MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Embodiment of a Song (Judging Phase)
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
Know how you feel, but @Tommia's request is reasonable.
Cool stuff. Oh, and congrats on your Tribal Trouble Victory!
Thanks! It was fun.
Also... I made this... http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/angels-vengeance-1
1st - Black Hole Sun - 9/10
2nd - Unusual - 8/10
3rd - Toxicity - 7/10
1st - Angel of the Skyways - 9.5/10
2nd - Limitless Potential - 8.5/10
3rd - Shinobu, Heart Under Blade - 7.25/10
1st - The Spirit Carries On - 9.5/10
Http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/my-house-1
Thanks to everyone who voted... however, since we didn't get enough votes, looks like it's time for me to vote and tally up all the votes.
Rock/Folk:
Confrontation (9.7): Ouch! This can really suck for a defensive deck. No way to really describe how good it is until you play it! Only thing I'd wager is that it should cost a little more due to it's potential. Should I attack and leave myself defenseless? Or should I stay safe and lose life?
Storm the Sorrow (9.5): This could have some fun interactions. First off, it's a major risk vs. reward card. Second, life loss! Lastly, I'd like to see what chaos ensues if this were to be destroyed! A very nice, very simple card.
The Victor (9) Now this one just speaks "charge!" to me. This can lead to a major strategic battle: should I have my opponent gain life, or shall I lose life? A major discouragement to chump blocking. It's majorly undercosted though.
Pop/Electronic:
Limitless Potential (10): That's one way to top scry. I'd love to have this card any day. Nothing wrong to see here. It even has a balanced benefit if you pay 0 for X!
Light in the Dark (8.5): It was a hard decision between this and Lunera, but this one took the cake in my opinion. Though overcosted in my opinion, it's effect is very nice, and it has an elegant flavor.
Angel of the Skyways (9.5): Probably the simplest in the contest, but one of my favorites. Simple, but effectively good.
Classical:
Noche Acosador (9.5): Slow burn for benefit? Almost as cruel as black gets! Not much to say about this one, but that's for the better.
Time to count the votes!
1. Black Hole Sun by @Kranbrat (based on Black Hole Sun by Soundgarden.) 15 points [geez!]
2. Back in Black by @stormbreath (based on Back in Black by AC/DC.) 10 points
3. Confrontation by @Corwinnn (based on Confrontation by Otep.) and Unusual by @Faiths_Guide (based on Unusual by Francesca Battistelli.) 9 points
4. This Shall Pass, which transforms into This Too Shall Pass by @Kranbrat (based on This Too Shall Pass by OK Go) 6 Points
5. Long Time by @poptabkid2 (Song unknown. Can someone tell me?) and Storm the Sorrow by @Grimshac (based on Storm the Sorrow by Epica.) 4 points
Honorable Mentions:
What's Left of the Flag by @tague84 (based on What's Left of the Flag by Flogging Molly.) 3 Points
Toxicity by @fabiocbinbutter (based on Toxicity by System of a Down.) 1 Point
Dani, the Flamehearted by @saveria201 (based on Daniel by Bat for Lashes) 1 Point
The Victor by @Faiths_Guide (based on The Victor by Keith Green.) 1 Point
Detroit Rock City by @poptabkid2 (based on Detroit Rock City by KISS.)
Waste of Hate by @ostewart (Song unknown. Can someone tell me?)
Turn to Glass by @saveria201 (based on Glass by Bat for Lashes)
Automatons Revolt by @kauyon (based on Metal Health by Quiet Riot.)
And I Dream by @Shadikal (based on Broken Dreams by Shaman's Harvest.)
Dreams of the Past by @FizzyGig (based on Eye of the Tiger by Survivor.)
Unquenched Vampire by @Corwinnn (based on Scott Pilgrim by Plumtree.)
1. Light in the Dark by @Suwako (Based on Fireflies by Owl City.) 14 Points (chosen by @Elektronikcraft)
2. Limitless Potential by @Lujikul (based on Gold by Imagine Dragons.) and Angel of the Skyways by @Corwinnn (based on Fall Into the Sky by ZEDD.) 14 Points
3. The Other by @fabiocbinbutter (based on The Other by Lauv.) 7 Points
Honorable Mentions:
Lunera Anisimov 5 Points
Mind Pop by @FunnyCardsAndStuff (based on Bangarang by Skrillex.) 3 Points
Shinobu, Heart Under Blade by @Shadikal (Based on Drums in the Night.) 1 Point
How To Be A Heartbreaker by @Suwako (based on How to be a Heartbreaker by Marina and the Diamonds.)
Nonsense Speaker by @Red_Tower (based on Nonsense Speaker by Joydreamer.)
1. The Spirit Carries On by @Grimshac (based on The Spirit Carries On by Dream Theater.) 10 (Chosen as the winner for classical by Elektronikcraft)
2. Noche Acosador by @Corwinnn (based on Noche Acosador by John 5.) and Come to the Table by @Faiths_Guide (based on Come to the Table by Michael Card.) 10 Points
Honorable Mention:
Zhahvon, the Impervious by @Shadikal (based on What Can You See In Their Eyes by Shiro Sagisu.)
1. Black Hole Sun by @Kranbrat (based on Black Hole Sun by Soundgarden.)
2. Light in the Dark by @Suwako (Based on Fireflies by Owl City.)
3. The Spirit Carries On by @Grimshac (based on The Spirit Carries On by Dream Theater.)
My Favorite:
Limitless Potential by @Lujikul (based on Gold by Imagine Dragons.)
I would like this contest closed.