I had an idea... for a 1,000 card set

18911131418

Comments

  • I'll take jund vs Azorius instead of grixis is Ranshi decides to take it.
  • edited January 2020
    @Leaf_Juggernaut, you can have Jund for now yes
  • edited January 2020
    Tribe Requests

    Naya v Dimir @DrakeGladis
    Grixis v Selesnya @Ranshi
    Esper v Gruul
    Bant v Rakdos @AxNoodle
    Jund v Azorius @Leaf_Juggernaut


    Sultai v Boros @Scott_Anderson
    Abzan v Izzet @TheWanderer
    Temur v Orzhov @TheWanderer***
    Jeskai v Golgari
    Mardu v Simic @Scott_Anderson ***


    Need: Esper vs. Gruul, and Jeskai vs. Golgari
    Available: Temur vs Orzhov and Mardu vs. Simic are still available as well.
  • I can do jeskai vs golgari.
  • So the job is to create a mechanical conflict between the two?
  • edited January 2020
    As far as the power level thing, maybe I'm exaggerating. Never mind that complaint.

    I think the origins power level is good for the set.
  • edited January 2020
    @Scott_Anderson
    Original Lore of creation I made a couple of weeks ago (copy pasted from that post):

    In the beginning there was a God (MTGCardsmith's embodiment) floating in a void. He was sleeping in eternal rest until one day he opened his eyes. This sent out waves upon waves of aether out (you guys mentioned the planes were going to be islands floating in the aether, which I think is a good idea). There was so much and it was overpowering; the light was too bright and it hurt the god's eyes. He couldn't tolerate it, but he knew that this aether had a mysterious power; he sensed it. So to try and control the aether, he ripped of parts of his body/limbs to sent them floating into the distance; these limbs were supposed to absorb the overpowering energy. Eventually as the light dimmed and the god could finally see, he saw 5 entities standing before him. They had mutated and came back each with a different element: the five colors of mana. (There was a white/blue/black/red/green one, which will each have their names when we make them.) Each one had the power to send mana of their kind into the aether, thus being able to create an infinite amount of floating-island-planes . The god saw them having fun creating planes and tried to send mana of his own; turns out, he colorless. But, there was still a problem. Within seconds of creating planes, they would turn unstable and explode. The god, curious and eager to be able to create islands like the others, added his colorless mana to one of the newly created planes. To their surprise, it didn't explode and thus created the first stable plane. The colorless mana neutralized the colored mana, which stabilized the energy of the plane.

    But, they weren't the only ones alive. There were other being out in the aether with intentions unknown. They had different kinds of mana like:snow mana, phyrexian mana, energy, etc. Some of them would help create islands by involving their own mana into them. But, who knows what other malignant being were created delving out in the farther parts of the aether...
  • edited January 2020
    The lore needs some revision not that the set is different, but that's the main idea.
  • @Ranshi not a mechanical conflict but a story conflict. Just a reason why they’re fighting and maybe a resolution. A little story. Not a graphic novel.

    Like, a slice of life.

    I once had a D&D adventure where the focus was two families of hobbits in a feud. But hobbits aren’t violent so it was pranks and gossip. It could be as simple as that. Or it could be a war or a love story or anything that has a little story to it.

    That gives you reason to connect some cards in a narrative. Not all of them, just enough to give the impression of a vibrant living world.
  • @leaf_juggernaut, I think you have something there. I even have a card that can help tell that story.

    The art and flavor text would need revision but this is a card for God’s origin:

    https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/alseep-for-a-hundred-years
  • @Scott_Anderson, can I do Esper vs Gruul?
  • edited January 2020
    @Scott_Anderson

    Yea that card fits the lore well. I like it.

    The lore may need revision since it was meant for the first design format of the set. Now that the set has changed a bit, it doesn't quite fit in as well as it did.
  • @Leaf_Juggernaut You bet. I'm writing a second draft of your first draft and I will send it to you in private so we can talk about it and how to proceed.
  • @IzItTrue and @WarriorCatInAhat those are great choices.


    Current Assignments

    Naya v Dimir @DrakeGladis
    Grixis v Selesnya @Ranshi
    Esper v Gruul @WarriorCatInAhat
    Bant v Rakdos @AxNoodle
    Jund v Azorius @Leaf_Juggernaut


    Sultai v Boros @Scott_Anderson
    Abzan v Izzet @TheWanderer
    Temur v Orzhov @TheWanderer***
    Jeskai v Golgari @IzItTrue
    Mardu v Simic @Scott_Anderson ***

    Start thinking and @Leaf_Juggernaut will hand us our finished lore premise soon.
  • @Scott_Anderson a few questions:

    1. I saw how many Jeskai/Golgari cards I should make but how many mono-color cards should I make?

    2. Can I make any legendaries?
  • edited January 2020
    I wanted to be part of this. Only this confusing shard/guild thing has excluded me.

