MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Public/Group Reverse Challenge (Ongoing w/ prizes)
Hello fellow cardsmiths, I've been under some artblock recently and wanted to continue the Murkletins' Reverse Challenge. But I feel we need to change the formula to keep people engaged while I come out of artblock. So what I've decided is to make this a public/group reverse challenge.
Instructions:
1) Card requests must be stated within 20 words or less.
2) You may post any number of card requests, but avoid posting on the thread with back to back messages.
3) You may make a card for any number of card requests. People can do the same card more than once.
4) Please post the request you are responding to with your card and the cardsmith's name.
4B) Alternatively you may link to the original card request's comment.
Please post no more than one new challenge per card created for other challenges. To keep from bulking the list and make it more manageable to finish most. This will also improve the ease of creating unique challenges.
Prizes: (Updated April 5th, 2019)
1) Each time you make a card for someone else's request, you get 2 favorites on cards of your choice you made.
1B) Please post the favorite requests in the same comment as your card.
2) If you created four or more entries for a single cycle, I will follow you.
3) Once per week, I will gift a month of premium subscription to one cardsmith who made a card for someone else's request.
To start us off, I will post three card requests for the mean time until people come up with ideas.
Starting Requests: (Posted in order of least to most difficult!)
1) Make a card that features an honorable female character.
2) Make a legendary card themed around a mechanic from another cardsmith.
3) Make a card that can be played or cast transformed.
Happy smithing everyone!
Instructions:
1) Card requests must be stated within 20 words or less.
2) You may post any number of card requests, but avoid posting on the thread with back to back messages.
3) You may make a card for any number of card requests. People can do the same card more than once.
4) Please post the request you are responding to with your card and the cardsmith's name.
4B) Alternatively you may link to the original card request's comment.
Please post no more than one new challenge per card created for other challenges. To keep from bulking the list and make it more manageable to finish most. This will also improve the ease of creating unique challenges.
Prizes: (Updated April 5th, 2019)
1) Each time you make a card for someone else's request, you get 2 favorites on cards of your choice you made.
1B) Please post the favorite requests in the same comment as your card.
2) If you created four or more entries for a single cycle, I will follow you.
3) Once per week, I will gift a month of premium subscription to one cardsmith who made a card for someone else's request.
To start us off, I will post three card requests for the mean time until people come up with ideas.
Starting Requests: (Posted in order of least to most difficult!)
1) Make a card that features an honorable female character.
2) Make a legendary card themed around a mechanic from another cardsmith.
3) Make a card that can be played or cast transformed.
Happy smithing everyone!
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Here is my 3 requests to choose from:
1) Create an instant or sorcery that is a type of removal spell.
2) Create a multicolored enchantment card that works with planeswalkers.
3) Create a creature or planeswalker that works with curse enchantments.
Hope those was challenging enough!
@murkletins here is my 2 favorites requests please:
1) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/eden-puppet-master
2) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/dora-honorable-champion
From: http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/comment/141612/#Comment_141612
Who does the voodoo? You do!
Challenge Request: Make a card featuring a character disconnected from reality.
Can you please favorite these?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/close-call-5
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/gloamingblade-usurper
Next up:
- A nonland card that features three instances of a static mechanic in MTG (Like a card with Exploit, Exploit, Exploit.)
- A noncreature card that can turn into a creature.
- A card featuring a mechanic named Usurp.
Usurp - Whenever a player becomes the monarch, [effect.]
Request: A card featuring El Dorado, the city of gold.
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/cue-the-rebellion
Request: Create a balanced card about nonblue extra turns.
Requests:
1) An artifact or enchantment with Ascend.
2) A creature the punishes planeswalker usage.
3) A card that incorporates the flavor text of Catullus 85 (translated or original).
"Ōdī et amō. Quārē id faciam fortasse requīris.
Nesciō, sed fierī sentiō et excrucior."
"I hate and I love. Why I do this, perhaps you ask.
I know not, but I feel it happening and I am tortured."
Hello fellow cardsmiths, I'm looking to make alterations to the base of this contest to keep engagement going past the first card of each week. So I'd like if you would post some feedback on what you're interested in with a comment. Below I will list some ideas that may be of interest!
Ideas:
1) Weekly super challenges w/ bonus rewards.
2) Endorsed challenges w/ bonus rewards.
Edit: I think I'm going to keep it simple for clarity sake!
Thank you for your support and happy smithing!
1)
2)
3)
---
Requests:
1) A functional and nerfed reprint of Doubling Season.
2) A female imp creature, good aligned.
3) A land that let me "explore" my library.
Remember that for each card you post for another cardsmith's request, you may request that I favorite two of your cards in the same comment as the card.
@murkletins please favourite: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/moonbeam-celestial?list=user and https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/gor-sandmagus?list=user .
Requests:
1- a blue goblin
2- an angel creature without flying, that doesn't have any colours other than white and isn't a fallen angel.
3- a blue-white creature with riot and afterlife.
@murkletins (only if old cards are allowed), please favorite these two:
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/devilish-pact-1
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/asha-the-blessed
Requests:
1. A Samurai.
2. A Hyena Jackal.
3. A nonbasic land.
That's because we're unimaginative. Take a look in "My Restaurant" to see how crazily diverse such a challenge could get. Here are the items on "The Menu" thus far!
I'll add some diversity challenges later today for those that want a challenge. I think I'll do that each day!
@Faiths_Guide
I'll accept old cards, but I prefer new ones. No worries!
Requests:
1. An Artifact Card of a Map.
2. An Enchantment Card that affects Planeswalkers
3. A Land Card you sacrifice when it gets used
@Murkletins - Please favorite these two cards
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/lourina-sarfinoss
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/check-the-surroundings
1) Create a tri-colored legendary creature using three different mechanics synergistically. (Note: They can be custom mechanics.)
2) Create an artifact with a new subtype and ability that allows it to be attached to something other than a creature. (Note: A twist on the equip ability.)
3) Create a unique transforming creature representing multiple definitions of a single term.
2. An Enchantment Card that affects Planeswalkers
Not sure who favorites these two, but here are the two cards I would like favorites for. Thanks!
1.) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/frozen-underworld
2.) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/aaira-risen-from-glory
Here are the next challenge requests from me:
1. Multicolored creature with Exert ability.
2. Mythic rare Saga based around the legendary Angel Avacyn.
3. Green sorcery with X in it's converted mana cost.
ORDER UP: Green sorcery with X in it's converted mana cost
YES I DO REALIZE I USED JOSU HERNAIZ'S OASIS RITUALIST ART (Which is used in an Hour of Devastation card)
Next will be...
-- A Charm
-- A Card with Resolve (Mechanic Above)
-- or A Card that pertains to Sagas
I think there are plenty of card requests already, so I will decline adding additional ones. @murkletins, if this is not okay, please let me know and I'll add some more.