I had an idea... for a 1,000 card set

Comments

• Scott_Anderson

  February 2020

  @warriorcatinahat oh gosh that’s very sad. I’m sorry to hear it. We shall see what happens with that.
  
  If you have some cards I would love to see them.
  
  Also I just noticed what your avatar is. So cute
• WarriorCatInAhat

  February 2020

  @Scott_Anderson
  I have like 3 cards. Check em out here:https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/forest-dweller-4?list=set&set=49163
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/caught-by-the-beast?list=set&set=49163
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/karmog-beast-friend?list=set&set=49163
  
  Farewell my friend.
• Scott_Anderson

  February 2020

  @warriorcatinahat no no lol not farewell - I look forward to seeing all your great cards and collaborating soon!
• Scott_Anderson

  February 2020 edited February 2020

  @WarriorCatInAhat
  
  My theme, broadly, is "adventuring Party versus dragons and their minions" but I haven't nailed down the main characters yet outside of Karmog.
  
  I made her into an orc so I could use feral and primal artwork for her since she's in Gruul.
  
  The Esper wedge will be humans and kithkin mostly, with knight, cleric, rogue, wizard.
  
  
  
  
  
  
• WarriorCatInAhat

  February 2020

  @Scott_Anderson
  Woah...
• Dom_Rocks

  February 2020

  Hey, sorry for not being here. Can I work on the "Spirit Realm" for the planeswalkers and creatures representing Cardsmiths?
• Scott_Anderson

  February 2020

  @dom_rocks
• Scott_Anderson

  February 2020

  Haven’t had any interest here for a while. Has anyone been hacking away at this? Shall we continue or maybe modify the goal?
• Ranshi

  February 2020

  Idk... I’ve been simply lacking inspiration.
• Scott_Anderson

  February 2020

  @Ranshi do you have a spreadsheet set up? That way when you do have inspiration you can slot a card. It's incredibly helpful to me.
• Ranshi

  February 2020

  I don't have a spreadsheet. But the spreadsheet doesn't help with inspiration anyway.
• WarriorCatInAhat

  February 2020

  This place has been pretty inactive.
• Scott_Anderson

  February 2020

  @warriorcatinahat it’s too bad. It is an ambitious project and the final result would be a glorious tribute to us all.
  
  Cest la vie
• TheWanderer

  February 2020

  @Scott_Anderson
  I'm still working, albeit slowly. Whenever an idea strikes, I make a card, but lately I've been a bit too busy with real life stuff to properly sit down and make a bunch of them.
• Scott_Anderson

  February 2020

  @thewanderer that’s wonderful. We will see what we have when various folks finish their first draft and then we can go from there.
• Ranshi

  February 2020

  @Scott_Anderson, could you please allow me to edit the spreadsheet so I can fill in what I have?
• Scott_Anderson

  February 2020 edited February 2020

  oh you betcha. Everyone ought to be able to grab a copy. Here:
  
  https://drive.google.com/file/d/1BnhSRV88l1vWkxMvMrqfQ9Ib4PUNqFKI/view?usp=sharing
  
  
  Here are two example pages of how to set up your cards so they can be slotted properly. Boros/Sultai and Esper/Gruul
  
  https://drive.google.com/file/d/1gKLsFyGzpPGaFk8NBnHNXVCIOpqxCWOg/view?usp=sharing
  
  
• Ranshi

  February 2020

  So, what parts are reserved for the island of Selesnya v Grixis?
• Scott_Anderson

  February 2020

  @ranshi first document, last page, titled Cards by Cardsmith
  
  It will show you how many monocolored cards you are responsible for and what rarities, and then where the S vs G specific cards go and their rarities.
• Ranshi

  February 2020

  @Scott_Anderson, are the mono colored bits two-fold, or are they to be shared by the conflicting parties?
• Scott_Anderson

  February 2020

  @ranshi You may make them how you like. It makes sense to keep them in the story you're telling but you can have them be standalones too. Of course they can be part of either team or whatever else makes sense to you.
• Ranshi

  February 2020

  @Scott_Anderson, why are there no common slots for multicolored cards?
• Scott_Anderson

  February 2020

  @ranshi there are no slots for gold cards because they are hard to cast and in draft you want to be able to play the cards you draft. There are slots for hybrid cards which are easier to fit in but have the same feel mechanically.
  
  I think - think - people like designing hybrids more than golds anyway.
  
  Yes? No?
• Ranshi

  February 2020

  Designing Hybrids correctly just results in more narrow designs, seeing as it would need to be fitting either one of the colors in a mono color pie.
• Scott_Anderson

  February 2020

  @ranshi would you like to use some of your common hybrid slots to make common gold cards instead? That sounds good.