  • @KorandAngels
    @Bowler218

    I will do a better job of explaining. I know that once we publish the lore for the mega-set, it will be quite clear what we will be doing.

    There are ten little islands in the aether. They look a lot like this:

    image

    On each island, there are two color-based factions. One is a three-color faction and the other is a two-color faction, using the remaining two of the five Magic colors.

    So for instance it could be Mardu vs. Simic. If you are confused about colors and their names, you can find them all here: https://humpheh.com/magic/c/

    Your job is to choose one of those pairs. Right now @KorandAngels and
    @Bowler218, we have Temur vs Orzhov and Mardu vs. Simic available.

    Think up a little story. It can be very simple. Just a point of conflict and some creatures you can talk about. And then make cards!

  • I'll take Temur vs Orzhov, got a pretty good idea for Temur
  • edited January 2020



    @IzItTru I am still hammering out which multicolor cards to make. I made a mistake that I've just corrected: Each block only needs ten color groups (5 islands) instead of all 20.

    @ Everyone on the thread:

    This is the link to the entire set plan: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1BnhSRV88l1vWkxMvMrqfQ9Ib4PUNqFKI/view?usp=sharing

    As far as which monocolored cards you create, I would suggest making as many as you like at each rarity. Make sure at least some of them reflect your story or island. I have labeled as many slots as I can at this early stage to give folks a good idea what cards we want and in what quantities.

  • Current Assignments

    Naya v Dimir @DrakeGladis
    Grixis v Selesnya @Ranshi
    Esper v Gruul @WarriorCatInAhat
    Bant v Rakdos @AxNoodle
    Jund v Azorius @Leaf_Juggernaut


    Sultai v Boros @Scott_Anderson
    Abzan v Izzet @TheWanderer
    Temur v Orzhov @Bowler218
    Jeskai v Golgari @IzItTrue
    Mardu v Simic OPEN

    @Korandangels would you like to handle Mardu and Simic? Or is there another pair you would like to try? If it's another pair then we would have to have collaboration or bump someone.

    I am willing to get bumped from Sultai v Boros.
  • edited January 2020
    @DrakeGladis
    @Ranshi
    @WarriorCatInAhat
    @AxNoodle
    @Leaf_Juggernaut
    @Scott_Anderson
    @TheWanderer
    @Bowler218
    @IzItTrue
    @Korandangels

    Here is the total count of cards that you must design:

    2-color tribe
    4 hybrid common creatures
    1 hybrid common spell
    3 uncommon hybrid creatures
    3 uncommon hybrid spells
    2 uncommon gold cards (any)

    3-color tribe
    1 or 2 rare gold 2-color creature
    1 or 2 rare gold 3-color creatures
    2 rare 2-color cards (any)
    1 rare gold 3-color instant
    1 rare gold 3-color sorcery
    1 rare gold 3-color enchantment

    Any Type
    2 Mythics – any color and kind of card you want

    Presumably any of those rares or mythics could be planeswalkers, and there are also rare monocolored spots.

    I would think that many of the 2-color factions would want to put a planeswalker at rare or mythic, I don't know.


    ADDITIONALLY you may submit whatever mono cards you like. Please remember it's commons that we need the most of and that are usually in the shortest supply.

    Spreadsheet: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1BnhSRV88l1vWkxMvMrqfQ9Ib4PUNqFKI/view?usp=sharing
  • I was just thinking, I wanted to include something obscure but in canon to sort of ground our plane into reality. I'm working on a Baltrice card, could we include her?
  • I don't know what Baltrice is. I would presume yes, especially if it's a planeswalker
  • Neither of those are to my tastes. That is unfair. I had posted a few pages earlier with my islands saying that it was naya with splashes of the other two, meaning that MY COMBO WAS STOLEN!!!!
    @mtgcardsmithdetective
  • I am finding almost all of your decisions respictive and unfair. @Scott_Anderson
  • That's no fun. What would you like to change?
  • But there can't be two planes with the same colours.
  • @korandangels Are there other decisions that we have made that you don't like?

    The things I am announcing about how we divide up the sets and what cards to make are subject to change. It is difficult to fit 20 tribes into even a 1000 card set so as to allow each one breathing room, is what I am finding.
  • I would like more freedom of the makeup of my island. It has about 4-5 factions.
This discussion has been closed.