Weekly Challenge: A Charming Challenge!

Comments

• stormbreath

  October 2015

  @Nicholas_Bolas so, my charm isn't viable?
• Gelectrode

  October 2015

  Too powerful?
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/coalition-charm
• CrucibleOfHate

  October 2015

  @Gelectrode I think it's balanced, but you didn't say which mana (one less mana of any color) and you need three choices to qualify for the challenge.
• Gelectrode

  October 2015

  Yes there are three choices
• CrucibleOfHate

  October 2015

  @Gelectrode To right it correctly in your format:
  
  Choose one: You gain 7 life, draw a card, and target player loses life equal to the number of cards in your hand; or Coalition charm deals 4 damage to target creature and another target creature gets +3/+3 until end of turn.
  
  There should have been a semicolon where you had a comma, so I inserted it, but there is only one "or" so only two options.
• Nicholas_Bolas

  October 2015

  @stormbreath It is not. If you change it to a three-option, choose-one instant, then it would be.
• Nicholas_Bolas

  October 2015

  @Gelectrode @CrucibleOfHate Crucible is correct.
• Animist

  October 2015

  Vast Charm
  
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/vast-charm?list=user
• Nicholas_Bolas

  October 2015

  @Gelectrode @CrucibleOfHate However, if Gelectrode wanted it to be three options, he could reword it: Choose one: You gain 7 life; or draw a card, then target player loses life equal to the number of cards in your hand; or Coalition Charm deals 4 damage to target creature and another target creature gets +3/+3 until end of turn.
• stormbreath

  October 2015

  @nicholas_Bolas can you do a command challenge next week?
• Nicholas_Bolas

  October 2015

  @stormbreath Probably not next week, but I will do one eventually, if you continue to keep track of my weeklys you will see it.
• stormbreath

  October 2015

  @Nicholas_Bolas thank you!
• lookingupanddown

  October 2015

  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/impulse-charm?list=user
• Wagegeo

  October 2015

  Here you go!
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/illusionists-charm
• Gelectrode

  October 2015

  Here, to avoid more confusion:
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/delban-charm
• Nicholas_Bolas

  October 2015

  Thank you all for entering, sorry for the confusion.
  My next contest is the Lost Legends Challenge: http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/761/weekly-challenge-lost-legends
  
  The winner for creativity is Gelectrode, with Delban Charm!
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/delban-charm
  Congratulations Gelectrode!
  
  The winner for flavor is leo5873, with Illuminati Charm!
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/illuminati-charm
  Congratulations leo5873!
  
  I hope you guys keep enjoying my contests!
• Nicholas_Bolas

  October 2015

  This discussion is closed.