MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Removal of Ravnica Competition.
Guilds of Ravnica is a pretty awesome set, in my opinion. There is, however, one problem.
The Golgari nabbed what is widely regarded as the best card in the set by quite a long margin. This removal spell will be showing up across multiple formats. My question is... why didn't the other guilds get some kind of removal to rival this monstrously good spell?
So that's your challenge. For each of the other nine guilds of ravnica design a removal spell that's powerful enough to rival Assassin's Trophy. It must be in that guild's colours and while I'm looking for something powerful it shouldn't be completely
broken. It must also fit into your guild.
What constitutes a removal spell? It must be able to hit creatures but it can target other types of permanents or do other things as well. Any number of entries are allowed. Go crazy!
1st place: Five favourites of your choice, a follow and a place in the hall of fame.
2nd place: Four favourites of your choice and a place in the hall of fame.
3rd place: Three favourites of your choice.
Competition closes on November 22nd (possibly 23rd, we'll see)
The Golgari nabbed what is widely regarded as the best card in the set by quite a long margin. This removal spell will be showing up across multiple formats. My question is... why didn't the other guilds get some kind of removal to rival this monstrously good spell?
So that's your challenge. For each of the other nine guilds of ravnica design a removal spell that's powerful enough to rival Assassin's Trophy. It must be in that guild's colours and while I'm looking for something powerful it shouldn't be completely
broken. It must also fit into your guild.
What constitutes a removal spell? It must be able to hit creatures but it can target other types of permanents or do other things as well. Any number of entries are allowed. Go crazy!
1st place: Five favourites of your choice, a follow and a place in the hall of fame.
2nd place: Four favourites of your choice and a place in the hall of fame.
3rd place: Three favourites of your choice.
Competition closes on November 22nd (possibly 23rd, we'll see)
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Does it have to be multicolored? Are old cards allowed?
Hope this is balanced enough, yet not too balanced.
Mm. Burn baby burn...
Now this. THIS one was hard to balance at all. I'm still not sure it is, but eh, it shows off it's guild perfectly.
@Undead how many entries are we allowed, and can we make more than 1 for each guild if we had more than 1 idea? (It would be nice to see someone make a card for all 9 of the other guilds, to complete the cycle.)
**Edited**