The uncertainty of it all! challenge (Asymmetric - Judged)

2»

Comments

  • ArmisJoeArmisJoe
    @KorandAngels love what you did with your challenge! So simple yet so rare
  • Netherin5Netherin5
    May we request a second challenge?
  • ArmisJoeArmisJoe
    edited April 2019
    @murkletins done!
    image

    I changed it a bit so it looks a bit less confusing, hope that's a okay!
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    @Netherin5
    Sure, go for it.
  • Netherin5Netherin5
    This is me requesting a second challenge.
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    @Netherin5
    Alright, this will be my first second challenge, so I will be making it special.

    I have something for you, this time based on your relationships with other cardsmiths!

    Challenge Theme: Flattering gift!
    Challenge: Make a creature card of another cardsmith you're fond of. (You must tag the @cardsmith in your post!)
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    Sorry for the delay, I was out tonight.
  • Netherin5Netherin5
    @murkletins It's fine. This is challenging, because I'm gonna seem like a jerk to any cardsmith I know who I don't make this for.
  • TemurzoaTemurzoa
    edited April 2019
    Done!

    image
  • LujikulLujikul
    Firstly, I'd like to apologize for taking so long to create a card for my challenge. (Make a card that expresses the good in an otherwise evil seeming being.)

    Secondly, this one might be cheating a little. The undead are often associated with evil, thanks to often being the work of necromancers, which are often portrayed as fiendish wizards with evil intentions. So while this one isn't an evil being showing a glimmer of good in its heart, per se, it's an attempt at demonstrating the good side of a type of creature that is often evil.

    image
  • sanjaya666sanjaya666
    What about a planeswalker?

    Yo, @sorinjace.

    image
  • pstmdrnpstmdrn
    Challenge Please
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    edited April 2019
    @Everybody
    I will extend this challenge to the 21st of April, 2019. Sorry for being away, I will judge my other challenges soon, now that I believe they're over.

    I'll give you a challenge in a bit, pstmdrn.
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    @pstmdrn
    I have something for you, this time based on your morality!

    Challenge Theme: A dilemma indeed!
    Challenge: Make a card that expresses and/or depicts a moral dilemma.

    I decided to give you a different challenge than I otherwise would, since I've extended the challenge duration and want to keep things interesting.
  • pstmdrnpstmdrn
    @murkletins I love it! This is an area of interest for me.
  • sorinjacesorinjace
    @sanjaya666 that card is cool!
  • pstmdrnpstmdrn
    edited April 2019
    image
  • TemurzoaTemurzoa
    May I please request another challenge?
  • TenebrisNemoTenebrisNemo
    edited April 2019
    Challenge Theme: A friend of friends!
    Challenge: Make a card that supports an archetype of your choice, while expressing friendship.

    Entry (a double-faced card):

    image image

    I aimed for aggressive friendship, hope it was worth the wait!

    @murkletins - I would like to ask for a new challenge.

    Edit: Also, if you're still giving two favorites for those who enter, I would like you to favorite these two cards of mine, please.
    https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/trogon-pathway?list=user
    https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/legornas-library?list=user
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    So it seems people want this challenge to continue a bit longer. I'm glad as it's a very experimental idea.

    I'll judge the initial entries and continue this challenge for 7 more days, offering a new prize for that week. However, this will be in a new thread I'll post soon.

    I'm very thankful that people are considering a second challenge from myself. I'll try to keep them interesting.

    Sorry for the absence on the forums, I hope to be on more often and deliver all the prizes promptly.
  • ArmisJoeArmisJoe
    If it is getting extended, I'd like to request a second challenge :D
    And thanks to you for make such a good challenge!
  • murkletinsmurkletins
    Hello fellow participants, sorry for the delay in judging. I'm going to post the results right now. Then later today open the new challenge, which will be a round two!

    Challenge Results:
    1st Place) Mirror Dimension by @ArmisJoe

    Prizes For First Place:
    - 1 month of premium subscription for yourself.
    - 1 month of premium subscription for a friend of yours on the site.
    - A follow from us.
    - 3 favorites on cards of your choice on your account.
  • ArmisJoeArmisJoe
    Me?! Wow thank you so much for this prize and for hosting this challenge. I will PM you shortly @murkletins

    I joined just last month and for me to have this recognition really means a lot. I saw amazing and very creative ideas in this thread. Good job everyone!
This discussion has been closed.