DIY Commander Tournament

1…457910…14

Comments

  • ElkThinElkThin
    Are you just monkeypirate @MonkeyPirate2002?
  • DoctorFroDoctorFro
    Yea leobs end of october
  • pakasharapakashara
    I've been uploading my cards as (PCC) for Pakashara's Custom Cards and (ANA) for Anavilia which is my custom plane. Is this okay?
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    Guys, I officially switched decks and thought I'd show you this greedy mana base for the five color deck.

    Can you guess the commander? XD

    Land (37):
    Basic (5):
    1x Plains
    1x Island
    1x Swamp
    1x Mountain
    1x Forest
    Fetch lands (16):
    Flood Plain
    Bad River
    Rocky Tar Pit
    Mountain Valley
    Grasslands
    Flooded Strand
    Polluted Delta
    Bloodstained Mire
    Wooded Foothills
    Windswept Heath
    Bant Panorama
    Esper Panorama
    Grixis Panorama
    Jund Panorama
    Naya Panorama
    Evolving Wilds
    Dual lands (10):
    Legendary Dual / Custom Card
    Legendary Dual / Custom Card
    Legendary Dual / Custom Card
    Legendary Dual / Custom Card
    Legendary Dual / Custom Card
    Legendary Dual / Custom Card
    Legendary Dual / Custom Card
    Legendary Dual / Custom Card
    Legendary Dual / Custom Card
    Legendary Dual / Custom Card
    Any color lands (3):
    Command Tower
    Mana Confluence
    City of Brass
    Special Land (3):
    Reflecting Pool
    Exotic Orchard
    Forbidden Orchard
  • RanshiRanshi
    Not really...
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    @Ranshi922
    I won't spoil it early for you, but I will say it when I upload the deck.
  • RanshiRanshi
    Well... ok... are you saying you're almost done?
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    @Ranshi922
    Yeah, mainly because the deck is quick to build a reasonable version. I should have it finished within two days.

    Just giving us extra time in case we need to make revisions.
  • RanshiRanshi
    ok. then will you help me with production. maybe recommend cards or trim based on the flow chart I showed?
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    Sure, just send us another message with what you need help with at the moment.
  • MonkeyPirate2002MonkeyPirate2002
    @TheEnderDragon it’s an older card I made but that’s cool it is valid.

    My name’s something like MonkeyPirate or MonkeyPirate2002, can’t remember which one is which.
  • DoctorFroDoctorFro
    Progenitus or Horde of Notions @murtlekins
  • BorosPaladinBorosPaladin
    is it too late to join?
  • DoctorFroDoctorFro
    No
  • ElkThinElkThin
    @murkletins, whats your Untap.in?
  • ElkThinElkThin
    It's not too late @BorosPaladin
  • ElkThinElkThin
    You got an Untap.in @BorosPaladin?
  • ElkThinElkThin
    @murkletins those Duals gotta be dual type (PlainsIsland) or your going to get screwed

    Still think that's too many fetches
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    edited September 2018
    @TheEnderDragon
    I haven't made an untap.in yet. But that's because I'm still making the 60 card version of the deck right now.

    But I should be done by tomorrow most likely.

    Edit: Yes, they are dual typed.
  • MonkeyPirate2002MonkeyPirate2002
    @TheEnderDragon alright, fixed up any problems with the wording! I couldn't find the original picture, so I used a different one.

    image
  • BorosPaladinBorosPaladin
    edited September 2018
    Can I use this card as my commander:
    image

    BTW my user name is the same as my MTGcardsmith account
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    @MonkeyPirate2002
    Minor change to fix mechanical exploit.
    -----
    Whenever Shivsnab, Yidris' Cohort attacks and is not blocked, exile it and the top four cards of your library in a face-down pile, shuffle that pile, then target opponent chooses one of those cards, reveal it. If the chosen card is Shivsnab, put that card onto the battlefield face-up. Otherwise, entrap that card and repeat the process.
    -----
  • MonkeyPirate2002MonkeyPirate2002
    @murkletins Unfortunately, that change destroys the entire idea of entrap. Entrap is meant to have an element of mystery. By revealing the card it ruins the surprise. Maybe if you only revealed the card if it was Shivsnab, then that would work for me. Besides, what’s the exploit exactly?
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    edited September 2018
    @MonkeyPirate2002
    I have a possible other solution, depending on what entrap is. May you explain entrap?

    Edit: You should also always post reminder text for all custom mechanics on your card's page and here. Or at least refer to your card's page with the reminder text.
  • MonkeyPirate2002MonkeyPirate2002
    @murkletins

    Entrap: Put the card onto the battlefield face down as a 0/1 Mine artifact creature with defender and "When this creature would die, instead turn it face up and exile it. If it is a nonland card, cast it without paying its mana cost." Players may not look at the card while it is face down.
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    Okay, here you go.
    -----
    Whenever Shivsnab, Yidris' Cohort attacks and isn't blocked, exile it and the top four cards of your library in a face down pile, shuffle that pile, then an opponent of your choice chooses one of those cards, look at that card. If the chosen card is Shivsnab, you may put that card onto the battlefield face up. Otherwise, entrap that card and repeat this process.
    -----
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    @MonkeyPirate2002
    Forgot to tag you.
  • MonkeyPirate2002MonkeyPirate2002
    @murkletins what's the deal with you may?

    also, http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=451048

    It's how WOTC officially words face-down piles
  • MonkeyPirate2002MonkeyPirate2002
    Any time a card of mine says "face-down" or "face down," always assume you may not look at that card unless otherwise specified.
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    @MonkeyPirate2002
    It's because you can't be certain of putting it onto the battlefield when it can, if the opponent can't see it. Which is a concern for your mechanic entrap as you mentioned.
This discussion has been closed.