MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
The |STAR| Contest! (AKA: Power [and/or Toughness] is Equal to... Contest)
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/rhodrolth?list=user
Nice entry!
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/spell-snarer
Lifeforce Angel:
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/lifeforce-angel
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/rhodrolth-1 <---- NEW
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/faithful-soul-priest
And the market of my home-plane.
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/hidden-marketplace
and I hope to have judging complete by the end of the night! Good luck all!
Honorable Mentions:
@fraziel07's Shinegaurd Cavalry
Really neat card that seems balanced and flavorful, well done!
@M15CardMaker's Feylera, Wish Keeper
Could get out of hand, but seems reasonable for the mana cost. Would be a little hard to keep track of all the abilities it gains but would be a blast in commander.
@stongbelieves' Terendel, Rage Unbridled
Maybe it's just me, but double strike is Super Powerful and I feel that it needs extra caution. Like the look and flavor of the card it's just that nonbasics (especially in eternal formats) are so absurdly plentiful this guy could 1-shot in a lot of games after T6. Great card!
@Beeswax's Summer's Scion
My personal favorite entry. Would have taken first spot for sure as it's function/art/design are all wonderful. Issues with this card are really just rarity, common seems totally out-of-whack. It draws cards and can be run in any number in a deck. I could see Wizard printing this at rare even though (most of the time) it wouldn't be too huge. Also you left avoidable text bleeding into the border... Awesome card for sure, thanks so much for the entry!
@jabrewer79's Kel-Don Clan Intimidator
Seems a little too strong at uncommon 3CMC. Really neat card for sure. "Cowards can't block Warriors!"
@Ludos' Secreteel
Neat design, cool function, name is a little silly/cheesy for my taste but I dig the functionality for sure. Maybe a little weak under most circumstances?
@Animist's Deepwater Aberration
Not a huge fan of Gestate. But as always your design/layout/artwork all are top notch. Great reference for everyone!
@squee's Rhodrolth
Awesome card, thought it would actually grab a spot when I first saw it. Competition was a little too steep for this bad boy though. The reason it couldn't get into the top three is twofold: Name (fine but not great), also haste and shuffle function has been done (lightning Shrieker). Great card nonetheless!
3rd Herald of Miracles by @seaspray4TF3
Wonderful design! Love it, but it doesn't get a higher place because of blue delve cards. Run this alongside Treasure Cruise, Dig Through Time, or even Temporal Trespass (or all three) and this card could swing for 8 in the air on T3. Great job overall!
2nd Lifeforce Angel by @kltmtg29
Wonderful submission, "doubles your life total" without being unfair. Goes perfectly with past giant Angels and functions beautifully. @Animist and @Tomigon gave you favorites and you certainly deserved them! Can't be too abused as its 0 power is static. EDH here we come!
1st Baluf, Son of Mogis by @milanaarz
Dude, the first ever Demigod card I've ever liked. You knocked everything out of the park, flavor, art, functionality, the dual purpose activated ability, the name doesn't sound great out loud (IMO) but is also fine! Thanks for entering!
I've decided to favorite Honorables entries as well, winners each get one additional favorite! Thanks for your entries @Everyone!
@seaspray4TF3, @kltmtg29, & @milanaarz you guys can post one other card you want faved!
For the favorite, this guy wants a bit love I think : http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/scrap-soldier-6?list=user
a little late! I got distracted by the hockey game!
For my extra card I'll choose: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/draco-grimborn-1?list=user
Name a card?
@Corwinnn, close this thing! Then let's blow this joint!