MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
The Legendary Brawl (Enter Now!)
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
You get 5 favorites of your choice and a follow.
The most creative card goes to @spookoops's Winston Old Mage.
You get 3 favorites of your choice.
The most Balanced card goes to @Undead's Uther, the Wolfish Baron.
You get 3 favorites of your choice.
Here are everyone's scores (B=balance, C=creativity)
Every card that got a total of 21 points.
@TheWanderer
Sally, Assistant to Maro
B:10 C:11 = 21
Every card that got a total of 20 points.
@Shadaar
Rhune of the Arkblade
B:8 C:12 = 20
@KorandAngels
Senture, Wandering Assassin
B:10 C:10 = 20
@skookoops
Winston, Old Mage
B:7 C:13 = 20
Bianca, Chef of Fancies
B:10 C:10 = 20
@Undead
Uther, the Wolfish Baron
B:9 C:11 = 20
Every card that got a total of 19 points.
@Faiths_Guide
Forga Rade, Profiteer
B:10 C:9 = 19
@Mir-151414
Talero of the Fiery Fist
B:10 C:9 = 19
@Fallen_Lord_Vulganos
Huntsmaster Einhar
B:9 C:10 = 19
@Ranshi
Fiore, Bearer of Potential/Fiore, Scathed Star
B:9 C:10 = 19
@brcien
Adrius with Sight
B:9 C:10 = 19
@Undead
Eunike, Follower of Elspeth
B:9 C:10 = 19
@samshala
Nina, Ancestor’s Champion
B:11 C:8 = 19
@Shadaar
Rhett, Rubbleveil Roilmage
B:9 C:10 = 19
@Crabbycabbage
Gvi, Brutal Warlor
B:10 C:9 = 19
Every card that got a total of 18 points.
@TheWanderer
Bartleby, Obstinate Scribe
B:9 C:9 = 18
@ArchieTaylor
Amia, Who Leads the Stampede
B:9 C:9 = 18
@zamshala
Tirala, Beast Swinger
B:10 C:8 = 18
Dareem Dragonclaw
B:9 C:9 = 18
@Scaccogaming
Yukaari, the Masted Beauty
B:10 C:8 = 18
Nataliya, the Self-Made Army
B:8 C:10 = 18
@Potato13
Shalla, Cleric Outcast
B:9 C:9 = 18
Every card that got a total of 17 points.
@Faiths_Guide
Orut Rade
B:9 C:8 = 17
@Mir-151414
Gorrad, One Who Sacrfices
B:8 C:9 = 17
@KorandAngels
Nadain, Coin Counter
B:9 C:8 = 17
@Fallen_Lord_Vulganos
Kesava, Duelist Adept
B:9 C:8 = 17
@spookoops
Nadar Dulra, Cryptolith Madman
B:9 C:8 = 17
@Crabbycabbage
Sandia, Boros Purifier
B:8 C:9 = 17
Every card that got a total of 16 points.
Glint-Claw, Nezumi Shaman
B:10 C:6 = 16
@Fallen_Lord_Vulganos
Grigor, Brain Collector
B:8 C:8 = 16
@Ranshi
Hat Guy, Dancy Maniac
B:6 C:10 = 16
Every card that got a total of 15 points.
@Faiths_Guide
Ohnia Rade
B:8 C:7 = 15
@Ranshi
Cie, the Frozen Heart/Cie the Burning Heart
B:6 C:9 = 15
@Scaccogaming
Gulmat, Halfblood Juggernaut
B:8 C:7 = 15
Every card that got a total of 14 points.
@ArchieTaylor
Chuchau, the Hidden Syndicate
B:6 C:8 = 14
Lami, Woodland Stream Patron
B:8 C:6 = 14
@KorandAngels
Deathseeker Rerrel
B:7 C:7 = 14
Every card that got a total of 13 points.
@Mir-151414
Gradan, Patron of the Wild
B:7 C:6 = 13
Stay tuned for next month's challenge which is starting in 3 days!
If you feel that I judged unfairly please send me a private message explaining in detail how you think I went wrong.
How about now?
Right... I completely missed that that wasn't a human...
I'm just going to let it pass because I've already judged and I would have to break up a tie in order to get a knew champion.
but thanks for noticing.
From now on there will be none of this happening. I will be strict with the rules from this point on. but just this once I will let it go
you all get an additional 2 favorites of your choice because of my mistake. (since one of you would have been the champion if I had noticed that Sally was a squirrel not a human.)
Please fave
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/badger-hospitable-steward
and
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ukhals-follower
https://mtgcardsmith.com/user/spookoops/sets/46476
what third champion?
could you favorite these 2 please?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/hit-squad
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/alphric-the-disembodied
You still got 2 days dude, two days
Oh... right. Wow. I really forgot about the whole humans-only thing. Sorry about that - I focused so much on the CMC part of it that the rest slipped my brain.
it's fine, I'm letting it count just this once
besides, it's my fault for not noticing
When a joke card won I sorta stopped caring about the Human rule and the ratings in general XD
It probably won't happen very often. But yeah it was really hard when I finished judging I had like 6 cards with the same total points and I had to give one of them 1 more point... Sally just managed to win by a hairsbreadth
The points thing isn't always going to be accurate or consistent. it's just the way of judging that I use. there are flaws in it (more then I care to admit) but I try to be fair with it all.
If you believe that I was not fair on a card, like I said PM me and I will explain why I gave it the amount of point is did. (so far no one has PM'd me so I have to assume that everyone is 'ok' with my judging)
Does anyone have any requests/ideas for the next challenge? I'm kinda short on ideas at the moment.
I will take requests/ideas today and tomorrow and consider them.
An idea: A four-colour legendary creature with an ability which requires a sacrifice?
A monocoloured legendary creature with a keyword that usually isn't used in that colour?
Just brainstorming here.
A creature with an activated ability that's cost is of a different color than the creature.
Or
A creature with an activated ability with X in its mana cost.
Or
A non-hydra creature with X in its casting cost.
I will announce it in two days, it begins when I announce it.
CHALLENGE 3, MARCH 2020
Create:
Up to one Legendary Sliver creature with converted mana cost 5-6.
Up to one Legendary Scarecrow creature with converted mana cost 7-10.
Up to one Legendary Shapeshifter creature with converted mana cost 0-4.
Rules:
1: Old cards are allowed.
2: Only Legendary Creatures are acceptable.
3: No MTG artwork.
4: Have fun, and may the best card win!
I am changing the scoring and prizes this time around, instead of have a champion, a most creative, and a most balanced card. I am going to have a Sliver champion, a Scarecrow champion, and a Shapeshifter champion.
Each of the 3 winners will get a follow and 4 favorites of their choice.
For judging I will be judging on a scale of 1-10 instead of 1-15.
Judging begins March 26, 2020
Here is my Sliver entry
Edit: I was so excited that I forgot to add a power/toughness lmao