Comments

• SpellPiper2213

  July 2020

  Out of curiosity, how did my cards score?
• fire12

  July 2020

  Same question as SpellPiper2213 
• Scaccogaming

  July 2020

  I'd like to know my scores as well. Altough, let's be honest. I won't judge about your rates about balance, but Cass' cards, altough they do look cool, are not what you could define as REALISTIC. Also, giving personal preferences isn't exactly fair. 
  
  Tl,dr: I think you misjudged some of the cards given your criteria. I am ok for not winning, but I needed to point out this very fact. 
• CassZero

  July 2020 edited July 2020

  I think it's fair for everyone to have their grades revealed. I imagine it is laborious to do (I felt it in my contests), but it is correct.
  
  As for realism, I agree for one of the cards. (which was not the highest grade)
  The start criteria were also not mentioned, as I could have sent other cards myself.
• joemamajoe

  July 2020

  @SpellPiper2213, first got a 6, second got a 6.5
  
  @fire12, your first was a 4.5 and second was a 4.5
  
• joemamajoe

  July 2020 edited July 2020

  @Scaccogaming, first was 4, second was a 5.5. CassZero got a 1.5 for realism and a 3 for balance on his first one. CassZero second one was a very realistic aftermath card.
  
  @CassZero, I didn’t want to give away everyone’s because maybe some people didn’t want to have their grades revealed to others.
• DrakeGladis

  July 2020

  Shall I post some?
  
  
• DrakeGladis

  July 2020

  
  
  
  
• jaceberlin

  July 2020

  Here they are. 1 is unset though.
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/jace-telepath-supreme-3?list=user
  Many have said this card was a little too strong, but it actually has weaknesses; it can easily be killed with kill spells as it is both a creature and a Planswalker, when attacked by anything with 5+ power, it dies.
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/time-dice-4?list=user
  Ok... The unset one.
  
  
• Fallen_Lord_Vulganos

  July 2020

  Ok then? Here are some... probably good cards of mine, I suppose.
  
  
• Tommyneko

  July 2020

  
  
• MTG_Sappy

  July 2020

  
  UDRE VICIOUS HUNTER; A new Werewolf tribal commander
  
   And a tokens commander from a set I'm currently working on. EDREMON: Battlepunk (steampunk+battlebond).
  
  Anyway, I hope I can become Cardsmith of the century with using MSE :P
  
• SpellPiper2213

  July 2020

  
  (links embedded in images)
• joemamajoe

  July 2020

  @Everyone, Cardsmith of the Century: Week Two winners be announced four days late (on the 27th instead of the 20th). Sorry for the inconvenience.
• TerryTags

  July 2020 edited July 2020

  
  
• joemamajoe

  July 2020 edited July 2020

  @Everyone, this week's
  
  

  CARDSMITH OF THE CENTURY

  
  is none other than... 
  
  @Corwinnn, with Magus of Displacement. Check it out here, and favorite it to show your support: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/magus-of-displacement.
  
  If we're saying runner ups, the runner up would be @Fallen_Lord_Vulganos with Cherryblossom! The only thing I would say about it, not that it matters, but why Graveborn?
  
  Ok, so @Corwinnn is heading to the finals with @CassZero. Six more will join them. Will it be you?
  
  
• Fallen_Lord_Vulganos

  July 2020

  @joemamajoe Well thanks! Also it was due to my lack of care towards the symbol, I suppose. *shrugs*
• fire12

  July 2020

  Well, here's my cards:
  
  I wanted to put the description of mutate on Frozen Sandwurm, but there was not enough space.
• Corwinnn

  July 2020

  Oh Wow, I totally was NOT expecting to win, let alone beat @DrakeGladis or @Fallen_Lord_Vulganos this week, so I'm stoked and looking forward to see who else brings their A game!
• Tommyneko

  July 2020

  
  
• shadow123

  July 2020

  Here are my two entries for this week:
  
  
• SpellPiper2213

  July 2020

  
• Shadaar

  July 2020 edited July 2020

  
• Suicidal_Deity

  July 2020 edited July 2020

  So, I will post one card others have seemed to enjoy, and one card I adore.
  
  1. People enjoy.
  Moxingbird
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/moxingbird
  
  2. I adore.
  Earthworm Jim
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/earthworm-jim-3
  
  
• DrakeGladis

  July 2020

  Hrm...
  Well, I guess that I can try to get something else good in.
  I don't know what I have that can beat my withering blow though.
• DrakeGladis

  July 2020

  
  
• DrakeGladis

  July 2020 edited July 2020

  Also, thanks @Corwinnn for the compliment.  Your work is always brilliant; I hope some day that I can truly measure up.  And just for kicks, what were my points @joemamajoe?
  
• joemamajoe

  July 2020

  @DrakeGladis, I didn’t judge this one. My brother who works at WoTC judged.
• Tomigon

  July 2020

  XD
  Let's see what your brother think about these.
  
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/skillthief
  
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/edea-dreamweaver
  
• MTG_Sappy

  July 2020

  @joemamajoe
  they aren't aloud to look at cuustom designs. How?