MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Visit MTG Cardsmith→
Discussions
Activity
Sign In
Sign In
·
Register
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Sign In with MTG Cardsmith
Sign In
Register
Quick Links
Categories
Recent Discussions
Activity
Categories
5.9K
All Categories
3.6K
Contests and Challenges
119
Sagas
842
Just for Fun Contests
717
Custom Card Sets
720
Custom Card Discussion
41
Tutorials
176
MTG Gameplay Chat
17
MTG Arena
23
News and Announcements
579
Off-topic Chat
Underrated tribal appreciation challenge - Updated rules (Closed)
«
1
2
3
4
»
Comments
modnation675
August 2018
Bump. Working on a example card to post here.
Ranshi
August 2018
@modnation675
, it just has to be an underused subtype? with another mechanic?
modnation675
August 2018
@Ranshi922
Yep, you're correct.
Ranshi
August 2018
What defines "underrated" exactly?
Ranshi
August 2018
I feel as tho slivers aren't used enough but most people would disagree and slap me with the fact that theyre op and banned.
Ranshi
August 2018
@modnation675
, would a hydra count as underrated?
Ranshi
August 2018
Also anyone someone plz use adaptability!
modnation675
August 2018
@Ranshi922
I'd say Slivers aren't underrated. But Hydras would count.
Ranshi
August 2018
Exactly what I thought!
Shadow29870
August 2018
edited August 2018
Psychic by @LastJustice ! (And a buff for illusions, specifically if used via milling. I never have seen an illusion Tribal. A good one, at least)
modnation675
August 2018
edited August 2018
@Everybody
Make sure to check out this challenge here.
http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/3797/derpy-weird-creatures-challenge-ongoing/p1
Ranshi
August 2018
@modnation675
, does a jellyfish count as an underrated creature type? I have a great idea for one!
modnation675
August 2018
@Ranshi922
Yep, that counts.
Ranshi
August 2018
Perfect! That's #10 on my list!
Ranshi
August 2018
edited August 2018
I present to you, the Jellyfish Merfolk: Reejerey of Illuminated Depths!
The ability glow by
@ChargingBadger
Ranshi
August 2018
@modnation675
, is a spellshaper an underrated one?
modnation675
August 2018
edited August 2018
@Ranshi922
Yes, I haven't even heard of one recently. Just make sure it has a tribal benefit!
Ranshi
August 2018
Oh
Ranshi
August 2018
It’s in my cards but I can’t put it here right now, tell me if it would be acceptable
modnation675
August 2018
edited August 2018
@Ranshi922
Both your Spellshaper and Jellyfish need a tribal benefit.
But they're able to win the artwork award still.
Ranshi
August 2018
ok. I cant fit a tribal benifit in either so I will make some more
modnation675
August 2018
@Ranshi922
Yeah, it's challenging, but someone recommended I add it to the rules.
It's easiest to make tribal lords in this challenge, but you can design them creatively.
Ranshi
August 2018
I am going to make a hydra that causes hydras to enter with twice as many +1/+1 counters on them.
modnation675
August 2018
edited August 2018
@Ranshi922
Cool idea. Can't wait to see it!
By the way, you might wanna join this challenge. You can use serious art, not just memes if you'd like. If you make a Chicken card, you get bonus favorites as well.
http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/3797/derpy-weird-creatures-challenge-ongoing
fiskerton
August 2018
So is tribal any subtype? Like can I do something for land creatures? I think plains and islands are very underappreciated.
Ranshi
August 2018
Oh! Does Alektorophobia count? It has a swole chicken
modnation675
August 2018
@Ranshi922
Post it and see! It probably counts.
modnation675
August 2018
@fiskerton
As long as it has an underrated creature subtype, that works. As well as a tribal benefit.
Tomigon
August 2018
Pegasus
->
Using "Two-Faced" by
@KJMartin
and "Leaderless" by
@Faiths_Guide
Rhino
Using "Charger" mechanic by
@ZendikarIncarnate
Octopus
Using "Mentality" by
@cadstar369
Ranshi
August 2018
A Psychic Jellyfish:
Psychic by @Lastjustice
«
1
2
3
4
»
This discussion has been closed.
© MTG Cardsmith.com
Comments
Yep, you're correct.
I'd say Slivers aren't underrated. But Hydras would count.
Psychic by @LastJustice ! (And a buff for illusions, specifically if used via milling. I never have seen an illusion Tribal. A good one, at least)
Make sure to check out this challenge here.
http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/3797/derpy-weird-creatures-challenge-ongoing/p1
Yep, that counts.
The ability glow by @ChargingBadger
Yes, I haven't even heard of one recently. Just make sure it has a tribal benefit!
Both your Spellshaper and Jellyfish need a tribal benefit.
But they're able to win the artwork award still.
Yeah, it's challenging, but someone recommended I add it to the rules.
It's easiest to make tribal lords in this challenge, but you can design them creatively.
Cool idea. Can't wait to see it!
By the way, you might wanna join this challenge. You can use serious art, not just memes if you'd like. If you make a Chicken card, you get bonus favorites as well.
http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/3797/derpy-weird-creatures-challenge-ongoing
Post it and see! It probably counts.
As long as it has an underrated creature subtype, that works. As well as a tribal benefit.
->
Using "Two-Faced" by @KJMartin and "Leaderless" by @Faiths_Guide
Rhino
Using "Charger" mechanic by @ZendikarIncarnate
Octopus
Using "Mentality" by @cadstar369
Psychic by @Lastjustice