No.1 Cardsmith Challenge 3

Comments

• TastyCheez

  November 2016

  @TrippleBoggey3 I understand what Butters meant, he just didn't convey it strongly enough for us to understand. The contest is realistic enough to my understanding, it is just explained poorly.
• TrippleBoggey3

  November 2016

  @TastyCheez, No it's not that. It's that single card based things, like cards made specifically to support another card are very rare and rarely used.
• Lujikul

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  Here is my first entry.
  
  
  Not associated with a particular planeswalker. Just a general esper support card for planeswalkers.
• kltmtg29

  November 2016

  @Butters Does it have to be a planeswalker we have make or can it work with a real mtg planeswalker?
• IanLowenthal

  November 2016

  Planeswalker (By Wizards):
  
  
  My entry:
  
• strongbelieves

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  @TrippleBoggey3 The contest isn't unrealistic. Like I said, WotC just came out with cards that have abilities which only do anything if another specific named card is on the battlefield, specifically Verdant Crescendo and Liberating Combustion. This makes the cards literally useless. The other cards that are still horrible but not quite as horrible are Renegade Firebrand and Guardian of the Great Conduit which are limited to having a Chandra or Nissa planeswalker of any kind and not the specific named ones. Still awful.
  
  Basically, the only cards that can be made for this contest are explicitly bad cards you would never want to play in any format.
• IanLowenthal

  November 2016

  My planeswalker (Wizards):
  
  
  My entry:
  
• IanLowenthal

  November 2016

  My planeswalker (Wizards):
  
  
  My entry:
  
• KJMartin

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  Hello human beings.
• KJMartin

  November 2016

  Can't we just make a card that supports planeswalkers anyway, not just a certain planeswalker?
• TastyCheez

  November 2016

  I don't mind this contest actually, it forces people to think of cards in a different concept than usual comps. It challenges our understanding on how to word the cards, and this isn't me trying to suck up to Butters but c'mon guys this is a contest and if you don't like the rules then bugger off - gives me a better chance at winning anyway. This is Butters' contest and its up to him to make the rules however unordinary they may be. He has explained the rules of the contest and if you still don't understand then message him about it.
• TastyCheez

  November 2016

  Maybe he could have written it as "non-planeswalker permanents that target specific planeswalkers you control"? That way we could have made stuff kinda liked"Oath of Chandra, Jace, Liliana, etc.
• Tutlaschk

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  @KimJongMartin @StrongBelieves How about seeing it as a challenge to make a good card? In my opinion your behavior is not fair to @Butters and his effort.
• Butters

  November 2016

  @TastyCheez yes
  @TrippleBoggey3 and @strongbelieves. That is up to you guys. The idea of this contest was to test ALL aspects of mtg not just the popular areas. If you choose not to enter, it just makes me job easier when it comes to DQing people.
• Butters

  November 2016

  @kltmtg29 totally up to you dude. You can make a custom and make a supporting instant or sorcery or you can just make a card that supports an existing planeswalker. Just make sure you atleast attach the link to your entries.
• kltmtg29

  November 2016

  @Butters got it.
• Tutlaschk

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  Planeswalker______________Spell_____________________
  
  
  Planeswalker______________Spell_____________________
  
  
  Planeswalker______________Spell_____________________
  
  
  Hope you like them!
  
  *Note: The radiation counters are explained in the comments of Decyna!
  
• TrippleBoggey3

  November 2016

  No, @Butters, that's not what I meant. I'm just saying that the contest is a bit unrealistic. I'm not saying it's bad. I'm perfectly fine with it. Don't get me wrong.
• TheFriendlyGeek

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  Entry 1:
  
  
  
• TrippleBoggey3

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  
• Tommia

  November 2016

  @Butters Expect to see my entry soon. Need to do a photo shoot and edit the photos in order to get my art.
• Gelectrode

  November 2016

  First entry! There is a lot of reminder text that I wanted to fit on, but I think it works.
  
  http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=389612
  
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/nahiris-innovation
• KJMartin

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  
• IanLowenthal

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  Hey, @KimJongMartin You know that a player can only control one Jace planeswalker at a time?
• Corwinnn

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  Liliana Vess
  
  
  
  
  
  
• KJMartin

  November 2016

  @IanLowenthal
  
  Of course.
• TastyCheez

  November 2016

  @Butters Just to confirm, I've changed my submissions on the first page. They are still valid, yes?
• TheFriendlyGeek

  November 2016

  Entry #2
  
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/user/TheFriendlyGeek/sets/15358
  
  
• Corwinnn

  November 2016 edited November 2016

  Entered -
  TastyCheez, MaverickGV, dashdo101, Lujikul, IanLowenthal, thenightbringer, Tutlaschk, KimJongMartin, Corwinnn, TheFriendlyGeek, Gelectrode, TrippleBoggey3, Arceus8523
  NOT Entered -
  @UndeadZombie22 @littledemon @Tommia @Faiths_Guide @kltmtg29 @VinylVantasy @Mila @strongbelieves
• kltmtg29

  November 2016

  @Corwinnn Don't worry I'm going to enter, just been super busy recently.