Battle for the Best (Creature Type)

Comments

• Ranshi

  February 2019

  Exactly, it is situational about when it is worthy of being mythic rare. A card like this can't have a cheapening effect or it would just be blatantly OP.
• ArinSka

  February 2019

  
  
  @pjbear2005
  
  Hey, Jpa--I mean...PJ. Could I get a new challenge?
• Bowler218

  February 2019

  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/kaylessa-woodland-guardian
  PJ, may kitty haz box? Wait! Wrong thing, may I have a new challenge?
• MemoryHead

  February 2019 edited February 2019

  This formerly contained a contribution to the conversation over whether Dungeon Party was too weak / powerful, but I then saw the conversation had ended so I've replaced it with this message. Sorry.
• MittoMan

  February 2019

  Where has @pjbear2005 gone?
• pjbear2005

  February 2019

  Oof, I will work on some challenges
• Warlord_Cyro

  February 2019

  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/cards_ip/1550183451162988.png?t=700021
  
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/complete/full/2019/2/14/1550185108727866.png
  
  https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/complete/full/2019/2/14/1550186545155735.png
  
  How do post the pictures here? oh well. Tell me if they are good.
• Mantis17

  February 2019

  Hydra.
• MemoryHead

  February 2019

  @Warlord_Cyro One of them displays error 404 so I can't help you there. Angelic Slayer uses +2/+2 counters, which haven't been a thing for about 20 years and were officially phased out of existence. It needs to be "two +1/+1 counters".
  
  Purity's Answer needs to be an instant so that you can actually play it at a time when the tokens can attack and probably needs to say "cast Purity's Answer only at the beginning of combat on your turn. That's a mouthful though so it might be easier just to give them haste or something even though it's off-colour. Admittedly, the card as a whole is off colour so that's fine.
• Warlord_Cyro

  February 2019

  thanks will fix, also which card is an error 404?
• MittoMan

  February 2019 edited February 2019

  @pjbear2005 can I have a challenge, and perhaps an assessment on the cards?
• MemoryHead

  February 2019

  @Warlord_Cryo The one other than Angelic Slayer and Purity's Answer. I don't know what it's called because it's gone for whatever reason.
• Warlord_Cyro

  February 2019

  its called Mela, angel guard. on my page
• MemoryHead

  February 2019

  @Warlord_Cyro Oh yeah, not sure why it doesn't work from the link on here. The second ability needs to give a +1/+1 counter or read "Mela gets +1/+1 as long as you control two or more Angels". Also, the flavour text probably needs speech marks.
• MittoMan

  February 2019

  So, I take it this thread has died?
• MemoryHead

  February 2019 edited February 2019

  @MittoMan Not sure whether it's actually dead, but it's certainly unconscious.
• MittoMan

  February 2019

  I hope not, this was enjoyable
  
  @pjbear2005 where have you gone?
• pjbear2005

  February 2019

  I'm on it! I have to change some rules around and then I will be back!
• pjbear2005

  February 2019

  New Rules:
  You get a new challenge every time you finish one and ask.
  Deadlines will now be every couple of weeks.
  New prizes will be given according to the new rules.
  
  If you have any questions ask me.
  
  New challenges soon.
• sorinjace

  February 2019

  Is this still a thing? Because I completely forgot about it.