MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
murkletins - Three week, Weekly challenge (December, 2019. Week 2 ongoing)
Hello fellow cardsmiths, starting a challenge with only favorites and follows as the prizes, just to see how popular one of my own can be. Without further adieu, let's get to the premise
Weekly challenges:
1st week: Post a card that features visually and/or mechanically, ways of breaking a mind.
2nd week: Post a card that features a critter, anthropomorphic animal, or furry creature.
3rd week: Post a card that features an effect that benefits an opponent, as well as yourself.
Is there an entry limit? --> 3 cards per week, no old cards for each week. (Weeks end each Sunday night.)
Is there an end date? --> At the end of the third week.
How to win prizes:
1) At the end of each week, (Sunday) myself will judge each card posted that week.
2) Myself will rate each card, on a score out of 10.
3) Prizes will be awarded based on the respective card's score.
Scored prizes: (Favorites are of your choice, on cards you've made.)
0/10 to 3/10. Results in no prize.
4/10 to 5/10. Results in one favorite.
6/10 to 7/10. Results in two favorites.
8+/10. Results in four favorites and a follow.
This is my little experiment, so hopefully it does reasonably!
Weekly challenges:
1st week: Post a card that features visually and/or mechanically, ways of breaking a mind.
2nd week: Post a card that features a critter, anthropomorphic animal, or furry creature.
3rd week: Post a card that features an effect that benefits an opponent, as well as yourself.
Is there an entry limit? --> 3 cards per week, no old cards for each week. (Weeks end each Sunday night.)
Is there an end date? --> At the end of the third week.
How to win prizes:
1) At the end of each week, (Sunday) myself will judge each card posted that week.
2) Myself will rate each card, on a score out of 10.
3) Prizes will be awarded based on the respective card's score.
Scored prizes: (Favorites are of your choice, on cards you've made.)
0/10 to 3/10. Results in no prize.
4/10 to 5/10. Results in one favorite.
6/10 to 7/10. Results in two favorites.
8+/10. Results in four favorites and a follow.
This is my little experiment, so hopefully it does reasonably!
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
@benw
4/10. Results in one favorite.
Judged artwork heavily on this one, due to using what seems to be an actual person in photo and the poor image quality.
@Corwinnn
7/10. Results in two favorites.
Honestly like this one, but was surprised by the image.
@Revan
5/10. Results in one favorite.
Liking the flavor. Although it feels under-costed for the power level.
@sanjaya666
5/10. Results in one favorite.
The only reason the score is lower is due to power level at the mana cost. This is a reasonable effect. But would prefer they draw one or more cards afterwards, to prevent locking down the game so early.
Everyone who participated is welcome to send their favorites here or via PM. Thanks for participating.
Scoring Rubric: (Favorites are of your choice, on cards you've made.)
0/10 to 3/10. Results in no prize.
4/10 to 5/10. Results in one favorite.
6/10 to 7/10. Results in two favorites.
8+/10. Results in four favorites and a follow.
2nd week: Post a card that features a critter, anthropomorphic animal, or furry creature.
How's this?
Don't see any issue with it.
this is my submission
Updated the rules:
Is there an entry limit? --> 3 cards per week, no old cards for each week. (Weeks end each Sunday night.)