgcardsmith.tumblr.com/post/163468618047/there-is-a-whole-cycle-of-these
• urtar370

  October 2017

  I remade it:https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/deathly-barrens-1?list=set&set=24455
• Stormtide

  October 2017

  Just a reminder, Phyrexian mana isn't NECESSARILY bad. Obviously, you have to balance around it, but certain instants/sorceries that are acceptable at colorless, and colored artifacts that are flavored from Phyrexia are ok.
• urtar370

  October 2017

  I think that it is only usable in a set that takes place on New Phyrexia.
• urtar370

  October 2017

  I remade Gunpowder, which is a SORCERY that says "When this card enters the battlefield, destroy target creature."
• urtar370

  October 2017

  No one remake Natural Bond. I made it because I wanted it to get onto the blog.
• NokiSkaur

  October 2017

  @urtar370
  
  That's one of the rules on WMTGCS--no cards made intentionally bad.
• AustinSmith

  October 2017

  
• Brainifyer

  October 2017

  
  Remade my favorite whymtgcardsmith card, and one I thought had potential.
  
  http://whymtgcardsmith.tumblr.com/post/150791537315/whenever-this-creature-dies-it-dies-like-every
  http://whymtgcardsmith.tumblr.com/post/142376826872