No.1 Cardsmith Challenge 2

Comments

• Butters

  October 2016

  @TrippleBoggey3 Either way. It is going to help with my decision as well which is the main purpose of it all. They will have 48hrs to have their responses into me otherwise I will post the results without their opinion. It is as simple as that.
• TastyCheez

  October 2016 edited October 2016

  Third Entry
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/scholar-of-the-forbidden-arts?list=user
  Transforms into
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/mother-of-the-dead.
  
  
  
  (Third Entry) Not final, I may replace or edit some entries.
• strongbelieves

  October 2016 edited October 2016

  
• Arceus8523

  October 2016

  Round 2 FIGHT!
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/tyrants-blow?list=user
  into
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/restless-avenger?list=user
  --
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/bountiful-vineyard?list=user
  into
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/grotesque-symbiote?list=user
  ---
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/unexpected-surge?list=user
  into
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/territorial-behemoth?list=user
• Corwinnn

  October 2016

  UPDATED LIST
  
  Entered:
  Corwinnn, TastyCheez, Mila, TheFriendlyGeek, thenightbringer, IanLowenthal, VinylVantasy, MaverickGV, Tommia, KimJongMartin, Faiths_Guide, strongbelieves, Tutlaschk, dashdo101, kltmtg29, Lujikul, littledemon, Gelectrode, TrippleBoggey3, Arceus8523 & UndeadZombie22
  
  Not Entered:
  @Feyamius, @TurkeyAsylum, @SalokinTheAllSeeing, @Nicholas_Bolas, @Beeswax, @gterww123, @LevelSeven.
• TrippleBoggey3

  October 2016

  I pray @Beeswax won't join.
  xD
• Butters

  October 2016

  At this point in time, those on that list are the ones being DQ from this round. However, if one of those cardsmiths enter, i will have to pick the worse card for this round and they will be joining them. DO NOT RISK BEING DQ and enter all 3 entries available to you guys.
• Corwinnn

  October 2016

  I really hope @Beeswax does, just because most of his cards are amazing! (he and @Teacup are secretly two of my favorite Cardsmiths)
• TrippleBoggey3

  October 2016 edited October 2016

  
• TrippleBoggey3

  October 2016

  Last entry comes tonight!
• MaverickGV

  October 2016

  @TrippleBoggey You'll never be able to use the flip side's ETB
• KJMartin

  October 2016 edited October 2016

  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/advocate-of-marchesa?list=user
  
  --TO--
  
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/slayers-of-marchesa-1
  
  I went with a vastly different approach: a conspiracy approach. The idea is that the Advocate has been supporting Marchesa al the rime and then, as she rises to power, they become her most trusted guards, and make sure no-one can take the throne off her.
• strongbelieves

  October 2016 edited October 2016

  
• TastyCheez

  October 2016

  @strongbelieves I don't see how "Enchanted creature is a 5/5 Avatar creature in addition to its other types" really works, it should be written that it has base power and toughness 5/5 and is an Avatar in addition to its other types.
  
• Faiths_Guide

  October 2016 edited October 2016

  @TastyCheez
  I left @strongbelieves a little comment on the Legendary side earlier.
• TastyCheez

  October 2016

  @strongbelieves ???
  
• Butters

  October 2016

  3 (or 2 depending on time zone) days remaining. Remember, if you have not entered any cards, you will be automatically DQ.
• Mobin

  October 2016

  Wait was I DQed? Lol I thought I made it.
• Butters

  October 2016

  @Mobin Sorry mate. Missed your entry on the last contest. Try and get a card together in the next couple of days to make sure you don't get DQ'd this round.
• TrippleBoggey3

  October 2016 edited October 2016

  
• Corwinnn

  October 2016

  UPDATED LIST
  
  Entered:
  Corwinnn, TastyCheez, Mila, TheFriendlyGeek, thenightbringer, IanLowenthal, VinylVantasy, MaverickGV, Tommia, KimJongMartin, Faiths_Guide, strongbelieves, Tutlaschk, dashdo101, kltmtg29, Lujikul, littledemon, Gelectrode, TrippleBoggey3, Arceus8523 & UndeadZombie22
  
  Not Entered:
  @Feyamius, @TurkeyAsylum, @SalokinTheAllSeeing, @Nicholas_Bolas, @Beeswax, @gterww123, @LevelSeven. @Mobin
• Mobin

  October 2016

  Thank you! @Butters
• JAM

  October 2016

  Will we be posting our opinions here, @Butters, or will we have a chat opened?
• Butters

  October 2016

  @JAM. if each of you can just individually message me, that will be easiest and less bias.
• Butters

  October 2016 edited October 2016

  @Feyamius, @TurkeyAsylum, @SalokinTheAllSeeing, @Nicholas_Bolas, @Beeswax, @Mobin, @gterww123, @LevelSeven. By my clock, YOU ALL HAVE LESS THEN 10HRS TO HAVE A CARD ENTERED. Please message me if you still plan to enter.
• Feyamius

  October 2016

  @Butters
  I'm at CET, I'll have to see if I can make a card tomorrow morning (in my time zone). Maybe it will be a few hours late.
• Corwinnn

  October 2016

  I'm totally good with waiting for Feyamius to make his card!
• Butters

  October 2016

  @Feyamius. I will give you until 9pm EST so that is another 24hrs to get one card done.
• Butters

  October 2016

  @Feyamius. I have to be strict with my rules and unfortunately I can no longer accept your entry. The cardsmiths being eliminated this round are:
  @Feyamius, @TurkeyAsylum, @SalokinTheAllSeeing, @Nicholas_Bolas, @Beeswax, @Mobin, @gterww123, @LevelSeven. All these cardsmiths were DQ on the decision of no entry.
  Top 3 Cards
  @VinylVantasy with Fluvirst Grove
  @Mila with Potent Conjurer
  @Corwinn with Murielle, Saving Grace
  
  Bottom 3 Cards
  @TrippleBoggey3 with Corwinnn, Sacrificial Warriors
  @Tutlaschk with Lost Kid. I loved this card on a comedy level but yea, not the right card for this comp.
  @kltmtg29 with Struggling Host.
  
  Your next competition will be posted in the next 3 days.
  
  Thanks all and congrats to those who have made it through. Starting to get down to the business end of things.
• KJMartin

  October 2016

  [Breathes out] I can finally relax now. Good...