MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Battle for the Best (Creature Type)
Hello and welcome to the battle for the best creature type! This will be a long running challenge to decide what creature type is the best!
You will choose a creature type from the following below and create each of these to enter: 2 Creatures using that type and a tribal instant and/or sorcery and/or enchantment with that type.
This challenge will last until every creature type is used and one is left standing. Challenges will be given to everyone after they enter and after they complete and request a new one. Every 2 to 4 days, if there are enough participants, one creature type and it's owner will be eliminated. Since there are so many creature types, people will be able to jump in even if they have already been eliminated, for it to be fair to new people, challenges will be issued to new people before returning people. There will also be a reward system based off of jpastor's mystery box challenge and rewards.
You will choose a creature type from the following below and create each of these to enter: 2 Creatures using that type and a tribal instant and/or sorcery and/or enchantment with that type.
This challenge will last until every creature type is used and one is left standing. Challenges will be given to everyone after they enter and after they complete and request a new one. Every 2 to 4 days, if there are enough participants, one creature type and it's owner will be eliminated. Since there are so many creature types, people will be able to jump in even if they have already been eliminated, for it to be fair to new people, challenges will be issued to new people before returning people. There will also be a reward system based off of jpastor's mystery box challenge and rewards.
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Every time period everybody who wants to play that week picks a type. They make two creatures and a tribal card for it. You pick one of the types used (the one with the worst cards, presumably) and eliminate it. The process repeats. Have I got that right?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/aeveral-lone-ranger?list=user
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/elven-archery?list=user
Yeah I want a challenge
Your challenge is: Create a red elf card.
Reward: Lucky Fruit: One favorite of your choice.
1:
2: Hugs: One favorite of my choice to a player of your choice.
3: Lucky Fruit: One favorite of your choice.
4:
5:
6:
7:
8:
9:
10:
11:
12:
13:
14:
15:
16:
17:
18:
19:
20:
21:
22:
23:
24:
25:
I call cat
Wizards.
@Arinska, you might like this challenge thing. (I’m pretty sure you’d like to pick soldier, human, or knight)
Bringer, Brushwagg, Camarid, Caribou, Citizen, Sponge, Deserter, Eye, Dreadnought, Graveborn, Lamia, Orb, Oyster, Pentavite, Pincher, Prism, Reflection, Sable, Sand, Splinter, Survivor, Tetravite, Trilobite, Wombat. That's a vague list of things that should probably get removed, though I'm sure somebody will want to do something with Brushwagg. They're a combination of types that appear only on obsolete tokens, types that appear only on one or two cards and could easily be something else and cards that are just silly to work with (primarily Bringer). There are probably some errors in this, please don't hate me.
I considered putting Blinkmoth on the list, but I'm sure somebody can work with it. I can, if nothing else.
Minion is technically still workable with, but it's discontinued and doesn't really have meaning.
Germ is workable, but you'd have to change it so people can make cards with Living Weapon instead of creatures.
Mole is arguably a type that goes in the top category as it only has one card and the card has no clear build, tribe or similar. On the other hand, I'm pretty sure people could do things with it.
Scarecrow (and maybe a few other types, not sure) appear multiple times throughout your list.