Ravnica third age commons finished... Advices are Needed

RavnicaRavnica
in Custom Card Sets
Hello, I'm Milanaarz
Maybe you already now I'm working on a Ravnica : Third Age set that should represent the five RTR guilds a milliena later.
I finished the 60 guild-related commons of this set (I'll still have to make non guild commons)
I'll be playtesting them this week-end, but I'd like to have external advices.
Are the cards balanced (for limited especially)? The synergies bad/good? (not) Interesting?
Any comment is welcome. Please take a look:
http://mtgcardsmith.com/user/Ravnica

Comments

  • GelectrodeGelectrode
    I personally love all of the cards shown because they are all so creative. Do you need help with the set? If so, I would love to participate.
  • RavnicaRavnica
    @gelectrode Thanks. And actually, yes. This was at the beginnig an open account where anyone could make cards, but wasn't so successful. The password is "guildpact". I'll comment every card that will be made on this account (powerlevel, wording...). I especially have a hard time coming up with rares and mythics... So if you want to help, you're welcome!
  • fraziel07fraziel07
    Hey Mil, I have a card for Rakdos I want you to look at if it's possible. I have a few I want to bring to the set but want your feedback.

    http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/fiend-juggler?list=user
  • TheCopyrightContinuumTheCopyrightContinuum
    You only mentioned five of the ten guilds; would the other five be in another set?
  • Blacktyger00Blacktyger00
    I am intrigued by this. I'd love to help make some stuff for this, also it would be helpful to list signature abilities of each guild. Also, are we only doing Izzet, Rakdos, Selesnya, Golgari, and Azorius?? I wanted to do Gruul too.
  • GelectrodeGelectrode
    Dibs on Izzet. I love that ability SOOO much!
  • RavnicaRavnica
    @TheCopyrightContinuum
    Yes, if this set is finished someday...
  • RavnicaRavnica
    edited September 2015
    Hello! I'm glad some of you are interested in this set! At the moment I won't be able to check this more that once or twice a week.

    I'll put some rules :

    First the obvious one : No one deletes a card without its creators authorisation (Please... respect each other)

    Then the formal : always use the dimond edition symbol and the m15 frame

    Since I want this set to be balanced in every format (especially limited) and the wording to be correct, I'll ask you to add the cards to the sets (golgari rares, selesnya commons etc) only with my aprouval (sorry for that). Sometimes, I'll remake some of your cards to be more balanced or with a good wording, so if possible leave an art link. And since we will use the same account, put your name in the commentaries.

    And I can do mistakes too. English is not my motherlanguage, so if you notice something wrong, or if you have an idea for a flavor text, feel free to comment...

    Milanaarz
  • RavnicaRavnica
    @fraziel07 Thanks. If you want, you can make cards directly with the account, just do not add them to the set immediatly...
This discussion has been closed.