MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Welcome to the Band Club (Music & Sagas) Challenge *Cancelled*
Hello fellow cardsmiths, myself am bringing my own Saga contest to the fray. Yes, we know this is done to death. But myself have some major twists for this one.
Twists/Instructions:
1) You may choose up to three songs in the comments for your play by plays coming from here on out.
1B) You can add songs at any time until you have three songs, unless a challenge states otherwise.
1C) You can't remove songs or switch them out. If you do, you'll be kicked from the band session. XD
2) You must make a legendary creature or legendary planeswalker that fits at least one of your songs.
3) You must make two signature spells (Instants or Sorceries), an artifact and an enchantment. All themed around any number of your songs each.
4) You may make a companion creature or planeswalker, this is optional and is only for judging tiebreakers.
5) Post your cards and songs in a single comment. The rest of the cards and songs you post may be posted in individual comments.
Editing Rules:
We all make errors when making cards, so myself will let you edit your cards... on the condition that once they have been judged, you don't edit them. Songs can not be switched out regardless however due to it being the main challenge of this contest. If you need to switch a song, PM myself here or on Discord and we can talk about it. Thanks for your patience with myself!
There will be four rounds, with each lasting a week!
Challenge 1: Just surviving. (Song to be announced: IPXIgEAGe4U)
Challenge 2: Ascending from nothing. (Song to be announced: l0HzYxuOoOY)
Challenge 3: Deal with the devil. (Song to be announced: sh7BZf7D5Bw)
Challenge 4: Confronted by lady death. (Song to be announced: h5f3-jB0-do)
Alt Challenge: For up to one challenge you aren't proud of your score for, you may make a card themed after this song and your main character to substitute your score for that challenge.
Note: At the end there will be the final judging
Participant List: (Updated 7/22/2019 10:20PM, CA)
@ThatOneCat (Still working on cards.)
Happy smithing everyone, all are welcome to join the band club!
Twists/Instructions:
1) You may choose up to three songs in the comments for your play by plays coming from here on out.
1B) You can add songs at any time until you have three songs, unless a challenge states otherwise.
1C) You can't remove songs or switch them out. If you do, you'll be kicked from the band session. XD
2) You must make a legendary creature or legendary planeswalker that fits at least one of your songs.
3) You must make two signature spells (Instants or Sorceries), an artifact and an enchantment. All themed around any number of your songs each.
4) You may make a companion creature or planeswalker, this is optional and is only for judging tiebreakers.
5) Post your cards and songs in a single comment. The rest of the cards and songs you post may be posted in individual comments.
Editing Rules:
We all make errors when making cards, so myself will let you edit your cards... on the condition that once they have been judged, you don't edit them. Songs can not be switched out regardless however due to it being the main challenge of this contest. If you need to switch a song, PM myself here or on Discord and we can talk about it. Thanks for your patience with myself!
There will be four rounds, with each lasting a week!
Challenge 1: Just surviving. (Song to be announced: IPXIgEAGe4U)
Challenge 2: Ascending from nothing. (Song to be announced: l0HzYxuOoOY)
Challenge 3: Deal with the devil. (Song to be announced: sh7BZf7D5Bw)
Challenge 4: Confronted by lady death. (Song to be announced: h5f3-jB0-do)
Alt Challenge: For up to one challenge you aren't proud of your score for, you may make a card themed after this song and your main character to substitute your score for that challenge.
Note: At the end there will be the final judging
Participant List: (Updated 7/22/2019 10:20PM, CA)
@ThatOneCat (Still working on cards.)
Happy smithing everyone, all are welcome to join the band club!
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
The Overpass by Panic at the Disco
Hit and Run by Lolo
Cards on the way.
There will now be four challenges, sorry for the discrepancy. Working on building a story with the challenges.
First song is Sweden by C418. Will link soon.
Would prefer new cards, otherwise we'd have to judge them more harshly.
So let me try to clarify what you are doing:
Post up to 3 songs. Anyone can make a card based on one or more of the songs you added to this contest, but you need to make one of the two: a legendary creature or a planeswalker influenced by one of the 3 songs you provided.
Is this correct? also, are the support cards optional or are they required?
Sorry I'm so confused on this here.
Firstly, you post up to three songs to start. But you can save some of the choices for later on for flexibility. Then each card you make must be themed off of one or more of your songs you've chosen. You do not directly interact with other cardsmiths' songs. That would be a nightmare to judge.
Lastly, the only thing that is optional would be the companion creature/planeswalker card.
Side note, the only songs you interact with other than your own are my songs posted in the main post regarding challenges.
Steps to enter:
1) Choose one to three songs for your starting cards to be themed off of. You can add songs at any time until you have three songs, unless a challenge states you can add more. You can't change songs midway, but cards can be edited before they're judged.
2) Make a legendary creature or legendary planeswalker that fits at least one of your songs.
3) Make two signature spells (Instants or Sorceries), an artifact and an enchantment. Each themed around one or more of your songs.
4) You may make a companion creature or planeswalker, completely optional. Also, themed around one or more of your songs.
5) Post your cards and songs in a single comment. The rest of the cards and songs you post in the future may be posted in individual comments.
If don't get a few more entrants, we'll have to call this a no contest challenge.
May you close this, when you have time? Myself have decided to cancel it.