Cursed by the Crimson Moon (Tommian Monthly Challenge for October, Premium Prize!)

2»

Comments

  • edited October 2019
    imageimage
  • *HMMMMM*
  • imageimage
    This is an odd one...
  • Attendance was a little underwhelming with this one. I'll definitely pick a grand prize winner, but the rest will be tbd. If you have any last second entries, I could be a few days late, so sneak them in!
  • edited November 2019
    @Tommia don't mind if I do ;)
    imageimage
    I got the idea of this from Pirates of the Caribbean Curse of the Black Pearl
  • OK! I finally got back to this, so it's time to announce the grand prize winner.

    @ASubtleGhost @JackDraco You guys made my job pretty difficult. In the end, it was between two cards that make you think strategically about how you want to play, with great payoffs when you do. Both Maddened Skulker/Nightmare Screecher and Kai have deep strategy, but overall, when I looked at things, I had to flip my perspective to the player on the receiving end.

    Which do I want to see? Maddened Skulker can pull shenanigans to get transformed without attacking, but Kai can just say "Boom. I'm transformed." Overall, Kai could get pretty out-of-hand, which is something minor in a less competitive setting, but in Modern or Commander... this can get incredibly painful very quickly. Overall, I'll be handing the victory to @ASubtleGhost!

    imageimage

    With Maddened Skulker, the opponent(s) has a much higher level of control, and it's possible for the Skulker to transform by their hand as well (unintentionally and intentionally.) Both of these cards have a presence, but Maddened Skulker definitely seems like something that's more likely to be printed.



    @ASubtleGhost Please PM me with the username of the cardsmith you would like to receive premium. It can be you, or someone else. Just say the name.
  • Late reply here, but thanks @Tommia for the contest and for consideration! Congrats @ASubtleGhost!
This discussion has been closed.