MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
"Cardsmith2017" set challenge!
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
Hahaha! Thanks! I'll fix those parts and make it in my 2nd account. But if you have time to remake it yourself, you definitely should! It's a great card! I already have an art link:
http://darkcloud013.deviantart.com/art/Giant-Slime-419510610
.........Gelatinous Titan.....
"Ooze Giant"........ooooh the ideas! (@__@)
I've got this blue legendary from a while ago
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/rynn-master-of-heists-1?list=user
But I'm not 100% sure about the balance. Might need tweaking but I'm not sure without playtesting. Let me know what you think and I can remake with the artist's name.
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/fracturing-slice
Cool concept! But I think it lets you draw too many cards. Her evasion ability is so good. You can draw almost always draw two or more cards. And you don't need to worry about losing your creatures if you know you can draw that many cards.
If it was my card, new version would be:
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/rynn-master-of-heists-2
^Is wording ok? Even without "If...", it is already a good card I think.
Yeah, I think it probably does draw too many cards. I would like the number of cards drawn to be tied to the number of creatures that attacked though so I'll try to keep that theme and balance it from there. Coastal Piracy and Bident of Thassa are both 4cmc so maybe this would be better at 4 or 5cmc and then just give it skulk if it doesn't attack alone.
I think those are good idea:)
@Dracomancer343
Thanks for the card! But I'd like green legendary to be who's born in the forest. Sorry!
Also, maybe this works?
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/back-to-the-past-1?list=user
Cool card! Thanks so much!
I mean, can you include a link to that card in your comment?
for this,
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/nights-embodiment?list=user
and for your new one
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/back-to-the-past-1?list=user
I googled the artist you credited in your card, but I couldn't find it.
Here's a blue legendary creature, although he's probably massively under powered for what you're looking for: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/cacara-wavewalker?list=user
G/W destroy artifact and enchantment.
Destroy target artifact and its controller gains 2 life if {g} was spent to cast Pure and Simple. Destroy target enchantment and its controller gains 2 life if {w} was spent to cast it. (Do both if {g}{w} was spent.)
Simpler.
That works: changed.
On a related note, why is green before white in this context?
Blue legendary creature
Commodity. It isn't anything noticiable, but the double colors actually have an order when they appear together... If you search Gatherer for Selesnya cards (g/w), the mana symbols always have {g} before {w}. Some patterns, I guess. You don't need to follow them strictly if you don't want to, just putting it out there.
For example... Keeping WUBRG in our mind...
Blue and white together is WU. That's obvious, because it's in the WUBRG order...
Next we look at another color combo...
White and green... In WUBRG it's WG, but that's not how it is in MtG...
WU is in that order, because on the color circle on the back of every card, from White to Blue is one step.
White to Green is four steps, but Green to White is one step, and so the order is GW and not WG
Here is the two color break down
WU
WB
UB
UR
BR
BG
RG
RW
GW
GU
Hope that helps!
XD
Thanks for those cards!
Pure and Simple is neat, but I want a card that can destroy both artifact and enchantment in mono color deck. Yours can't destroy enchantment if it is played in mono green, and it can't destroy artifact if it is played in mono white.
Rising Tide Nakame feels like more of a Powerful Wizard, if it turns land into another land.
I think I'll wait for a bit more submissions. It doesn't mean your cards are bad. They just don't fit in the set.
_____
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/rupturing-force?list=user
-----
This is for 2 other contests:
13 and If you cast it, you deserve it.
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/cryptic-cadaver