wishes card set: charms, commands, and other decisions!

Comments

• stormbreath

  October 2015

  here are a few cards based in the set, to give you some tips: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/collective-wish?list=user
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/the-wishmaker-1?list=user
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/one-final-wish-1?list=user
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/wishmakers-charm?list=user
  and here is the link to the set:http://mtgcardsmith.com/user/stormbreath/sets/3169
• Tomigon

  October 2015

  Thanks for calling me!
  I just made this card for 5 color card challenge.
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/maelstrom-invocation-1?list=user
  
  And this is an idea that I kept in my mind for a while..
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/blessed-breeze-3
  What do you think? It's using old mechanic called "Fading."
  Fading N (This permanent enters the battlefield with N fade counters on it. At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from it. If you can't, sacrifice it.)
  You can't choose everything, so it forces you decisions.
• stormbreath

  October 2015

  @Tomigon nice idea, can you try and contact all the others? the first call may not be enough.
• stormbreath

  October 2015

  @Tomigon, also, wishes have two prongs- making decisions, and getting more powerful based upon the number of creatures on the field, sort of like homicidal seclucion, but in reverse(like battilion from the return to ravnica block, but active all the time. metalcraft is the best anology I can think of. call it camarade or something like that.
• Corwinnn

  October 2015

  @stormbreath - I'm working on cleaning up a set I'm currently working on (plus my usual 12 hours away from home) so give me a couple of days and I'll bring you some cards!
• stormbreath

  October 2015

  @Corwinn thanks, you four are the best card creators I know on this site, so I expect great things from you!(also, I expect constructive critizism from everyone on some of the cards that I make, also, a few of the cards above are rough drafts(possibly) so cut me some slack.)
• Gelectrode

  October 2015

  Does this card make sense?
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/primordials-insight
• stormbreath

  October 2015 edited October 2015

  @Gelectrode no, I would make it a bulleted list to make sense, It is also OP, try six +1/+1 counters.
• CrucibleOfHate

  October 2015

  @stormbreath I'm not that good of a Cardsmith, I just know all the rules. XD
  Also, seven mana to give a creature +10/+10 doesn't seem to OP to me.
• CrucibleOfHate

  October 2015

  Make A Wish
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/make-a-wish-1
  
  The second thing that came to mind. The first was a bad idea.
• stormbreath

  October 2015 edited October 2015

  @CrucibleOfHate, the thing is, it's a choose TWO effects, at least I think it is, nice card by the way, a focus that I thought no one would explore.(also, I want to see all of your ideas, even bad ones, they could become very good.)
• stormbreath

  October 2015

  here is a new cycle of wishes that I am working on:
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/wish-for-redemption
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/wish-for-vengance
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/wish-for-power
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/wish-for-knowledge
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/wish-for-strength
  a wish cycle, showing of the other form of wishes!
• Gelectrode

  October 2015

  My card is slightly tricky: you get to choose an effect for yourself, but you also have to choose an effect for an opponent as well; look closely at the card.
• stormbreath

  October 2015

  ah, thanks for telling me. that balances it out nicely,but can kill some decks(draw to mill)
• stormbreath

  October 2015

  oh, by the way, there is no limit to how many cards you create. just post them all!
• flamelordytheking

  October 2015

  I hope that this isn't to o.p.
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/silent-steps
• stormbreath

  October 2015

  um, guys, you can post more cards, you know
• Corwinnn

  October 2015

  We weren't sure you were ready for more cards....
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/bad-wish-1?list=user
• Corwinnn

  October 2015

  These are older cards... obviously
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/wish-bottle-1
  XD
• Corwinnn

  October 2015 edited October 2015

  And a new one...
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/wish-upon-a-squirrel-1?list=user
• stormbreath

  November 2015

  just so you know, I want cycles of cards, like the wish for cycle above.
  here is another cycle card. create the other members of the cycle.
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/wish-of-the-knight?list=user
• Corwinnn

  November 2015

  Oh.. cycles! If I get time before you close this out, I will work on that (I'm at work all day today and I have a contest to judge later but there are only three entries, so that should be easy enough)
• stormbreath

  November 2015 edited November 2015

  I will not close this out until there are to many cards for me to choose from, or no one comments on this thread for a year, whichever comes first(latter will likely be the only reason I close the thread most likely, will probably hold semi-relevant contests based on sub-forms of wishes(auras, commands, charms, cards likeMight of the Masses, and Homicidal Seclusion) and I will choose any number of cards to enter my set once the thread ends
• Corwinnn

  November 2015

  Oh, okay then!
• stormbreath

  November 2015 edited November 2015

  so please, post whatever you want that is relevant. but remember, the three forms of wishes deal with choices, other wishes, and creatures based on number.(i.e. Might of the Masses or Inspiring Call)
  also, first semi-relevant challenge will be posted on seperate thread, but the theme is to fill in a card for the "wish of the(insert Planeswalker title here)" cycle! any and all cards are welcome!
  here is the thread: http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/770/wish-of-the-planeswalker-make-an-enchant-planeswalker-or-creature
• stormbreath

  November 2015

  the "wish of the (insert planeswalker title here)" is a bit of an enigma, but makes sense from a lore standpoint. also, a few other points to consider for card creation would be creatures/artifacts dealing with wishes.
• stormbreath

  January 2016

  two notes: all winners of my monthly challenges have their cards added two this growing set, and that the wish of the (planeswalker title) is something very similar to the Oath of (Planeswalker).