MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Circuit contest (5): #1 Monthly. This month's theme: Commander.
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
Relentless Invasion
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/relentless-invasion
@Faiths_Guide , similarly, we try to check day to day, any changes a person has made to their set (incl. the addition of new cards), so there's no urgency to notify us here.
But thanks guys - it's thoughtful.
@Cryptonight
@Suicidal_Deity
I've decided to make a new set. I bore easily, and my last one was controversial. I'll keep you posted.
I thought yours was quite interesting, you sure you don't want to keep it?
Power level concerns. I tried to balance out the obvious power with the uncertainty of top-decking, but it's just too easy to manipulate what's on top of deck. The new one has a lot of the same themes, though.
@Cryptonight
@Suicidal_Deity
http://mtgcardsmith.com/account/sets/7837
The Dolmen of Yig, as with so many magical sites, has been used for centuries by the Izzet to attempt spells beyond their limits. Occupying a weak point in the planes, it pulls mana from these other realities to fuel its user's attempts, but such mana is unstable at best and downright dangerous at worst. Creatures from the Blind Eternities are also drawn to the Dolmen, given flesh and purpose by the spells which roar through it.
P.S. I'm sorry for resubmitting my set. I liked the old one (and I'm keeping the cards), but they relied on the uncertainty of deck order to justify their outsize power levels, and there are just too many ways to game that. I kept the land-commander theme and the randomness, but changed it to UR coin flips from G topdecking.
P.P.S. The cards involve a LOT of math-hammer in the comments; if you have any questions about that or would like additional math hammered out, just say.
P.P.P.S. Chance Encounter isn't a thing in the universe where these cards are published.
Your link doesn't work
("not it" - to catalog
http://mtgcardsmith.com/user/Kotadis/sets/7871
Based on commander Sael, and the concept of mono black swarm. Sael is supposed to be an undead soul warden that captures the restless souls of the meek to battle with him even after their death. Supposedly he would get stronger with each tool he is in control of.
Gartrian, Budding Hero
Now to make support cards!
It's fixed ;D
(*Edit - sorry, I just noticed your comment. I guess that's a folder for all of your circuit entries... can you create a new set just for the EDH challenge please? It would make it easier to evaluate as a whole.)
@fabiocbinbutter , can't wait to see it. You can link a set with a single card in it, and simply add support cards to the set as you create them. We will see them.
@Creeper333_ , remember to leave a small comment under each card, so that you get notified when we communicate / leave comments. Makes things easier
(I wonder if a notification gets sent out when you edit and add a new "@" tag...)
Elynia, Kindle of Growth
http://mtgcardsmith.com/user/fabiocbinbutter/sets/7982
This is my set... Made for a monocolor White angel commander set.
Btw Sarianna is my commander of choice.
Thanks for the suggestions! Re-did the cards mostly along the lines you suggested!
Sorry, your entries have disqualified due to the art rule. The only card we can currently accept is "Life and Death".
@Creeper333_
"Mind Blown" needs some fixing
@Superman101
I need you to re-consider this rule: - MAKE ONLY NEW CARDS! Every card submitted must be made for the purpose of this contest, to show off your innovative cardsmithing skills!
I can see how it could be interpreted as "this contest" aka "all circuit contests", but we're talking this contest specifically - I do believe 2 or 3 of those cards you posted are not eligible?