MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Oath of MTG Cardsmith
Good morning, good afternoon and good night.
This is the first challenge I am creating and I will try to make it as plausible as possible. Without a lot of performances (drumming - but you should have seen it in the title * laughs *)
This challenge will focus on planeswalkers and oaths (forget the sentry lore and make your own. 
).
).Rules:
Make 1 planeswalker card and 1 Oath card for this planeswalker (this set will count as an entry)
• Maximum of 2 entries per participant
• Old cards valid only for planeswalkers. Oaths must be cards after 06/17
Edited: The cards need the link of the creation made in MTGCardsmith
Edited: The cards need the link of the creation made in MTGCardsmith
Rewards:
Only if you have more than seven participants. Below that all participants will have three favorite cards to choose from.
1st - Seven favorite cards and a follow (if I already follow you will have +2 favorite cards)
2nd - Five favorite cards
3rd - Three favorite cards
(May increase according to the number of participants)
Judging:
10 points each card:
2p - my opinion for judgment
3p - quality
3p - balancing
2p - grammar
1extra point - Illustration of the oath is similar to the current one (it replaces a possible loss of points. the limit score is 10)
1extra point - Illustration of the oath is similar to the current one (it replaces a possible loss of points. the limit score is 10)
I will try to make challenges faster, because I don't know how the first challenges will behave. Limit until 06/21 or until the seventh different participants.
Good luck to everyone and be creative
My Examples: (I don’t think they’re good, but it’s worth it )
My Examples: (I don’t think they’re good, but it’s worth it
)This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Ileri is an undead paladin.
(Sorry the images are so big)
Don't worry about the image, but the cards link was missing. Could you fix it?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/oath-of-ileri
As the planeswalker was made at MTGCardsmith, it will be considered for evaluation.
You know how black creatures sacrifice other creatures to make themselves stronger? Well white creatures usually do the opposite and sacrifice themselves to help others. I wanted to create a planeswalker that emphasised this concept:
You can click on the cards to go to the card page ^^
The last ability of the Oath card might need a bit of an explanation. What it lets you do is activate each loyalty of your planeswalkers independently. For instance, Jaine could theoretically activate her +2, -2, and -7 in the same turn, though not the same ability twice.
Edited: Link fixed.
Oh yeah that's weird >.< I fixed it, it should work now, thanks for the heads-up
The Planswalker.
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/oath-of-netsiy?list=user
The Oath
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/drafna-lat-nam-archmage
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/oath-of-drafna
@SpellPiper2213
Zaeri the Watcher - 7/10
Oath of Zaeri - 7,5/10 - 0,5 Similar Oath and Planeswalker
Final media = 7,5/10
@KorandAngels
Ileri of Myth - 7/10
Oath of Ileri - 8/10 - 0,5 Similar Oath and Planeswalker
Final media = 7,75/10
@Jeroukoo
Aelph, Conscript of Selesnya - 6,5/10
Oath of Aelph 8/10 - 0,8 Similar Oath and Planeswalker
Final media = 7,65/10
@ningyounk
Jaine, Selfless Paladin - 8,5/10
Oath of Jaine - 7,5/10 - 0,9 Similar Oath and Planeswalker
Final media = 8,45/10
@Corwinnn
Tomigon, the Tormentor - 6,5/10
Oath of Tomigon - 6,5/10 - 0,5 Similar Oath and Planeswalker
Final media = 6,75/10
@jaceberlin
Netsiy, Memory Stitcher - 6/10
Oath of Netsiy - 6/10 - 0,7 Similar Oath and Planeswalker
Final media = 6,35/10
@TerryTags
Drafna, Lat-Nam Archmage - 7,5/10
Oath of Drafna - 7,5/10 - 0,4 Similar Oath and Planeswalker
Final media = 7,7/10
Overall Rating:
1º @ningyounk - 8,45/10
2º @KorandAngels - 7,75/10
3º @TerryTags - 7,7/10
4º @Jeroukoo - 7,65/10
5º @SpellPiper2213 - 7,5/10
6º @Corwinnn - 6,75/10
7º @jaceberlin - 6,35/10
Thank you. It was my first challenge. I am adapting too and will leave more time in the next ones (probably depending on a card only). I thank you for your participation.
Thanks for the challenge, it was fun and very well-organised
May I request you to favourite those seven cards?
1) http://https//mtgcardsmith.com/view/suicide-doll
2) http://https//mtgcardsmith.com/view/all-who-is-meek
3) http://https//mtgcardsmith.com/view/sharl-demanding-king
4) http://https//mtgcardsmith.com/view/kizz-interplanar-friend
5) http://https//mtgcardsmith.com/view/pattl-the-capricious
6) http://https//mtgcardsmith.com/view/gawar-apex-of-the-wild
7) http://https//mtgcardsmith.com/view/catacomb-hurdler-1
Feel free to exchange any of them with any other card you prefer from my gallery ^^
See you for the next challenge!
You guys have been very welcoming to a new guy like me, and I appreciate being part of a community that is willing to open itself to new people. Thank you to all!!
Here are the three I'd like favorited:
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/privden-obsessed-artist
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/adrihel-the-abandoned
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/kupira-fickle-advokist
And, not that anyone asked, but: these are three planeswalkers from a set I was envisioning which is similar to "The Boys" or "Injustice" or "Leverage" in which the stereotypical villains are trying to reform, and use their -1/-1 counter abilities to bring about goodness; while the stereotypical heroes have become tainted by human frailties and use their +1/+1 counters for selfish (and evil) results.
- Privden was an Izzet guildmember who became obsessed with perfection, to his detriment and the detriment of others when he ends up magically Detaining anyone he was giving compliments to.
- Adrihel was an immortal member of the Selesnya Conclave who started to go mad when her friends and lovers would die and abandon her, so she turns people she helps into Defenders so they won't leave her.
- Kupira was an Orzhov Advokist who became so obsessed with the letter of the law that now she tends to dismiss & banish people who annoy her.
Anyway, thanks! This was fun!!I already put the five favorited. If you want to exchange, just send a direct message with the links of the cards.
@Corwinnn
I dont know if you are the one who closes, but you can consider the challenge as finished.
Thank you all. Any questions can send messages privately without problems.