Official Contest - Warlock Mayhem

bnew07 · May 2018

pjbear2005 · May 2018

@mtgcardsmith

Does my entry count because it is a flip?

Scott_Anderson · May 2018

I think mine will be a flip too.

pjbear2005 · May 2018

@Scott_Anderson I don't know if they count flips

Scott_Anderson · May 2018

Yes, the rules still feel incomplete.

baryonyx69 · May 2018

I still have not heard if I can take mine out and put in an edited one.

Bobman111 · May 2018

CastorCrozz · May 2018

Here is the link to my entry, Covenant of Vengeance:
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/covenant-of-vengeance

CastorCrozz · May 2018

And @baryonyx69 -
I am afraid that you cannot retract your submission to change it.

Taken from the first page (Italics & bolds added):

"You may only enter one card, so search your grimoire well. Cards may be directly edited (premium) on the same submission URL until the final day of the contest, but you cannot re-post/enter more than once."

I believe that this means you cannot re-post the same card. I wish you could, because that's a real feel-bad thing to realize, though. If your only problem is that you didn't credit the artist, you could try crediting them in the comments on your submission.

Dechujoh64 · May 2018

@CastorCrozz So a good portion of people are screwed up if they get one small thing wrong and want to change. Thanks, mtgcardsmith. A rule to screw over people, cool.

TenebrisNemo · May 2018

Corwinnn · May 2018

@Lastjustice - I'm trying to forget about those times...
:::sniffles:::
That one is still fresh in my mind...
;(

Corwinnn · May 2018

@Baryonyx69 & @Dechujoh64 - @CastorCrozz is right.
Without that rule, it becomes insanity trying to keep track of everyone's entries. The new rule allowing edits does let people "skirt" their mistakes. Anyone who is serious about winning, and there are quite a few of them, will work on their cards until they think it's perfect, and then they analyze it some more (see @KrampisZman) until they enter it right near the end of the Challenge. Others (see @Corwinnn) really just want that sweet Avatar!

Scott_Anderson · May 2018

@corwinnn can we do flip cards? Is there any chance a token would win?

Corwinnn · May 2018

@Scott_Anderson - My best guess, is that you CAN enter a flip card, but I like to use a Chopped analogy in situations like this... If you have a chicken challenge, and you make chicken two ways, you get judged on BOTH chickens. It would really stink if you had the best chicken AND the worst chicken on the same plate.