Circuit contest (5): #1 Monthly. This month's theme: Commander.

13»

Comments

  • Faiths_GuideFaiths_Guide
    @BradXmagic
    Don't forget to leave comments below each card so the judges can notify you of a comment on them.
  • BradXmagicBradXmagic
    It won't let me comment on it, I go onto my cards, click on them, and it shows the comments, but nowhere to leave one...
  • CryptonightCryptonight
    edited March 2016
    @BradXmagic , it could be that you don't have a Disqus account.

    There must be some place where you see something like " Log-in to comment ".

    You can create one in a matter of seconds - maybe a minute or two, and it'll be worth it to be able communicate with others about your cards, in general.

    (I recommend making your Disqus account with the same name as your MtGCardsmith - BradXmagic, so that others will easily be able to recognize you.)
  • BradXmagicBradXmagic
    Awesome, thanks!
  • DomriKadeDomriKade
    As per usual, here's my entry right before the deadline:
    Saorise, Siren Exemplar

    Thanks for such an in-depth challenge! This was fun to put together.
  • CryptonightCryptonight
    edited March 2016
    @fabiocbinbutter , you need ( 1 ) more card in your set or it won't meet the minimum requirements and it'll be disqualified :( - there is less than a week before the deadline.
  • CryptonightCryptonight
    edited March 2016
    @Superman101 , you need ( 3 ) more cards in your set or it won't meet the minimum requirements and it'll be disqualified :( - there is less than a week before the deadline.
  • CryptonightCryptonight
    @BradXmagic , no problem. Did you sign up for your Disqus account? Try leaving a comment under your commander. ;)
  • BradXmagicBradXmagic
    I go to leave a comment, it says sign in with disqus. I logged in, and it said invalid, I have been trying over and over, but it says the email is in use so I can't log in.
    Just forget about me when you go to choose the winner.
  • CryptonightCryptonight
    @BradXmagic , we won't forget about you (and it doesn't disqualify you at all), but it's unfortunate that we can't exchange thoughts on your cards more interactively.

    It sounds like maybe the email address you used already had a(nother) Disqus account associated, or else maybe you've blocked Disqus cookies.
  • CryptonightCryptonight
    @Latinas , you need ( 1 ) more card in your set or it won't meet the minimum requirements and it'll be disqualified :( - there is less than a week before the deadline.
  • Superman101Superman101
    @grimshac
    That set is cards for all the circuit contests-I'm only entering Gartrian. I'll say in my comments which card I'm entering.
  • fabiocbinbutterfabiocbinbutter
    @Cryptonight - I added my last card, hopefully it's not too late
  • CryptonightCryptonight
    @fabiocbinbutter , perfectly on time - thanks!
  • GrimshacGrimshac
    Hello everyone, and sorry about my absence. I had a tech-breakdown during my trip, so the contest results will be delayed, but worry not, they will come soon.

    I have extended the judging period to the 10th of April. On the 11th of April, we will announce the results of the contest. There are a lot of cards and we will do our utmost to judge fairly and consider everything, within reason.

    Thank you everyone for participating, and thank you to @Cryptonight for running upkeep in my absence.

  • Faiths_GuideFaiths_Guide
    So no more entries beyond this point?
  • GrimshacGrimshac
    @Faiths_Guide

    If you have a last-minute hail mary, go for it - I'm being a little extra large on this one since it is the first monthly contest and not even any of the judges had a firm grasp of exactly how the scale of things would pan out.

    Anyway, people can still turn in cards for another EIGHTEEN HOURS - because I have decided that it is that way ;p
  • Faiths_GuideFaiths_Guide
    edited March 2016
    I really just wanted to remake one so 18 hours is plenty :P

    (remade Tombstones Undoing)
  • GrimshacGrimshac
    Hello everyone! I just want to let you know that we're going to postpone the judging for a bit - Lots of cards, little time right now for any of the judges to coordinate and actually get to talking about the cards. That said - Fear not! Judging WILL come, at latest middle of April, even if I have to do it myself (which I doubt!) :)

    In the meanwhile, I'll be making a mini-challenge to keep people interested.
  • Faiths_GuideFaiths_Guide
    Good job!
  • BradXmagicBradXmagic
    @Grimshac

    So... What's going on?
  • GrimshacGrimshac
    @BradXMagic

    Nothing currently - It's looking dim right now for the judge proceedings - I'll update in a few days with the final decision but it is like we'll have to go against all my principles and leave this contest unjudged, sadly.
  • Faiths_GuideFaiths_Guide
    Hard to come to an agreement on this one was it? Maybe it was just to ambitious in terms of how many cards were being entered?
  • BradXmagicBradXmagic
    @Grimshac

    Ok, thanks for the contest though!

    @Faiths_Guide

    There were a lot of good entries...
  • Faiths_GuideFaiths_Guide
    @BradXmagic

    True!
  • GrimshacGrimshac
    @Faiths_Guide

    None of the judges (myself included) really had the time we thought we had - So it was a choice between half-assed judging or no judging at all, and frankly, I'd rather not judge at all and then re-do it some time into the future and do it properly.
    I completely overshot and the scope of the contest became too big, which I take full responsibility for. It happens :c

    The next monthly contest will be "as big", but in a different manner. Probably fewer cards per entree and a less broad subject - A more specific design challenge in mind so judging will be easier to process. I'm mulling on it, but I will bring back the regular circuit by monday/tuesday next week, so eh.

    Sorry everyone - Mistakes were made!
  • Faiths_GuideFaiths_Guide
    No problem, thanks for taking everyone into consideration when getting this all figured out. We (I) haven't lost faith in you @Grimshac!
This discussion has been closed.