MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Callous' Card Feedback (aka I Will Give Feedback)
Hey.
I will give feedback for your cards. Just link it in a response to this thread.
I've played magic since 2001, been an active part of custom communities since I first found one. I give no guarantee that my feedback is great, but I will help those that ask and then they can decide if the feedback was useful or not.
I'm a competitively minded player, and will rate cards thusly. I do not sugarcoat things - I'm very straightforward and I will say my honest opinion on things, so be prepared for negative feedback as well as positive.
And remember, nothing I say is meant to be hard facts with no potential to be wrong, it's merely how I see it.
I have but a few rules.
One card per response.
There must be 2 other responses between each one of yours.
I will give feedback for your cards. Just link it in a response to this thread.
I've played magic since 2001, been an active part of custom communities since I first found one. I give no guarantee that my feedback is great, but I will help those that ask and then they can decide if the feedback was useful or not.
I'm a competitively minded player, and will rate cards thusly. I do not sugarcoat things - I'm very straightforward and I will say my honest opinion on things, so be prepared for negative feedback as well as positive.
And remember, nothing I say is meant to be hard facts with no potential to be wrong, it's merely how I see it.
I have but a few rules.
One card per response.
There must be 2 other responses between each one of yours.
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/chinkol-the-dark-necromancer?list=user#.VP5U-PmUd8E
Thanks
I commented. Feel free to discuss my points with me, here or on the cards.
I liked your review of the last card as it was in depth and helpful. I was wondering what your thoughts are on this card?
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/paynes-priest?list=user#.VP77jBxp6RI
Well said
Please don't advertise your challenges here, it's needless clutter.
Please and Thank you.
Feel free to bypass my "rules" for now, I thought there would be more responses. Though keep it to one card per response, but feel free to make a new response as soon as I have commented on the most recent one - Helps me keep things catalogued.
I usually frequent MtGsalvation/RedditcustomMtg and a few other (lesser known) places and people literally rain cards on threads of this kind like a monsoon - I guess this forum is still rather young.
I'm not sure if it's good, bad, OP, UP?
Done. Not UP, not OP. Not good, nor bad. Average?
I'm more interested in what you have to say about Focus than the rest of the card, because without focus, it's more of a vanilla creature that might fill the bill in a draft, as a 2/3 for two and one blue.
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/knight-of-new-dawn?list=user#.VQGluBxp6RI
Still; can you have a look at this?
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/commander-chavez?list=user
You're welcome.
And since no one else is biting on this, how about thoughts on...
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/nina-dangelo-fate-changer?list=user#.VQRAwBxp6RI
I was a bit surprised myself, was expected to be flooded - Maybe people just havn't found the forum yet?
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/kirax-final-reaver?list=user#.VQSHyfCYbIU
Responded and explained. Let me know what you think.
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/alecto-master-vivisectivist-3?list=user#.VQSsoWTF8qo
Thank you in advance, by the way!
There's nothing you comment?