Post your cards here. Actually see what others think.

TenebrisNemo · September 2019

@wizzart87 - I commented on both cards.

I would like to know your thoughts especially about this one, so please post your comment on it (and/or favorite it if you like it) before posting your card(s):

SteampunkDragon · September 2019

@TenebrisNemo -- commented and faved. Super interesting stuff.

This is a high-power, complicated card with drawbacks, something new for me. Is it balanced? How can I improve this kind of card?

Post a comment below/on the card page and favorite it if you like it

DrakeGladis · September 2019

Commented
I'm trying something for a challenge
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/sophia-deluca-first-mate
I need to keep it Temur

Dizzydude · October 2019

Made this for the mystery box challenge, hope y’all like it.
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/last-act

DrakeGladis · October 2019

Hem hem. Mind commenting on previous cards first @Dizzydude ? We do that to make sure that all cards actually get discussed.

shadow123 · October 2019

@DrakeGladis Commented.

@DizzyDude While your card has a cool concept, it is waaay too powerful a board wipe + a huge card draw is extremely OP. I suggest getting rid of the card draw.

This is a card I made to celebrate becoming a featured cardsmith! Is this okay?

SteampunkDragon · October 2019

@shadow123 -- commented and favorited. Awesome on getting featured!

My card:

Please comment on the card page if you want to give feedback, favorite it if you like it, and then post your own card!

shadow123 · October 2019

@SteampunkDragon Thanks! I love your card! Faved.

My card:

SteampunkDragon · October 2019

@shadow123 do you mind adding some more feedback via the card's comment section? Why do you think it's good? Thanks for the favorite.

shadow123 · October 2019

@SteampunkDragon I don’t really have anything more than say. It’s balanced, flexible, and creative. I think it’s a cool card!

DrakeGladis · October 2019

@shadow123
Commented and faved. Opinions on this?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/jacob-ruthven-dashing-rouge

shadow123 · October 2019

@DrakeGladis commented.

Next up:

DrakeGladis · October 2019

@shadow123
Commented. If/when you edit it, I will fav. Great idea. Your thoughts on this guy?
Welp. Just saw that you already commented and faved. Thanks for that. Will post again soon.

shadow123 · October 2019

@DrakeGladis Here’s the new version! Is this better?

shadow123 · October 2019

@DrakeGladis Are you going to post a card, cause I also need to post cards that I need feedback on.

DrakeGladis · October 2019

Go ahead @shadow123 . My stuff is unexpectedly delayed

Netherin5 · October 2019

@shadow123

You alredy got some criticism, but any good sac outlet and some life gain can get you a great self-mill deck. Worried about OTKs.

shadow123 · October 2019

@Netherin5 commented.

My cards:

Is Syndicate Debt Collector balanced? Does Furious Bloodstealer’s last ability work? I also feel like Furious Bloodstealer is too powerful, if that’s true, how should I reduce its power level? Should I just make it a 2/2?

Revan · October 2019

@shadow123 Syndicate Debt Collector's main ability is a little hard to understand. I like its concept though. It feels balanced to me. Bloodstealer does seem a bit powerful. I agree with your thought on Furious Bloodstealer being a 2/2. And I believe that its last ability should work fine.

shadow123 · October 2019

@Revan Commented on both. I’ll be happy to give the Captain a fave once it is edited!

This is made for the Oh the Horror contest.

Revan · October 2019

@shadow123 thanks. The Captain is updated

shadow123 · October 2019

@Revan Fave given

Keep up the great cardsmithing!

Revan · October 2019

@shadow123 you too.

Mir-151414 · October 2019

I hope this doesn't seem excessive. I think the name and ability make sense though
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/complete/full/2019/9/13/1568398748762975.png