MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Post your decks here, actually see what others think
So, this is like the normal feedback
thread (https://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/3627/post-your-cards-here-actually-see-what-others-think/p1), except for decks.
Mine: https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/sir-zndrsplt-aka-how-to-change-the-commander-meta/
thread (https://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/3627/post-your-cards-here-actually-see-what-others-think/p1), except for decks.
Mine: https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/sir-zndrsplt-aka-how-to-change-the-commander-meta/
Comments
I think I have two big questions more than anything.
1: What is the deck trying to do? What is the plan for winning? My view of the deck appears to be mostly a "go wide" strategy with a lot of small damage that stacks up, is that fair?
2: Why 4 color? If my previous assumption about deck strategy is correct, I could very easily see cutting black and/or green from it. I just don't see any specific bombs that justify spreading your mana base so wide.
If you specifically building around the Nephilim, there are three things I see your deck needing to focus on: 1, protecting your commander so it can hit people. 2, making sure you have enough lands to get a good number of tokens. And 3, having payoffs for generating all of the tokens.
In that regard the deck isn't bad at all, it just seems like it's missing a few things. Some stuff like Impact Tremors from red, some anthems and overrun effects from white and green, and some on-death triggers from black. Also some kind of bomb to spend all the mana you'll have from your lands, and artifacts/Ashnod's altar.