MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Commander: Adjunct Challenge (This'll be interesting.)
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
The cards themselves, I don't want ro review right now, so here's the gist: Sisay, while I like the reference, and it really fits the original, is REALLY friggin powerful. Like, Kaalia of the Vast powerful.
Cleridra is a very white, very angel card, but as a legendary, since she only prevents damage, I would suggest lowering her p/t to 3/4 and making her cost 5. She would then be significantly better.
That's all Imma put into this.
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/cleridra-the-dawnbringer-1?list=user
please tell me about any mistakes I made, oh, and colud you check out the cards I have on the "epic elves" thread, and maybe leave a review? not a demand, but a request, just saying.
XD
@TheCopyrightContinuum wins for defeating the point of adjunct.
@Tomigon wins for confusing me.
@Animist wins because I say so.
It's a three way tie. No prizes. XD
No seriously. I'll go score these cards now, using whatever scale I want, and get back to you later. You three haven't actually won (yet).
Sorry for lying to ya!
I sat and debated with myself for the longest time about how to score this stuff, and then I realized it wasn't a contest at first, so I have no obligation to be unbiased. (Scumbag Crucible, I know.)
I would write huge reviews on all the cards, but then I'd have to justify my choices, so I won't.
First place to @Animist , literally because I said so. I liked Nuruka, Second to One more than all the other cards submitted here, and I honestly don't know why. Probably the art. :P
Second place to @GodOfWar for Tesskre, Word of Betrayal. I picked this one because it's the only card that took advantage of the inevitable adjunct deck without outright exploiting it. Is what I would say. In reality, he just makes it so much worse. Now, you don't even have to pay the extra commander costs, you just bounce all your legendaries out of the graveyard for the rest of the game. Congratulations, for breaking adjunct more than anyone else.
Third place was very nearly a tie, but I decided I wasn't going to have a tie, so I flipped a coin. You will never know who the other Cardsmith was. @koover with Vexar, Butcher of Rakdos takes third place. For reasons. (I'm really starting to hate myself for this.) He seemed balanced, I liked the idea of Peonage, and he had a reason to be an Adjunct, functionally and flavorfully. Why did you get the most praise, when you took third place? Now i'm confusing myself! Anyways stuff.
Honorable Mentions: Everyone who bothered to post. Yes, even you, @Corwinnn
You make it worth every second of wasting your time. I could probably do this without you, but it isn't nearly as fun if no one insults me. Don't you just love it when I'm an a**hole openly? Neither do I. *sigh*
Because I'm feeling particularly dastardly today, all three of you get the same prize. However, you three have to decide what that prize is. This'll be fun, @Animist @GodOfWar @koover XD
How about one custom card with three characters? @Animist @GodOfWar
e.g. Triad of WhateverYou'llFigureOutSomethingCool
XD
Http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/urox-dralnus-pawn-1?list=user
@Animist @koover @GodOfWar
Here's the reward card. After listening to what you had to say, I rebalanced it a bit.
It's as good as I could make it, so throw things @Corwinnn, not me.
Godhead Triumvirate
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/godhead-triumvirate-1
That's right, Corwinnn, I did it. If it's underwhelming, you have only yourself to blame.
Anyway, sorry for sucking.
This Discussion is Closed. I promise.