MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Chandra
Since the new kaladash block is coming, i want everyone to make up a Chandra and post it. I will pick the top Three Chandra related cards, who will be the winners. equipments, artifacts, and other cards can be entered and can win.
prizes is 3 likes of choice and follow for first
2 likes of choice for second
1 for third
you can make up to 5 cards and edit them all you want.
prizes is 3 likes of choice and follow for first
2 likes of choice for second
1 for third
you can make up to 5 cards and edit them all you want.
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Tried to make it as red as i could.
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/chandra-incandescent-1
my card http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/chandra-of-the-phoenix?list=user
Living Memory: (You may exile this card and a number of other cards from your graveyard equal to this card's converted mana cost. If you do, copy it and cast the copy without paying its mana cost.)
1. I believe the current wording is "Create a 3/3 red Phoenix creature token with flying"
2. Since you can only use Loyalty abilities on your main phase, the Phoenix can't enter "tapped and attacking". I think the only way to make that work the way you want it to work would be to say "Create a 3/3 red Phoenix creature token with flying and haste. It attacks this turn if able."
3. +X can just be +50182466198659871892639879861986896 unless you say that the land sacrificing is part of the cost. If it just states "+X: Sacrifice X lands (etc.)", then, say you have 7 lands from playing Chandra, you sacrifice those and then find no more to sacrifice, so it ignores the ability.
4. It would need to say: "+X: As an additional cost to activate this ability, sacrifice X lands: Destroy X TARGET permanents."
5. PLEASE promise me that you will never ever put the word Permants on a magic card. Ever again. Ever. I will not Permant you. Sorry, permit. Argh.
6. WHY
7. "You get an Emblem with:" is the correct wording.
8. "Creatures you have every ability." What. So, lets see, Wait, so creatures you have... Every ability. Wat. wait, its the other way around. Creatures you... Have every ability. Creatures you what? Control? Own? Like to lick when you're bored? WAAAAAAAAT.
9. Any ability you want them to have. OK, now I want it to have "At any time, if you want to, you win the game and the next 50182466198659871892639879861986896 games after this one." Yay I win. 50182466198659871892639879861986896 times.
10. WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT. I am now going to design this card with correct wording. Here I go, oh woe be me.
Chandra of the Phoenix 4RRR
Planeswalker --- Chandra
Starting Loyalty: 5
+1: Create a 3/3 red Phoenix creature token with flying and haste. It attacks this turn if able. At the end of combat this turn, if that creature didn't attack this turn, tap it.
+X: As an additional cost to activate this ability, sacrifice X lands. Destroy X target permanents.
-20: You get an Emblem with: "Creatures you control have Menace if you want creatures you control to have Menace. The same is true for every other ability on cards outside the game, cards you own, cards you don't own, and cards that don't exist yet. If an ability on one of those creatures has a value, that value is 3."
I will now go drown myself. Meow.
1. "It is actually meant to be create a 3/3 red Pheonix creature token with Flying tapped and attacking." As compared to previous cards with the same ability, only with different wording. Since you realized that too, I would suggest "During your next combat step, create a 3/3 red Pheonix creature token with Flying, tapped and attacking." Also, this is pretty OP, but not too bad. It's like a "must attack" Elspeth.
2. Sacrifice X lands to destroy X permanents? You don't even need lands anymore with Chandra!!! You can just sacrifice all 6 lands, destroy 6 creatures/lands your opponent controls and then just save up for -20. However this will only work against decks with fat creatures, and -20 is still too hard to save up.
3. You still can't do that!!! You never specified what kind of ability!!! Make it "You get an emblem with, creatures you control gain flying, deathtouch, double strike, haste, hexproof, indestructible, lifelink, menace, reach, skulk, trample, and vigilance..."
4. Crop the art better!!!
Now I too will go drown myself.
and you did the wording wrong
It should say "At the beginning of the next declare attackers step, create a 3/3 phoenix creature token with flying tapped and attacking.
Also, It is very red.
How is +1 deal 2 damage to a creature and 2 damage to you not red?
http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=221174
Living Memory is alternate flashback. If you didn't notice, red cards can have flashback too.http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=368518
And copying instants and sorceries. Seriously. Are you serious?
http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=197891
it shouldn't deal damage to you on the +1. ITS A PLANESWALKER!!!!!!!!
living memory is different then flashback. change it to flashback and i would be OK with it.
@Mysterious_Gangsta