The Legendary Brawl (Enter Now!)

Fantastickill7 · April 2020

Closed for judging!
Stay tuned for the results and the next challenge(scheduled for the 1st of May)

Fantastickill7 · May 2020

RESULTS!

For this round I replaced "balanced" with "hilarity" for obvious reasons.
C = creativity ?/10, H = hilarity ?/10. 6/10 is average and 10-12 is the average total

@Dizzydude's Quack-Quack Lost Duckling C = 6, H = 7. Total = 13
@Dizzydude's Cluck-Cluck The Peaceful C = 6, H = 5. Total = 11
@zamshala's Humpty The Ever Cracking C = 8, H = 4. Total = 12
@zamshala's Karen Master Of Engines C = 6, H = 4. Total = 10
@zamshale's Americat The Free C = 6, H = 5. Total = 11
@KorandAngels'Timmy Failure, Bad Detective C = 8, H = 7. Total = 15
@KorandAngels'Tabble And The Bull C = 7, H = 5. Total = 12
@Ranshi's Thanos, The Inevitable C = 7, H = 7. Total 14
@Ranshi's Corwinnn, Squirrel Proprietor C = 8, H = 6. Total 14
@Bobman111's Mt Snuffles, Legionnaire C = 9, H = 10. Total 19
@Abu_Jafar's Valduck, Keeper of the Bread C = 6, H = 5. Total 11
@Abu_Jafar's Sergeant Evergreen C = 6, H = 6. Total 12
@Abu_Jafar's Harold, Yee Old Knight C = 9, H = 7. Total 16
@ArchieTaylor's Atraxa, Traitor's Voice C = 7, H = 8. Total 15

The champion for April 2020 is...
@Bobman111's Mt Snuffles, Legionnaire With a total of 19 points!

Most creative card (other than Mr Snuffles) is...
@Abu_Jafar's Harold, Yee Old Knight C = 9, H = 7. Total 16

Most hilarious card (other than Mr Snuffles) is...
@ArchieTaylor's Atraxa, Traitor's Voice C = 7, H = 8. Total 15

The Legendary Brawl Challenge for May 2020!
April shower bring May flowers. This month will be based on Plants and Elementals!

Up to four legendary Plant/Elemental cards per person.
Please credit the artist.
Have fun!

Fantastickill7 · May 2020

@Bobman111 you get 5 favorites of your choice and a follow, @Abu_Jafar you get 3 favorites of your choice, and @ArchieTaylor you get 3 favorites of your choice.

Abu_Jafar · May 2020

@Fantastickill7, just favourite three of my cards that you like please.

Fantastickill7 · May 2020

@Abu_Jafar, Alright, I'll let you know what I pick.

Fantastickill7 · May 2020

@Abu_Jafar I faved https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/anna-the-trickster?list=user, https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/crazed-blood-shedder?list=user, and https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/the-knights-return?list=user

Ranshi · May 2020

I'll only have two old entries this time around!

KorandAngels · May 2020

I assume that according to the scores, my Timmy Failure card would fill the next best slot, which there wasn't a thing for.

KorandAngels · May 2020

Here's a card:

Fantastickill7 · May 2020

@KorandAngels
You Timmy was next best, but I have it as highest total, highest creativity, (if the card with the highest total has the highest score in creativity the second best creativity score wins this same applies to balance(in his case hilarity)) and highest balance.

And anyway Abu_Jafar's Harold Yee Old Knight had 16 which is 1 greater than yours.
And ArchieTaylor's Atraxa was tied with your with 15 points.

So to avoid all these ties that I would have to break up I don't have it as 1st, 2nd, and 3rd.
But rather 1st, highest C, and highest B(H).

KorandAngels · May 2020

Fantastickill7 · May 2020

@KorandAngels
Would it be possible for you to post the links with the image? I don't care if it's a clickable image but if you could please add the urls so that I can easily find them later on that would be much appreciated.