MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Reactivation Challenge #3 - Commander Challenge by Beeswax
Reactivation Disclaimer:
1 ) An inactive challenge is chosen to be reactivated, it gets posted for new submissions with a new deadline.
2 ) The new judge cannot choose his or her own submissions as the winner.
3 ) After the winners are declared, the judge selects one participant as the next host (must be an active member).
4 ) The chosen participant chooses the next challenge that has been inactive for over 2 months. He or she hosts it as the reactivation judge.
5) The reactivation judge starts this process all over from step 1.
Second Disclaimer:
- New discussion is opened for each reactivated challenge. A link to the original challenge is put there.
- The alternate judge must send a message to original judge to notice that his or her challenge is reactivated by the alternate judge.
- The original judge has a right to take over their original challenge or to ask for it to remain open and unresolved at any time prior to a winner being declared and posted.
Original discussion:
http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/53/commander-challenge#latest
Okay. I may have lied to you. The challenge is not to make a commmander. The challenge is to make something that WORKS with a commander. Not like a combo piece, or something synergistic, but something like the Lieutenant ability from Commander 2014. Something that plays with the rules of Commander. It can be a mythic legend, it can be a common sorcery. Whatever. The prizes will be as before: provide two Mad Lib words (one for the name, one for the flavor text) and some artwork. Keep it classy, or I won't make the card.
Thank you, and good luck!
Deadline : June (6) 20, 2015
Anyway, do not provide a Mad Lib. That was what Beeswax was doing. Same as the last two Reactivation challenges - trophies for da winnahs.
Previous Entries:
- AustinSmith : Supersight
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/supersight?list=user#.VXzjeH-9KSN
- Oblivion234 : Relentless Attack / Soul Steal
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/relentless-attack-2#.VXzjd3-9KSN
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/soul-steal-15#.VXzjY3-9KSN
- Looverse : General Rimoas
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/general-rimoas#.VXzjbn-9KSN
- Damnation : Dragontide (INVALID)
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/dragontide-2?list=user#.VQdwp3-9KSM
- SirWarriorLegend : Land-Fell Titan
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/land-fell-titan?list=user#.VXzjZ3-9KSN
- Suicidal Deity : Etoliated Demon
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/etiolated-demon#.VXzjW3-9KSN
- Chairforce : Alric, Robber of the Throne
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/alric-robber-of-the-throne-3?list=user#.VXzjVX-9KSN
- Crucible of Hate : Unsteady Alliance
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/unsteady-alliance-2#.VXzkAX-9KSO
- Darkray : Sink Into Utter Chaos
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/sink-into-utter-chaos#.VTR4zSHBzGc
- RedRageMage : Decisive Move
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/decisive-move-1?list=user#.VXzjS3-9KSN
- VeteranProwler : Graven Summoning
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/graven-summoning#.VXzjSH-9KSN
1 ) An inactive challenge is chosen to be reactivated, it gets posted for new submissions with a new deadline.
2 ) The new judge cannot choose his or her own submissions as the winner.
3 ) After the winners are declared, the judge selects one participant as the next host (must be an active member).
4 ) The chosen participant chooses the next challenge that has been inactive for over 2 months. He or she hosts it as the reactivation judge.
5) The reactivation judge starts this process all over from step 1.
Second Disclaimer:
- New discussion is opened for each reactivated challenge. A link to the original challenge is put there.
- The alternate judge must send a message to original judge to notice that his or her challenge is reactivated by the alternate judge.
- The original judge has a right to take over their original challenge or to ask for it to remain open and unresolved at any time prior to a winner being declared and posted.
Original discussion:
http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/53/commander-challenge#latest
Okay. I may have lied to you. The challenge is not to make a commmander. The challenge is to make something that WORKS with a commander. Not like a combo piece, or something synergistic, but something like the Lieutenant ability from Commander 2014. Something that plays with the rules of Commander. It can be a mythic legend, it can be a common sorcery. Whatever. The prizes will be as before: provide two Mad Lib words (one for the name, one for the flavor text) and some artwork. Keep it classy, or I won't make the card.
Thank you, and good luck!
Deadline : June (6) 20, 2015
Anyway, do not provide a Mad Lib. That was what Beeswax was doing. Same as the last two Reactivation challenges - trophies for da winnahs.
Previous Entries:
- AustinSmith : Supersight
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/supersight?list=user#.VXzjeH-9KSN
- Oblivion234 : Relentless Attack / Soul Steal
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/relentless-attack-2#.VXzjd3-9KSN
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/soul-steal-15#.VXzjY3-9KSN
- Looverse : General Rimoas
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/general-rimoas#.VXzjbn-9KSN
- Damnation : Dragontide (INVALID)
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/dragontide-2?list=user#.VQdwp3-9KSM
- SirWarriorLegend : Land-Fell Titan
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/land-fell-titan?list=user#.VXzjZ3-9KSN
- Suicidal Deity : Etoliated Demon
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/etiolated-demon#.VXzjW3-9KSN
- Chairforce : Alric, Robber of the Throne
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/alric-robber-of-the-throne-3?list=user#.VXzjVX-9KSN
- Crucible of Hate : Unsteady Alliance
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/unsteady-alliance-2#.VXzkAX-9KSO
- Darkray : Sink Into Utter Chaos
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/sink-into-utter-chaos#.VTR4zSHBzGc
- RedRageMage : Decisive Move
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/decisive-move-1?list=user#.VXzjS3-9KSN
- VeteranProwler : Graven Summoning
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/graven-summoning#.VXzjSH-9KSN
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
You didn't do a bad job either. Except when no one except Tomigon knew who else was going to judge... well, no one else except myself knew, anyway. (Claps silently. Why? No one will know. Well, I dunno, either.)
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/spectre-of-life-1#.VX443ZXn-P8
True.
Side note: Had to read the comment five times before I got what you said. Mostly because of all the we's.
Check this out!
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/challenges-8#.VYIeQUvY9D0
We should put this link to every Reactivation Challenge!
Sounds like a good idea!
This challenge is now over. Judging was a tad difficult, because I saw plenty of cards that wanted you to play with a bunch of legendary creatures or dealt with the commander, and so on. I also didn't see any reasons to justify why I should ignore some cards [Unfortunately, I didn't want to in the first place.]. The list is about medium-sized, actually. [If I could rank mine, I would've put it somewhere between six and nine.]
Top Three
1. Corwinnn : Spectre of Life
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/spectre-of-life-1#.VYYZaX-9KSO
2. Suicidal_Deity : Etoliated Demon
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/etiolated-demon#.VXzjW3-9KSN
3. Looverse : General Rimoas
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/general-rimoas#.VXzjbn-9KSN
These three are the ones I felt were more versatile or interesting compared to the rest, and I honestly ignored anything I believed would push a player into jamming many legendary creatures into their deck or dealt with the commander alone.
~TROPHY~
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/trophy-15?list=user#.VYYrDZVRGP8